In post 1255, EspeciallyTheLies wrote:You are a fucking moron. You are basing a read on me on how others are reading me, my fucking life schedule, and my predecessor's idiotic playstyle. That is complete and utter fucking idiocy.
Again with the putting words in my mouth, here. Insulting my intelligence is generally not a good way to make me think better of you, either, considering that I'm a decent player. Not solid, mind you. I'm only upper-mediocre. But upper-mediocre is apparently good enough.
My read on you has nothing to do with how others read you. Well, aside from the nightkill target. (Which, hell yes, influences my read.) It might be strengthened by players I think to be town backing me up, but its basis is not on that. But on the overall picture.
You're not scum for any one factor. You're scum for the grand total combination of all the factors. Your predecessor's scummy posts. (And, no, writing them off as being idiotic won't work. They weren't idiotic. Quite the opposite--they looked brilliant. They look town when looking at things superficially. But they look like they had scum intent.) Your predecessor's interactions with others. Others' interactions with your predecessor. (Interactions, not reads. Reads are a type of interaction.) And then you. Your interactions. Your posts. For instance, you're calling me without-a-doubt-town, off of basically nothing. Why can't I be scum pushing for a mislynch on you? My point exactly.
Combined with POE. The townreads I have on others. My scumdar is admittedly not solid. My town radar is far, FAR more refined. I have a solid list of town players, and your name is outside of it. Even IF I didn't have ALL of the above, that ALONE would be enough to scumread you. With all of the above, it just seals the deal.
You're caught scum. You don't like my reasons for you being caught scum. But you ARE.