Alright, so here goes:
First off, wow, what a mess of a game. The mechanic, the D1 shenanigans, the D2 inactivity, everything.
Bert
: Voted for Saki twice in a row. A bit confusing, that. Then, he buddies Mutley and joins the bauss wagon, without giving anything substantial. Later, he makes a couple of non-points against bauss, essentially saying "I don't like his style". On D2, he says people have said nothing yet and is waiting for them, whilst at the same time saying nothing himself. Afterwards, starts pressing Siv a bit and appears to be doing a small effort to scumhunt. Could be legit, but by this point it seems doubtful. Furthermore, bauss asks him to answer his own question about whom he'd lynch. He says gut points to Siv, but doesn't vote Siv. This makes no sense at all. Also, he asks people to make their votes, but makes no effort to get anyone to vote for either his "scumread" or his wagon.
Read:
Scum
. His scumhunting is minimal at best and insincere at worst.
Darger
: Few posts, but on the other hand the scumhunting seems far more genuine. Unfortunately, he disappeared for a while now, which is annoying, as I'd like to see more.
Read:
Null-town
. Would be further towards town, if not for the low number of posts.
Derivan/Frog
: 2 useless posts, followed by 0 useless posts. Nothing to go off of.
Read:
Null
.
Jennifer
: Another low activity person. A bit better than Derivan, a bit worse than Darger.
Read:
Null
.
bauss
: A bit disappointing that both the vig and the watcher went in one go... Moving on from that, his arguments seem well-reasoned and his scumhunting sincere. He also gets a few extra townpoints from the fact that Bert has kept his vote on him even after claiming to have found someone scummier (see above).
Read:
Town
.
bartlet
: Yet more inactivity. And someone else mentioned this before, but his two posts that contain anything of substance involve on one hand buddying mutley, by saying that his (somewhat faulty) logic seems good and on the other keeping a means of retreat ("I hope I am not being led astray" and all that) and asking people if they'd be cool with voting Mutley (note that he himself doesn't switch votes at this point).
Read:
Scum
.
Mutley
: All the missing thread activity is here. A bit too much, even. Led the wagon on Saki. Repeatedly makes illogical statements with an inordinate degree of self-assurance and little to no actual backing. On the other hand, Saki claimed scum and also fake-claimed fruit vendor, so the wagon can be excused. Also, he is scumhunting and doesn't seem to be faking it, providing most of the original content. Bert's and bartlet's buddying also give extra points here. I doubt that two scum would both buddy their 3rd partner so blatantly.
Read:
Town
Noctan
: Ineffectual and unhelpful. Something about cheese. Something about fruit. (Also, why exactly are you announcing to whom you'll be sending your fruit next? Even if it's a borderline useless power, it's something that's there. Why, as town, would you give scum info that you could withhold?)
Read:
Null
. Tempted to put him in the town pile, but would rather wait on this.
Saki
: Dead VT.
Sakura
: Dead Watcher (Town).
Tornado/TMTO
: Not much from Tornado. Questioned mutley a little before disappearing. TMTO opposes the bauss wagon and reads Mutley as town. Still, I'd have liked to see a vote from him at some point and a few more reads...
Read:
Null, leaning townish
.
Siv
: I've played a few games with him some time ago. Doesn't seem too different from those and he was town in those. Also, I'm really liking two of his three votes, what with them being on scum and everything.
Read:
Leaning town
.
Ryzza/Jason
: Dead VT. Didn't even say anything at any point. What the hell?
As far as I can tell, scumteam is Bert, bartlet and one of the more lurky folks. Bartlet has votes already, so he can go first, although I'd have preferred Bert, since he looks entirely more scummy.
Vote: bartlet
I urge the non-voters to make up their minds quickly. A no-lynch means that town has no control over who is eliminated (excluding vigs). Also, mutley and bauss, I urge you both to stop voting each other. 1) You both look pretty much town to me and 2) Your current votes aren't helping anything.
And now, it's bedtime for me. I apologise for the length of the post; it is inevitable when catching up. My subsequent posts should be much shorter.