That doesn't make it careless - that makes it a different speed that we decide upon a lynch...and, functionally, with your vote in play on someone you don't even think is scum that appears to make you more careless because at least I'm standing behind my vote. Am I missing something here?
I left my vote on him to see what his reaction was going to be when he does finally come to the thread. Thats what I was waiting on. I vote for him for the same reason you voted DoL. It was the RVS and you wanted to get the ball rolling and see what her reaction was going to be.
My vote is on Blonde but that doesnt necessarily mean I would be "okay" with lynching him. All I am trying to do by voting him is to attempt, and the key word is attempt, to apply pressure to him. Im trying to scumhunt and it seems like you dont like that.
So, you feel by me saying I'd be okay lynching you that I have locked myself into a belief system that i cannot change and you are taking issue with that?
No thats not what it is at all and you are putting words into my mouth right here. There is a difference between "I at least try" and "At least I try." What I'm am talking about right there is how I personally play and what needs to be in my thought process when I feel "okay" lynching someone. That has nothing to do with me thinking that you are locked into lynching the guy. I take issue that you are like "okay" with lynching someone, whether it be me or anyone else in the game, with so little info about them. Not that I think you are locked into a belief system that you can not change
So...are you saying this is an incredibly weak town read you just voiced?
I mean, you're the one who announced it as a town read, all I'm trying to do is understand your logic - I currently understand your answer to be 'She seemed calm in addressing a non-aggressive attack while under minimal pressure, I take that level of calmness as some percent likely to be more common with town than scum'
Do I have that right?
And if so - how strong of a read is it, and should I even bother paying attention? And if it is so small, why did you feel the need to announce it?
Yes I am saying it is an incredibly weak town read but it is still a town read. I guess a better way of putting it is that it is an attribute that I think a townie would posses. So in a way yes you are understanding correctly. I played mafia before with my CoD clan mates and have seen people get sketched out over than and get defensive and they flipped mafia.
It is a very weak town read and it could very well be wrong. I'm not saying I think she is town, I'm saying that she did something that I think a townie would do. Two different things. As for if you should pay attention to it that is your call. Im an active person in mafia. I announce everything. If I post it I can remember it later when I look through the thread. It shows me what I was thinking at the time and why I was. Think of it as a reference
