Open 533: Pick Your Poison - The End

[notscience]

You've literally just proven my point.

You continued the vote as an attempt to be like "ha only town would joke in RVS so I must be town!"

[Kalimar]

Vote Count 1.1

(3)

YellowKingValley

: 1baldeagle1, beastcharizard, Venrob
(3)

NicCage

: Egg, Hermy, Banakai
(2)

Banakai

: NicCage, notscience
(1)

Egg

: Hot Cheetos

Not Voting:

mnemonicdevice, YellowKingValley, YES YES YES, BK201

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-10-22 07:45:00)

[Banakai]

You've literally just proven my point.

You continued the vote as an attempt to be like "ha only town would joke in RVS so I must be town!"

No, that was sarcasm.

[1baldeagle1]

IF YOU ARE Egg, Hermy or Banakai, THEN READ THIS

Why did you guys vote for NicCage when we were voting the other obvscum?

VOTE: YKV
For reasons.

Also fucking hell I REALLY WANTED TO BE MAF IN THIS SETUP!!!

Explain your reasons.

[Egg]

I don't think YKV's opening post is scummy but it is anti-town. I don't really want to vote on something that's intentionally WIFOM and might not have anything to do with anything.

Why even call it out if you're not going to vote on it? Even if you aren't voting for it, why not RVS?

So, guys

I claim IC.

Discuss.

If this is for real, prove it. If it's fake, it's dumb.

I counter claim IC

See above.

Niccage, did you at all consider that (admittedly probably joke) claims when you made that vote?

Baldeagle, I don't see yellow's opening post as scummy.

[BK201]

Hi, I'm actually V/LA until I catch up on Japanese and French...second week of the term and it kinda snuck up on me. So V/LA until Friday.

Haven't read this yet.

[1baldeagle1]

For now, I would just ignore the IC claims. If they are really the IC, then they need to get confirm. But doing it now is stupid anyways.

@Egg, okay, thank you.

Nic, do you have any scumreads besides Bana? Why is Bana scum?

[BK201]

VOTE: NicCage

Scum located.

[NicCage]

Oh, I forgot IC was a role.
I thought they meant IC as in Inexperienced Challenged.
Lol I guess I just assumed they were being silly. No I didn't consider it even a little.

[NicCage]

you said it was "Wifom" which makes absolutely no sense whatever as it was a joke

What he said could be implying that he is a vig or mafia, and those could either be true or false. So wifom.

@egg, I called it out because I didn't like it, and because I thought some people were voting/going to vote him over it and I didn't want to get into that discussion cause it's dumb.
And RVS is largely butts

[NicCage]

Nic, do you have any scumreads besides Bana? Why is Bana scum?

No, I don't. My scum read is mostly gut, I don't like how he switched off his RVs and onto me

[1baldeagle1]

Nic, do you have any scumreads besides Bana? Why is Bana scum?

No, I don't. My scum read is mostly gut, I don't like how he switched off his RVs and onto me

So, Bana has a gut scumread because he voted for you? Yeah, I don't like that reasoning for jumping on Bana.

VOTE: NicCage <----This one is serious.

[NicCage]

No it's because he was just joining my bw while pretending to have reasons like I said earlier.

[Venrob]

Vote: Eagle

For saying his vote was serious.

Reasons on YKV.... How bout RVS? I tend to say "for reasons" when i have no reasons. If i have reasons, I would say "for reasons i will explain later". If it's just "for reasons" then there are none, save RVS. YKV wagon did build early, though early wagons get us out of RVS and generate discussion. In a game this size (I.E. not a micro, 7 to lynch day 1) it is okay for a wagon to build as it did early. Other than that, the IC claims are probably both liars. (by that I OBVIOUSLY mean I'm mafia and we didn't pick IC)

[NicCage]

What's wrong with Eagles vote?

FOS: Venrob

For that weird uncalled for qualifying.

[Venrob]

In post 28 i was asked what reasons.
Also ppl who say "serious vote" are always scumz!

[Banakai]

I was lieing about being IC,
Pretty sure notscience was too

Still not liking Nic. He's over reacting abit and he still hasn't said why he's calling that post "WIFOM"

[notscience]

Here's a fun question-

If you were scum, which 3 roles would you pick for town to have and why?

[Venrob]

For fun, i would say jailkeeper, 2-shot vig, and tracker. Jailkeeper can block either of the others, especially good to destroy one of the vig's shots. Tracker might follow vig and lynch vig for killing, especially if maf and vig kill same person or maf are blocked by jailkeep- only 1 kill, vig dies, gg.

[1baldeagle1]

I would do 1-Shot Vig, Tracker and 1-Shot Cop.

1-Shot Vig would help by shooting another townie. Tracker has to actually track the correct scum to get a guilty. 1-Shot Cop is almost useless because it generates only one report.

Also, Venrob, why are you trying to RVS? (Atleast I'm assuming you are RVSing).

[notscience]

For fun, i would say jailkeeper, 2-shot vig, and tracker. Jailkeeper can block either of the others, especially good to destroy one of the vig's shots. Tracker might follow vig and lynch vig for killing, especially if maf and vig kill same person or maf are blocked by jailkeep- only 1 kill, vig dies, gg.

Funny, those were my ideas too.

[BK201]

Here's a fun question-

If you were scum, which 3 roles would you pick for town to have and why?

Probably IC, 2-shot Vig, and Tracker. IC isn't as powerful as 1-shot cop though it has its advantages. 2-shot vig statistically will have a higher chance of killing town rather than scum, and it's only 2 shots so by the time they have a better idea who is scum they are out of bullets. Tracker cus I'd rather not have 1-shot Cop or JK.

[BK201]

I would do 1-Shot Vig

1-Shot Vig would help by shooting another townie.

Now this is annoying. I'm not sure if this is town-ignorance or scum faking town-ignorance, but it seems too damn obvious to be legit town-ignorance.

VOTE: 1baldeagle1

[notscience]

Why isn't the IC as strong as a one shot cop?

Essentially it gives EVERYONE an inno rather than one person.

Granted, there is no chance of getting the guilty on scum with an IC, but it still provides someone the scum HAVE to kill before Lylo. It provides lynches to analyze without the lynch.

Pedit- I can sheep that.

VOTE: 1baldeagle1

[NicCage]

In post 28 i was asked what reasons.
Also ppl who say "serious vote" are always scumz!

YKV wagon did build early, though early wagons get us out of RVS and generate discussion. In a game this size (I.E. not a micro, 7 to lynch day 1) it is okay for a wagon to build as it did early.

Other than that, the IC claims are probably both liars. (by that I OBVIOUSLY mean I'm mafia and we didn't pick IC)

You weren't asked about the wagon speed (I don't think) so that was sort of out of nowhere. The bolded is what I was talking about though, I just don't understand why you felt the need to do that.

I was lieing about being IC,
Pretty sure notscience was too

Still not liking Nic. He's over reacting abit and he still hasn't said why he's calling that post "WIFOM"

Yeah I have ya dummy

If I were scum I'd pick 1-shot Cop, Tracker, and IC. 1-shot Cop is probably going to be useless, a Tracker would have to pick the right scum so I think that's unlikely, and an IC because I have to fill out the three. I think a 2-shot Vig is a gamble depending on what player gets it and JK is good.