Mafia 56: Hardcore Street - Game over!

[Zindaras]

Going on a full re-read:

Post 63, SL calls out Canuck. Post 150 Twito distances himself from milkman. Canuck switched from Twito to BM Day 2.

I'm definitely inclined to believe olio right now. Therefore, I should

Vote: milkman

[Zindaras]

Mod

, please prod all non-voters.

[Ancalagon]

Rereading.

[Ancalagon]

Looking through, olio is 10x more scummy than milkman.

Vote: Olio

[irrumator]

I can't believe im doing this, but

Vote Milkman

His claim is sooo much worse than olio's.

[spectrumvoid]

Prodding cheesefan since his last post was 6 days away.

vote count!

milkman: 3 (olio, zindaras, irrumator)
olio: 3 (milkman, canucklehead17, ancalagon)
7 alive, 4 to lynch!

[Ancalagon]

Zindy and olio are scum.

[Zindaras]

Cheesefan, for god's sake, kill milkman.

Ancalagon, you're free to be wrong, but you'll have to give reasons for it.

[Zindaras]

EBWOP: I feel forced to point out that the only confirmed townie at this stage is voting milkman. Important note.

[Ancalagon]

Who's confirmed? What if they're both Mafia with you?

[irrumator]

I'm confirmed . Both cops have me as town. Unless you think they're both liars.

[Zindaras]

Who's confirmed? What if they're both Mafia with you?

And what's next? Irrumator's Mafia with olio, milkman and me?

You still haven't given any reasons, Ancy.

[Zindaras]

Unvote

Let's not argue in a 3-3 with 4 to lynch.

[Ancalagon]

Irrumator's Mafia with olio, milkman and me?

Yeah, that's a bit far-fetched, I can see that.

But I just think irrumator is wrong. Lemme put some evidence against olio.

[Zindaras]

Let you unvote so nobody can hammer the guy out of nowhere.

Kay?

[spectrumvoid]

vote count!

milkman: 2 (olio, irrumator)
olio: 3 (milkman, canucklehead17, ancalagon)
7 alive, 4 to lynch!

[olio]

Ancalagon, reasons for your vote on me or unvote. Now.

Did you really read the whole thing in 10 minutes? Well, it was too fast for you as you managed to miss irrumirator's towniness. You failed to notice Canuckle's slip up. You're townie playing lousy. Accept the fact that you're wrong and start thinking, and - most importantly - provide reasoning behind your thinking. You're not saving this game, you're dooming it.

Milkman has lurked the whole game without providing any help to the town. Do you really think cop would've acted like that? He never expressed his opinion about Twito, didn't try to get reactions from other people based on the results he knew, avoiding the spotlight all the time - he is clearly lurking scum.

Even to this date he hasn't used his results for town to gain any new insights on persons he doesn't have result on. Why? Because he knows everyone's alignment and couldn't think out of his scum-box to give town more info.

My results after discussion:
06. Canucklehead17 = scum; slip up
07. olio = cop
08. irrumator = pro-town
10. cheesefan = ?, probably pro-town
11. milkman = scum, false claim
13. Ancalagon = pro-town
14. Zindaras = pro-town

Milkman's results after discussion:
06. Canucklehead17 = pro-town
07. olio = scum, false claim
08. irrumator = pro-town
10. cheesefan = ?
11. milkman = cop
13. Ancalagon = ?
14. Zindaras = ?

Now, Ancalagon, answer me this:
Which of the above lists benefits scum more?

[Zindaras]

Ancalagon, just unvote so we can argue this out instead of shouting at each other when someone can hammah at any moment.

[olio]

Milkman, who do you think are scum at the moment?

[Ancalagon]

Unvote: Olio

The reason behind my vote was that in about 13 of the first 15 posts he made were all off topic. I'm playing as a lousy townie.

[milkman]

Milkman's results after discussion:
06. Canucklehead17 = pro-town
07. olio = scum, false claim
08. irrumator = pro-town
10. cheesefan = ?
11. milkman = cop
13. Ancalagon = ?
14. Zindaras = ?

Olio, and maybe cheesefan or Zindaras are the scum. I have my doubts about cheesefan, by the way Zindaras pushed Ancalagon to unvote. Then again cheesefan is nowhere to be seen.

Milkman has lurked the whole game without providing any help to the town. Do you really think cop would've acted like that? He never expressed his opinion about Twito, didn't try to get reactions from other people based on the results he knew, avoiding the spotlight all the time - he is clearly lurking scum.

I decided before the game to play a certain way. I decided to play as a lurker because of the nature of the game, and I was just going to play with any of the people I found as town. I'm not one to give up the ghost, so I kept with it.

I didn't find out about Twito tell the day I hammered him, and I did play for reaction, most of my posts defended or echoed Canuckle. I honestly believe my play up to this point is the only reason I'm alive.

[Canucklehead17]

My slip-up?

[spectrumvoid]

vote count!

milkman: 1 (irrumator)
olio: 3 (milkman, canucklehead17, ancalagon)
7 alive, 4 to lynch!

Giving cheesefan till tomorrow to respond to his prod, since it was the weekend.

[Canucklehead17]

Mod: Ancalagon unvoted Olio. He has only two votes on him. Also, no one unvoted milkman. If I count correctly, it should be 2-2 between olio and milkman.

[Zindaras]

Olio, and maybe cheesefan or Zindaras are the scum. I have my doubts about cheesefan, by the way Zindaras pushed Ancalagon to unvote. Then again cheesefan is nowhere to be seen.

In what way do you have doubts about Cheesefan? As in "thinking he could be town" or "thinking he could be scum"?