Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Mafia - Game Over

[Svenskt Stål]

scum actually does not, they only have to reach parity

[Titus]

Regardless, supposing Pyro sticks with his stanced stance, Pie is the lynch. We should scumhunt as if Pie is dead rather than bicker.

We need a universal definition of whether scum includes or excludes the sk. The popping back and forth because people use the word scum differently is a bitch.

[Svenskt Stål]

they both need to die for us to win, what is the problem titus.

does the above not compute

[Sakura Hana]

the SK also needs to die for Scum to win.

[Titus]

I am not saying I have a problem with either of you. I am saying the debate is moot. We can use the time to scumhunt until Pyro presumably hammers. That's what I am saying.

[Sakura Hana]

I've already done scumhunting I've pointed out 4 scum.

[Sakura Hana]

Like seriously... think about it, what is the most common thing to give to an SK in most setups?... Bulletproof, limited shot obv. And what happened last night? only the kill from the SK!

[Titus]

If you've picked out your neighbor, have you considered hammering so scum cannot muddy the waters?

[Svenskt Stål]

Like seriously... think about it, what is the most common thing to give to an SK in most setups?... Bulletproof, limited shot obv. And what happened last night? only the kill from the SK!

might want to let that thought circle a few more times

[Sakura Hana]

I'm NOT hammering pie. He's a valuable asset to town.

P-Edit: Yeah I'm thinking scum actually wanted to kill pie last night but encountered a bulletproof vest.

[Svenskt Stål]

I'm NOT hammering pie. He's a valuable asset to town.

P-Edit: Yeah I'm thinking scum actually wanted to kill pie last night but encountered a bulletproof vest.

yeah, and you should let that thought circle a few more times.

[PeregrineV]

pedit then get back on the wagon Sven and stop derping out!

exactly why sven is scum :>

First Majiffy is scum for pushing you (catching you out actually)

Then I am (and now you're trying to appeal to me)

Then Titus is (even though that's the most conftown slot in the game)

Then Sven is

You know what? I see a pattern here.

@Wayne- just wanted to let you know that I think Pie is the SK. I don't see a point to your arguing with him about whatever it is your arguing about, and am starting to think it's become your substitute for sucmhunting.
In case I can't find your old reads list, can you update who you think is scum and who you think is town?

[Titus]

Thanks for quoting that PV. I missed the buddying by Waynegg. Ew.

[PeregrineV]

And you're wrong. You do t let known scum live. It's bad logic. We let known scum live yesterday and lynched town now we're down 3 town to no scum with known scum on D1. You're either stupid or scum to think it's not beneficial to lynch known scum. I don't think you're stupid...

And you don't get to state that everyone sees him as scum and then turn around and differentiate him being SK. you don't get to sit that fence. And when he flips factional scum, whatcha gonna say then?

You are saying that Pie is mafiascum not SK.

And you think that the mislynch yesterday was to avoid Pie being lynched.

Examine the Doolittle wagon and find all of Pie's teammates and point them out to us.

Day 1 - Vote Count #65

DrDolittle (11)

- Sakura Hana, Natirasha, leviathan93, pieguyn, talah, Belisarius, PeregrineV, NachoKoopa, kanyeknowsbest, Titus, Pyrotechnics

pieguyn (7)

- Empking, Majiffy, AGar, waynegg, DrDolittle, ArcAngel9, Wake88
[

Empking (1)

- DeasVail

ArcAngel9 (1)

- Svenskt Stål

Not voting (0)

-

[Titus]

PV, point ou the scum is fair. Why do you assume All of Pie's hypothetical scumbuddies didn't bus? That's a neon flag. I would expect one or two on the Pie wagon. Point out all of the scum is intellectually unfair.

[PeregrineV]

That makes total sense.

In any game town will suspect townies

Pie, if scum, knows who is not on his scum team

Pie picks a "town friendly" target

Pie kills the "town friendly" target

Nothing of this should make you think that pie is town friendly

Pie is 100% not town and is likely scum, he needs to die for town to win.

Damn that Pie. He killed a town friendly target.

Day 1 - Vote Count #65

ArcAngel9 (1)

- Svenskt Stål

[PeregrineV]

I, too, am considering replacing out.

Kdub's game is wonderful. However, noob/bad/stupid "Town," who keep making excuses to not lynch the supposed SK, is beyong aggravating. Not kdub's fault. They'll likely lynch another Townie, and another Townie will likely get killed by SK.

One should never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups.

Who are the other non-Pie scum?

[PeregrineV]

At this point all of the D2 discussion is "Yuh-uh"ing and "Nuh-uh"ing about lynching pie and abso-fucking-lutely nothing is happening that might catch scum instead.

This distraction from scumhunting needs to be eliminated.

VOTE: pie

So the car is at fault, not the drivers?

[Svenskt Stål]

peregrinev,

if you want to call me out on something you point to the fact that i asked everyone to unvote pie... like 5 pages ago

[PeregrineV]

Sheep me on this guys, this is the guy along with waynegg that have been causing all this noise in the thread when the SK has already been leashed by us, once he's dead we will have glorious days of scumhunting with all that noise gone.

Also FoSing: Sven, Waynegg and Wake.

P-Edit: I trust pie because he's bound to us.

Your giving a list of scumreads? How can you do such a thing when we have an SK?



Yes, you, in the back.

"She's town!"

That is correct!

[PeregrineV]

peregrinev,

if you want to call me out on something you point to the fact that i asked everyone to unvote pie... like 5 pages ago

I'm just reading up. if I happen to point out something you said back when you said it, the good news is you still said it.

The even better news would be if you have new information and/or new opinions.

But, I have to read them first.

[PeregrineV]

You know we would have found scum already if you pulled your heads out of your asses and started scumhunting instead of trying to get a leashed SK lynched.

You know I already found scum if you'd pull your head out of your ass and vote it.

Unless you think the game is 20 town vs 1 sK, you still got work to do.

[PeregrineV]

Majiffy is the most town looking of Wake/Stal/Jiffy. A stal or Wake wagon is more likely. Given Pie is at L minus 1, you will need a fast wagon.

Nati, why kill one of the people on the wagon if Pie is the SK? Woyldn't those likely be null for reasons we have already discussed?

Catching the SK earns you no town credit in the game of mafia.

What you do afterwards is where it's at. I see 3 more pages to read. Let's see if Majiffy tries to look for mafia by the time I reach the last one.

[PeregrineV]

Nati, why kill one of the people on the wagon if Pie is the SK? Woyldn't those likely be null for reasons we have already discussed?

It is trying to figure out who has the

least

reason to vote for pie. Empking silently hopped on the wagon, I think he's mostly using it as an excuse to not contribute more than he was. Svenskt is, well, look at him.

Beli falls into that category too.

[PeregrineV]

lol. haha "yeah, I agree" =) well, i pretty much lost all my "real" reads on people due to this stupid argument over Pie which is why I want him dead already so I can finally think. at that point I was just agreeing with everything you said because it seemed reasonable to me. I always went back and checked what you meant and if you were correct to feel the way you were and for the most part you were.

So, with more people posting and putting information out there, your ability to read people based on what they post has just vanished?