Open 12 - Masons & Monks (ABANDONED) - before 405

[BrizzyBoi]

Lostsoul is being replaced now for good. He was prodded and replied so he was given a second chance.

Other than Lost Soul, everyone has posted within the last 4 days except Twito who explained he was having some technical difficulties.

THE WHILE I AM HERE VOTECOUNT

Simenon 2 - Twito, Patrick.
ac1983fan 1 - pevergreen.
pevergreen 2 - IH, simenon.
scotmany 1 - ac1983fan.

[Twito]

Twito, you made it look like you were certain that Patrick was scum. What made you change your mind?

I haven't changed my mind.

I read the couple of pages. I stick to my vote and my suspicions.

Scumlist from up to down:
Simenon/Patrick - I think both are very likely scum.
Pevergreen - Right behind the other two
scotmany12 - Confirmed mason which easiers it for him but I still find him outright scummy and could be higher in the list.
ac1983fan - Good participation.
IH - Still giving townie wibes to me.

LostSould120 - Unranked due to not having any read on him.

[Twito]

I'd prefer either Simenon or Patrick lynch. I'm ok with Pevergreen or Scotmany lynch.

[Patrick]

I could go with pevergreen, but I don't want to do anything hasty before we've got a replacement for lost soul. It's pretty dangerous to have one player who we have absolutely no information on whatsoever. If he's scum, it's just a useful advantage for him.

I find some of Twito's assessment's poor; I don't think he has any good reason to have me at the top of his list. I disagree with a scotmany lynch today, and I have no idea how Twito can say that acfan is participating well.

[Simenon]

I wouldn't be shocked to see twitoscum and patrickscum.

[IH]

Are you saying that they are scum together?

Or that they are one of four scum, since there are two seperate scum teams in this game?

[Simenon]

I wouldn't be surprised to see them scum together.

Pure speculation, though.

[BrizzyBoi]

Spectrumvoid is replacing Lostsoul.

As he died Night 0 with no information there is no conflict.

[IH]

SV is a female-u-lar

[Patrick]

Welcome to the game spectrumvoid. Please make the game exciting for us, it's been boring so far

I have no clue how Simenon has drawn a connection between Twito and I. Don't get that at all.

[spectrumvoid]

Hi all. More tomorrow.

[spectrumvoid]

I claimed just to let you guys know that I was a mason. I didn't see anything wrong in it since vitamin is now dead. Should I have not claimed?

Um, how did you know that a mason was eliminated. The mod never stated that VitaminR was a mason, or I am not seeing where it was stated.

Does anyone besides me see anything wrong with this 2 posts?

[Twito]

Not really. Could you point it out?
Sticking to my suspicions btw.

[IH]

<3 SV, unvote, vote:Scotmany

If he's a mason, I believe he'd know if someone was a mason or not.

[scotmany12]

I knew he was a mason. Thats why I claimed. The reason I asked that was because I didn't see where the mod said that VitaminR was the other mason, and I was curious at how the others knew that vitamin was a mason. Look back and see.

[Patrick]

I don't buy the attack on scotmany here. I also think that if he wasn't a mason, the real mason would pretty obviously have come out and counterclaimed by now. There's no real doubt in my mind that he's a mason, though of course he could still be a werewolf.

[Simenon]

That's exactly what I had in mind when I made my first vote.

Scotmany: something doesn't check out here. You must have known VitR was dead, because you said "the other mason is dead" in your first post. In the next post, you ask someone how they knew that the mason was dead and how he knew it was a mason.

However, he has to be a mason, so the point is moot. Basically, scum or town, the slip doesn't really matter.

[IH]

No, he looks like a wolf throwing suspicion on someone with those two posts. At the moment, I'm feeling either a scotmany or pever lynch.

I really need to do a pbp for this game when I get time.

[scotmany12]

I knew he was dead. What I did not see was where the mod specifically said that Vitamin was a mason. My fault for not reading the first post fully. I was just wondering why someone else knew that he was a mason, but it said he was on the first post which I did not see. They guy I was questioning said that vitamin was mason even before I first posted.

[spectrumvoid]

I'm ok with scotmany's explanation. I'm currently on page 5.

- Why is ac1983fan not so scummy because he has good participation? I don't like the way he argued from page 3-5. Then again, I agree that ac1983 is probably not scum, more like a foolish townie. (No offense).

- I don't see the connection between Patrick and Simenon.

- Simenon is on the top of my LOS.

I wanted to wait till I finished before posting, but I fell sick. Elaboration and detailed arguments soon to come when I get well.

[ac1983fan]

I am foolish. I would be insulted if you didn't call me foolish

[ac1983fan]

I am foolish. I would be insulted if you didn't call me foolish

[Twito]

Sticking to my suspicions.

[Simenon]

Why did Nightfall die last night?

My guess is because ac is scum.

I still want to lynch pevergreen.

[IH]

Acfan, what was the purpose of the above said post?