Mini 1493: Lucky's <insert cool name here> game (GAME OVER)

[archaebob]

Likelihood that we have a watcher AND a tracker AND a cop?

[NicCage]

I need more time to think, but I think if I'm going to believe antihero, then that paints Wake as scum.
Which makes sense with all the "let's just lynch him" shit he's been pulling for a long time. Doesn't seem like a town mindset to me.

[aptil]

1 of the 3 is lying for sure,right?
UNVOTE: for now.

[theaceofspades]

UNVOTE: antihero

[SalmonellaDreams]

lol
VOTE: wake

[Wake1]

Oh boy.

If you Lynch the Town Tracker, that's completely on you.

And I have no problem lynching on of my five suspects.

Go ahead. Lynch one of your Town PRs. See what happens.

[archaebob]

@ Wake -

Between SD and Antihero who's lying.

[archaebob]

^ should be a "?"

[Antihero]

1 of the 3 is lying for sure,right?
UNVOTE: for now.

no

especially if i'm right about ninja/godfather combo. ninja alive means that watcher and tracker are pretty much useless (they actually could be a liability as they out PRs, as Wake already brought up). and godfather alive means my innocents are pretty much useless.

sorry I stunk up this game (drawing cop really makes me self conscious about my play; usually, i like to be close to the center of attention, but if i'm a cop, i feel compelled to stay in the background)

but the good news is, i can go back to being my loudmouth self

i'd be cool with a nacho, ABR, or banksys lynch

[Lady Lambdadelta]

1 of the 3 is lying for sure,right?
UNVOTE: for now.

no

especially if i'm right about ninja/godfather combo. ninja alive means that watcher and tracker are pretty much useless (they actually could be a liability as they out PRs, as Wake already brought up). and godfather alive means my innocents are pretty much useless.

sorry I stunk up this game (drawing cop really makes me self conscious about my play; usually, i like to be close to the center of attention, but if i'm a cop, i feel compelled to stay in the background)

but the good news is, i can go back to being my loudmouth self

i'd be cool with a nacho, ABR, or banksys lynch

If we're lynching any of the 3 claims, it's this one.

[theaceofspades]

I really don't think that ABR is scum. I just don't see it. Nacho's kinda null to me as well. banksys......i don't know.

what makes you so sure there's a ninja? Godfather I see with a cop and tracker, but i'm not so sure about a ninja. I mean its' a possibility IF there's a watcher but the existence of a watcher can't be used to prove the existence of the ninja that we need to prove the existence of a watcher.

[Antihero]

I really don't think that ABR is scum. I just don't see it. Nacho's kinda null to me as well. banksys......i don't know.

you don't? why not?

abr hasn't taken that active of a role this game. have you seen him really push his reads with conviction or just kind of sit back and let everything happen? while banksys herself isn't very scummy, she did replace into a scummy slot (the player may have changed, but the role didn't)

what makes you so sure there's a ninja? Godfather I see with a cop and tracker, but i'm not so sure about a ninja. I mean its' a possibility IF there's a watcher but the existence of a watcher can't be used to prove the existence of the ninja that we need to prove the existence of a watcher.

i'm assuming that lucky and whoever reviewed lucky's setup knows how to balance a game

[Antihero]

If we're lynching any of the 3 claims, it's this one.

you... are really going to hate me after this game...

i'm sorry...

[theaceofspades]

right but the ninja and watcher prove each other, which is to say that neither is really proven. If there's one there is the other. but who's to say that either one is here?

and bansky i agree. not scummy herself. but the slot was scummy. which is why i'm nervous about voting or not voting her she doesn't read scum, but her predecessor did.

my gut says ABR is town, what he's responded to and how he's done it have lead me to believe he's scum

[theaceofspades]

edit NOT scum

[Wake1]

@archaebob.about who to lynch

God that's a tough call.

[Antihero]

right but the ninja and watcher prove each other, which is to say that neither is really proven. If there's one there is the other. but who's to say that either one is here?

and bansky i agree. not scummy herself. but the slot was scummy. which is why i'm nervous about voting or not voting her she doesn't read scum, but her predecessor did.

my gut says ABR is town, what he's responded to and how he's done it have lead me to believe he's scum

Is SD's claim really still in question?

what kind of scumbag suspects the claimed tracker all along and then claims out of the blue to neatly explain said suspicion?

[archaebob]

I need expert opinions on the setup. Albert? Nacho? LL?

Do we know that one of the claimed investigators is scum?

[Nachomamma8]

I believe Anti-Hero's claim.

Why?

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I need expert opinions on the setup. Albert? Nacho? LL?

Do we know that one of the claimed investigators is scum?

No, we don't. And even if we can make that assumption, it's not worth lynching inside them.

Because what happens if we lynch a town power role? Scum can either kill the other one tonight OR kill someone else and make us wonder whether we should lynch between the two remaining claims.

And let's even say one of them is lying and we lynch that person correctly Day 2 after missing day 1. The scum still have knowledge of our power roles and can roleblock and/or kill them whenever they please.

No, it's better in this situation to put the onst of killing our power roles in the hands of scum. Force them to make the choice and guarantee us some kind of result, hopefully.

[Nachomamma8]

antihero is a liar, but i suppose we don't have to deal with that today.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

antihero is a liar, but i suppose we don't have to deal with that today.

I'm fully aware of where you're coming from and what you're seeing. I see it.

But it's not the play today. The play today is Banksys.

[Nachomamma8]

@ Al -

What are you thoughts on ace?

I'm able to follow his line of thinking so far; it makes sense. Scum usually don't change their minds as easily as town in my experience.

So you agree with ace's thought that Wake should have been lynched for bad play (i.e. policy lynched)?

Wake's claim should have been counterclaimed pretty much immediately when Antihero saw it. THIS is his first response to the claim.
Compare to Sal's response, which was "need to think" and then starting to push him again after a short period again.

[Nachomamma8]

antihero is a liar, but i suppose we don't have to deal with that today.

I'm fully aware of where you're coming from and what you're seeing. I see it.

But it's not the play today. The play today is Banksys.

we won't lynch antihero today, but I'm not sold on Banksys.

[Nachomamma8]

Here's where I'd rather start for now:

Vote: ArcAngel9

Bob, you should adore this vote. Join me on it.