In post 224, Skelda wrote:Okay let's do this...
BA- He gives a lot of town reads. I usually don't like that, since hunting town doesn't really help us all that much. And I don't mind his read on mneumonic, he seems like he had a gut feeling supported by evidence and stuck to it and that is always good. Although sometimes his evidence can be a little weak, like in
114, I'm classifying him as a solid leaning town read.
Gramr- I wasn't crazy about the way he jumped around to Peace early on, but I suppose most of us did. That seemed a little caught up in the moment, but maybe scummy. But overall, I find him very town. I especially like his case against mnemonic in
124 and
203. He actually changed the way I thought about mnemonic, and I think that's a good thing since I'm not exactly renowned for my Day 1 scumhunting abilities.
Honig- Well, he seems to be invested in this game in a way that I don't often see scum invested. His
211 seems very genuine, and in general I find myself agreeing with most of what he says. At the same time, his posts are very wall-of-texty, and that sometimes makes them a bit difficult to get through, but his dislike of rolling the dice with peace seems very town to me.
mozamis- He is being really fluffy right now. Getting on my nerves, honestly. His
218 is especially bad with his "I'd forgotten he was scum", since I can't imagine his read was ever that serious to begin with if he forgot about it.
155 is also bad, since "forgetting to put someone on your reads list" is, in my mind, not a legitimate reason to suspect them. It is like forging evidence or something. Not good.
Shane- His
75 was basically jumping on moz's reads, and pretty much useless. And other than that, he is just a lack of information for the town. His one comment came from
163, when the best he could come up with was a tip about pressuring directed at me. Kind of ridiculous, he has given us nothing.
Matt- I don't like how he voted Moz and then unvoted the instant he was pressed. That isn't good. I also didn't like that all of his reads were town ones in
180. Leaning scum.
JKLM- Looking back, I'm not entirely liking how he put me in a box early on saying "this is your scummy", "this isn't your scummy". That never appeals to me. But, he does seem to genuinely be trying to get reactions and participating, so that is good. Null/town.
Hermy- Well, I don't like how quick she was to call me out for lurking in
214, since she hasn't exactly been helpful herself, and I try to post whenever I can. But Null...
Mnemonicdevice- His Unvote in
106 was strange. And the fact that he is refusing to vote seems to be the biggest evidence against him. I also really dislike his
141 where he says that he is always vague day 1, since scum need to actively think about how they always are and act like it. I think he's scum.
smargaret- I think he's very town. His
193 was interesting for me. I don't view Honig as scum, but it does seem like his suspicions are valid, if that makes any sense.
I think that's everyone. If I missed anyone let me know and I'll throw something together.
