In post 969, Amrun wrote:White knighting can be a scum tell, situationally. But sometimes, people are just town and is town's job to protect other town. Sometimes, in order to do that, town white knights. It's town's job to look at it and determine if it comes from town or scum motivation.
Just like everyone who coincidentally attacks someone who happens to be attacking scum isn't chainsawing, calling someone town isn't white knighting.
That is really poor scumhunting and I think you are in that stage where you have learned the words and you want to use them. If I didn't think you were town for other reasons, I would say you were scummy for looking for flaws in posting to attack rather than motivation, but alas.
P-edit: NO YOU CAN'T MAKE ME :3
White knighting
is
scum specific, just like chainsaw defending
is
scum specific. If town is defending someone else, then it is neither, although it may look similar. Chainsaw defending is scum attacking town who is attacking their scumbuddy. White Knighting is scum attacking town who's attacking town in order to gain towncred after the attackee flips. I know what I mean when I use these phrases, because I've seen instances of both. In fact, I've caught scum chainsaw defending, and I've successfully white knighted. It's interesting that your course of action is to try to discredit me, instead of arguing against the idea that you white knighted. You're not saying "I did not white knight.", instead saying "White knighting is not a scum tell." and "You cannot prove I did that.". This sounds more like scum having been caught and trying to wriggle their way out of the situation, rather than town who thinks that they are being called scum for stupid reasons.
Bulbazak is so town that everytime someone votes him Mastin coughs blood.
In post 959, Bulbazak wrote:Here's my point. They both seem to be doing the same things, but I don't think both of them are scum. One is genuine. The other is not. So if you had to put your money on who was scum and who was town, which one would you pick and why?
If one of us was scum then it's definitely who cuz I'm town.
However amrun seems scummy too. I'll sheep bulb
VOTE: amrun
Why does Amrun seem scummy? Why are you blindly sheeping me?
Bulbazak is so town that everytime someone votes him Mastin coughs blood.
In post 969, Amrun wrote:White knighting can be a scum tell, situationally. But sometimes, people are just town and is town's job to protect other town. Sometimes, in order to do that, town white knights. It's town's job to look at it and determine if it comes from town or scum motivation.
Just like everyone who coincidentally attacks someone who happens to be attacking scum isn't chainsawing, calling someone town isn't white knighting.
That is really poor scumhunting and I think you are in that stage where you have learned the words and you want to use them. If I didn't think you were town for other reasons, I would say you were scummy for looking for flaws in posting to attack rather than motivation, but alas.
P-edit: NO YOU CAN'T MAKE ME :3
White knighting
is
scum specific, just like chainsaw defending
is
scum specific.
If town is defending someone else, then it is neither, although it may look similar.
Chainsaw defending is scum attacking town who is attacking their scumbuddy. White Knighting is scum attacking town who's attacking town in order to gain towncred after the attackee flips. I know what I mean when I use these phrases, because I've seen instances of both. In fact, I've caught scum chainsaw defending, and I've successfully white knighted. It's interesting that your course of action is to try to discredit me, instead of arguing against the idea that you white knighted. You're not saying "I did not white knight.", instead saying "White knighting is not a scum tell." and "You cannot prove I did that.". This sounds more like scum having been caught and trying to wriggle their way out of the situation, rather than town who thinks that they are being called scum for stupid reasons.
They do look similar. If Amrun was whiteknighting by your definitiion, then you think she was attacking Voided?
In post 975, Bulbazak wrote:Why? This is important. And the last person who argued with me like this was scum (Granted, I was on his team, but still.).
It doesn't look important to me. More like you two are getting into a slapfight or something.
Because I'm beginning to think that I've got a few too many townreads and I need to work through which ones I'm PoE-ing. Considering that Morph is currently supertown until proven otherwise and is effectively with you and sakura/gm in the town list, I don't need to worry about a flashwagon onto them at the moment and just need to work out who between amrun/baezu/who is the two scum.
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
In post 979, morph the cat wrote:They do look similar. If Amrun was whiteknighting by your definitiion, then you think she was attacking Voided?
What is this referring to?
"They do look similar" was to the part of bulba's post that I emboldened. The rest was asking how he'd apply his defiiniton of WKing to Amrun's defense of DP.
In post 959, Bulbazak wrote:Here's my point. They both seem to be doing the same things, but I don't think both of them are scum. One is genuine. The other is not. So if you had to put your money on who was scum and who was town, which one would you pick and why?
If one of us was scum then it's definitely who cuz I'm town.
However amrun seems scummy too. I'll sheep bulb
VOTE: amrun
Why does Amrun seem scummy? Why are you blindly sheeping me?
I think the way she's been acting this game is not like her usual town self so for me the lynch pool is between who and amrun. Since there seems to be more support for an amrun lynch I'm voting her.
“Baezu’s my top town. If she's scum I'll eat Alchemist's hat.” (Something I never thought I’d hear in any game. Ever.) -RCEnigma in EICN
“Baezu tier: Baezu” (Oooo I get my own tier!!!) -Vorkuta
In post 987, Baezu wrote:I think the way she's been acting this game is not like her usual town self so for me the lynch pool is between who and amrun. Since there seems to be more support for an amrun lynch I'm voting her.
Why not me?
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
Have we played before? Your play in this game hasn't raised any flags to me. It's been consistent and at worst you are null but I'm leaning town on you
“Baezu’s my top town. If she's scum I'll eat Alchemist's hat.” (Something I never thought I’d hear in any game. Ever.) -RCEnigma in EICN
“Baezu tier: Baezu” (Oooo I get my own tier!!!) -Vorkuta
In post 989, Baezu wrote:Have we played before? Your play in this game hasn't raised any flags to me. It's been consistent and at worst you are null but I'm leaning town on you
No, we haven't played before. I'm just wondering why you excluded me. After all, if one of those two are wrong, then that would mean that it's a me/whoever is left scumteam to you, right?
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
Bulba, it sounds like you feel that one of Amrun/Who are scum and it's more likely to be Amrun because of the WKing. Correct? Who is your other pick for scum?
