Good news. If we don't lynch Pie today, and you still hate him tomorrow, you can shoot him.In post 2040, Titus wrote:Sven Stal is scum. AA9 is likely overwhelmed. That statement is not meant as alignment indicative.
How many shots does Titus have?In post 2047, Sakura Hana wrote:pieguy's an SK, titus is an X-Shot Dayvig, what's the difference? both are uninformed and are probably going to follow the uninformed majority.
Do you always press to lynch possible-not-scum and kill possible-not-scum whilst keeping claimed-scum alive? Or is this just an exception?In post 2048, PeregrineV wrote:This is exactly the process by which town lynches scum. Are you going to press for a no lynch after Pie's death?
Gladly.In post 2052, Majiffy wrote:If you aren't voting Pie, refute my arguments. Immediately.
Actually, it depends on the circumstances.In post 2051, Majiffy wrote:Do you always press to lynch possible-not-scum and kill possible-not-scum whilst keeping claimed-scum alive? Or is this just an exception?In post 2048, PeregrineV wrote:This is exactly the process by which town lynches scum. Are you going to press for a no lynch after Pie's death?
21 players with a claimed SK. 5 mafia is standard in 20 player game, so how many factions do you think there are?In post 2053, Titus wrote:Moonlogic?
Then explain it to me. Why is it good to keep claimed scum alive when we have no idea whatfactionsare in the game?
DV seems pretty town to me on my readthrough, so why would we lynch him Majiffy? The fact is we are not organized when we cannot even lynch claimed scum.
In post 2055, Sakura Hana wrote:Gladly.In post 2052, Majiffy wrote:If you aren't voting Pie, refute my arguments. Immediately.
1) It's a very risky maneuver to claim SK as scum, because if for some reason your lynchpool is full of scum, or for some reason your only target is scum, you'd be found out, and if you're still alive after several days you'll be found out too.
2) It's more likely for an SK to claim Vig than Scum to claim Vig, since then scum cannot explain the lack of a second kill, while an SK will be the source of a second kill.
3) SK is a Neutral/Third Party role... NOT scum, scum HAVE to get rid of him as much as we do since he cant joint, but he can help town until scum undoubtedly NKs him.
4) Leaving a leashed SK alive maximizes our chances at killing scum per day due to having 2 kills a day, while scum STILL can only kill once a day.
5) Eventually if he's not dead when reaching LyLo he has to be lynched before then.
My only correction to this is 3 kills a day (Pie, Titus, Lynch).In post 2056, Sakura Hana wrote:Expanding on #3 obviously if he doesnt follow our advice, we lynch him.
Seriously, this town can just go fuck themselves for jerking themselves to the levi - sakura scum mason claim.In post 2033, kanyeknowsbest wrote:vote dv
ill accept the drd lynch over a pie lynch if literally no one else in this entire game wants to lynch dv :<
Because he made a mistake, it seems.In post 1986, DeasVail wrote:Nacho, why did pie claim vig so early?
I thought his kanye interactions were a lot more townie, actually.In post 1986, DeasVail wrote:the AA9 ISO despite joining it, the major wagon of Day 1, (I think scum feel pretty self-conscious about this kind of thing) is more likely from town, so I'm not really interested in pursuing any kind of wagon there for the time being.
I would be extremely happy if we got to control a scumfaction's NK.In post 1988, Majiffy wrote:Pie could also be scum claiming SK for self-preservation at this point, which is even more dangerous as he can choose to exclude any scum from his faction in his list of killables.
this is stupid.In post 1989, Majiffy wrote:If he is SK, chances are he's going to hit more town than scum being guided by an uninformed majority.
If scum have blocking/protective roles, then this is actually a large worry.In post 2021, Wake1 wrote:The problem Sakura (what a nice, feminine name) is that if the SK messes up and knocks out a Townie, it's OUR collective faults. If Scum were clever (in which they are) they'll happily allow Town to direct the SK to accidentally kill Town.
I have no idea what you're saying.In post 2041, Titus wrote:Stal is scum due to his claim. His alleged role is a mechanic. That screams doctor in a setup with huge flying robotic machines. Doctor wouldn't claim something that would make their inherent role obvious. Thus, Stal is scum.
Yeah his last post kinda steered me in that direction.In post 2062, NachoKoopa wrote:I would also be unbelievably happy with an Empking flashwagon.
It was neighbors.In post 2060, DrDolittle wrote:Seriously, this town can just go fuck themselves for jerking themselves to the levi - sakura scum mason claim.In post 2033, kanyeknowsbest wrote:vote dv
ill accept the drd lynch over a pie lynch if literally no one else in this entire game wants to lynch dv :<
I support this sentiment, remember back in RVS when i said one of the 3 was scum?In post 2062, NachoKoopa wrote:I would also be unbelievably happy with an Empking flashwagon.
SAYS THE GUY WHO KILLED OBVTOWN MASTIN.In post 2065, Titus wrote:DoLittle, go on. I have a strong scumread on you,
I'm reading this and i dont know if to laugh or facepalm.In post 2067, DrDolittle wrote:SAYS THE GUY WHO KILLED OBVTOWN MASTIN.
Flavor to role isn't always so obvious.In post 2065, Titus wrote:Nacho, Stal claimed Korijo Murdoch. Given my lack of knowledge of Gundam, I googled it and came across the wiki. The character is a chief mechanic. That suggests he repairs or heals machines. Repairing machines suggests a doctor. Doctor shouldn't claim something that makes their role obvious. Stal is scum.
this has nothing to do with anything, by the by.In post 2067, DrDolittle wrote:SAYS THE GUY WHO KILLED OBVTOWN MASTIN.In post 2065, Titus wrote:DoLittle, go on. I have a strong scumread on you,
COOL BEANS
still makes more sense than town killing mastinIn post 2071, Sakura Hana wrote:So scum dayvig you say? so we're fighting against a scum dayvig and an SK? is that your reasoning?
Explain DV later. Pie is the play today.In post 2053, Titus wrote:DV seems pretty town to me on my readthrough, so why would we lynch him Majiffy? The fact is we are not organized when we cannot even lynch claimed scum.
Hi kanye.In post 2054, kanyeknowsbest wrote:hi majiffy. were not lynching pieguy today. dwi.
And I read him as scum early on. Look who was right! Guess you should probably start sheeping me now.In post 2057, PeregrineV wrote:I read pie as scumhunting early on, not hiding or coasting.
Except it doesn't. And I elaborated on why. So unless you're going to refute my arguments, vote pie.In post 2057, PeregrineV wrote:Plus, it's day1, so getting a couple or anti-mafia shots off, as well as absorbing a possible NK/RB, is worth it at this point. He may not be able to win, but this early claim makes it a better chance for us to win.
Yes lets give them a list of people and they can kill the townies on the list, that's a great idea.In post 2061, NachoKoopa wrote:I would be extremely happy if we got to control a scumfaction's NK.
this is stupid.In post 1989, Majiffy wrote:If he is SK, chances are he's going to hit more town than scum being guided by an uninformed majority.
