Lord of The Rings Mafia - Game End

[alienBRO]

MuffinMan: What is the scum motivation in claiming a fake guilty? That's why I'm not questioning it.
-Bro

[Gollum]

Are you kidding us? There's plenty of scum motivation to claiming a fake guilty.

[alienBRO]

...So you get lynched the next day and are down to a single scum mate. That is a great trade. Obviously.

-Bro

[zMuffinMan]

I am considering the possibility this is a dumb gambit.

I want to make sense of this before subliminal is lynched.

[Empking]

Vote Count Fifty Three

Miss Subliminal (3) - goodmorning, alienBRO, Gollum
Amrun (1) - NSin
ToastyToast (1) - Amrun
NSin (1) - thezmon221

Not Voting: TwinFlames, Miss Subliminal, zMuffinMan, DeathNote, ToastyToast

Six to lynch
(expired on 2013-08-27 13:38:36)

[goodmorning]

How/why did goodmorning end up with the ring after Who's lynch?

idfk. Who was lynched, it went into night, and I was told I had received the ring. I don't know if it had anything to do with the lynch, but that's when I got the PM.

[DeathNote]

So... just pondering here... but whats to stop someone from just giving the ring away before they get lynched? If you can transfer the ring during the day just by PMing the mod secretly, then we would technically never get the ring by hammering.

Personally, I would just give it to who I thought was town if I was up for a lynch instead of letting whoever hammers me get it.

@Mod- Do you publicly announce when the ring has shifted owners? Also, can you give the ring away at any time? Is there a limit to the number of times it can be transferred in one day?

[Empking]

@Mod- Do you publicly announce when the ring has shifted owners? Also, can you give the ring away at any time? Is there a limit to the number of times it can be transferred in one day?

No. Only during the day. No.

[DeathNote]

Thank you mod.

Theoretically, goodmorning could have received the ring yesterday but it doesn't make sense why someone would give it to him unless it was Venrob or Who as they both were about to die.

Regardless, I don't see a reason to not believe goodmorning unless someone wants to counter claim that they have the ring.

vote: Subliminal

BTW- who is poisoned? This is important so goodmorning doesn't give you the ring and you die with it tonight.

[thezmon221]

Okay, that makes more sense. I thought someone said he received the ring as a result of the lynch.

However, why did he just get the ring at the lynch?

[thezmon221]

By the way, who are the hydras and who's playing in them?

I know Miss Sub is a hydra, but not who is playing them.
I think Gollum is a hydra?

[Amrun]

Mod: Is it theoretically possible to get informed you have the ring during the night phase?

This is not adding up.

[Empking]

Mod: Is it theoretically possible to get informed you have the ring during the night phase?

It is possible for one to be informed of having the ring while the thread is in night.

[thezmon221]

@Mod: Will they know of their possession of the ring the instance they receive the ring?

[Empking]

@Mod: Will they know of their possession of the ring the instance they receive the ring?

You do not know. (Unless its a question about my speed of action; that isn't instant.)

[Amrun]

Mod: Is it theoretically possible to get informed you have the ring during the night phase?

It is possible for one to be informed of having the ring while the thread is in night.

Can you list the situations in which this is possible, or at least the public ones we know about?

But all right, given this...

VOTE: subliminal

If this is a scumflip it's going to rip me a new one...

[thezmon221]

Guys, please lynch NSin. Robert's scum meta follows this to the period. Like, it's identical.

[DeathNote]

We are not lynching nsin when someone has claimed to have a guilty on subliminal.

[thezmon221]

See, the problem is how he ended up getting the ring.

Besides, you're scum too, so eat rope, DN.

[DeathNote]

You still have some catching up to do lol.

It doesn't matter how he got it. The point is that we have gauranteed scum between goodmorning and subliminal due to his claim.

[thezmon221]

Nope. I've read the last 15-20 pages. You're scum as far as I can tell.

[Empking]

Can you list the situations in which this is possible, or at least the public ones we know about?

Publicly known mechanics could mix with possible private mechanics to make my making such a list unfeasible.

[Gollum]

Guys, please lynch NSin. Robert's scum meta follows this to the period. Like, it's identical.

but sometimes younger players tend to RVS their buddies so its possible that Rob was RVSing his buddy sub. + both heads of sub have been lurking horribly. This is the days correct lynch.

[ToastyToast]

will vote sub after they get here and say something, in case of shenanigans.

[thezmon221]

Alright. I'll call intent to hammer if Toast doesn't do it.

Has Sub claimed, or is that needed?