Death's Diner -Game Over-

[StubbsKVM]

What about the other 2? Are you basing this on your own reads?

[ArcAngel9]

V/LA till Monday

[Slandaar]

Obviously it is based on reads yes. Rofl is obvtown and Ghost Penguin is town based on penguin meta.

[StubbsKVM]

UNVOTE:

I'll wait until one of the others backs this up. You never know

I'm assuming none of you know what kind of cop you are? 4 cops is a quite a lot in this setup.

[TiphaineDeath]

1 scum in

Rofl
Slandaar
MS
Bro
Ghostly

19 player game means likely 3 scum left assuming same team in-
Rift Adrift
StubbsKVM
Xiao Long
Baezu
Titus
EddieFenix
Aunt Jemina
ArcAngel9
TiphaineDeath
PeregrineV
oriole
elvis_knits
Amrun
Zoidberg

Removing, to my eyes, obvtown, leaves.
StubbsKVM
Baezu
EddieFenix
ArcAngel9
PeregrineV
elvis_knits
Zoidberg

Assuming I am imperfect and one of the people I have quoted as obv town is actually well playing scum, that means there are still two scum in the above list.

They're probably Zoidberg and PV.

I'm not sure how yet, but this list will matter later.

Now let's get a second smaller list going
Slandaar
Bro
Ms
Rofl
Ghostly

I'm happy to remove Ghostly and slandaar from this list, and I will trust slandaars info to remove ms from this list, however scummy I see him as.

Bro
Rofl

PV-Rofl-Zoidberg-X This-List-Makes-Sense

I still do not think bro is scum, I guess rofl can be scum without lurking, I rest my case.

[Titus]

Can one of my games just have players be sane?

What happens if Bro flips town Slandaar?

[4nxi3ty]

roflcopter (1) - ArcAngel9
Zoidberg (2) - Titus, TiphaineDeath
Baezu

(6)

- Aunt Jemina, Metal Sonic, oriole, BROseidon, Rift Adrift, Amrun
TiphaineDeath (1) - EddieFenix
Metal Sonic (1) - elvis_knits
elvis_knits (3) - Baezu, Ghostly Penguin, PeregrineV
Aunt Jemina (1) - Xiao Long
BROseidon (3) - Zoidberg, roflcopter, Slandaar

Not Voting (1) - StubbsKVM

With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.
(expired on 2013-08-09 10:28:34)

[BROseidon]

Slandaar is honest. That was the shit I was crumbing.

Mathematically it makes more sense to lynch outside the group than inside it for everyone if there are 5 or more scum, and if there are 4 it only makes more sense for the people within the 5 to want to lynch within the 5. If there are only 3 or 2 scum this game is designed horribly.

Math is hard, let's go shopping >:C

[StubbsKVM]

Bro, who do you think is scum out of the other 4

[TiphaineDeath]

That's great to know and all.... but can we lynch zoidberg now?

[TiphaineDeath]

Yeah ok, stubbs can be town.

[TiphaineDeath]

I'm thinking Amrun might be my misfile.

PV-Zoidberg-Rofl-Amrun?

That sounds like a scumteam to me.

[BROseidon]

[quote="In post 1558, StubbsKVM"][/quote]

My guess is rofl right now, but it'll sort itself out.

[TiphaineDeath]

@mod, wtf is that last votecount. What happened to my beautiful zoidberg wagon?

[Titus]

Umm how OP is the town right now?

We have 5 cops, 2 players knowing each other, and my role, that's at least 7 confirmed town if Slandaar is right. That smells waay too easy.

[BROseidon]

I'm thinking Amrun might be my misfile.

PV-Zoidberg-Rofl-Amrun?

That sounds like a scumteam to me.

I really liked the way Amrun responded to my crumb, though. Last time I pulled off the same play the scumteam (minus the traitor who had no idea what I was doing) skirted the issue and tried not to engage with the crumb directly, although there was a bit of a different context involving the role wonkiness. Syryana can comment on it because he was scum in that game.

[TiphaineDeath]

Titus, read better, 4 cops, 3 of which are probably some degree of ineffective and the fourth of which may not know his own effectiveness. I was in a setup like that once, it was hell.

[BROseidon]

Titus, 4 cops of unknown sanities (ie, one is paranoid and one is naive, which are functionally useless), as scum (sans an SK or multiball shenanigans) start out the game either with one of them knowing who the 4 are or, more likely because having pregame chat is standard, they already know who the cops are.

pedit: An insane cop is just as useful as a sane cop once he knows his sanity.

[4nxi3ty]

@mod, wtf is that last votecount. What happened to my beautiful zoidberg wagon?

hmm I must've mixed up an older votecount. Well it's fixed now. Let me know if there are any other mistakes.

[Titus]

Tiphane, you should volunteer to be checked then. We lynch outside the cops, and then everyone will know the cop sanity.

I still like lynching outside the cops. If that means Baezu, so be it. I would rather have Zoidberg though.

[Rift Adrift]

yes

It was not completely clear of the alignment of the 5th person

he was known as the liar

, Sonic PM'ed the mod to ask if the liar is scum, MOD said yes, I confirmed this, for Sonic to do that as scum is quite... well I can't see him doing it.

I don't understand this bolded part. What does this mean? Is the 5th person BRO?

UNVOTE

[BROseidon]

Rift: He means that scum knows who he is in the group. It's functionally a side-game of Dethy.

And MS pming the mod to ask him isn't much town cred when the first thing I said in the QT was bitching about being in a side-game of Dethy because I hate Dethy.

[Zoidberg]

Good lord that's a lot of posts

Catching up.....

[StubbsKVM]

Do the cops know which sanity they are? I want Bro to answer this first actually.

[Zoidberg]

ZOIDBERG

I KNOW YOU'RE THERE

GET IN HERE

NOW

YOU TOO BRO

Chill. We have tons of time left before deadline. I'll hammer to prevent a no lynch but I still think Bro is a better wagon