Open 533: Pick Your Poison - The End

[YellowKingValley]

To save time, get Hermy and NS to claim together then we decide.

[NicCage]

Why would we do that? That's ridiculous. Just vote Hermy jeez

[YellowKingValley]

Hermy aka Banakai the 2nd.

[NicCage]

How does them both claiming help with that?

[Kalimar]

Vote Count 2.9

(4)

notscience

: EspeciallyTheLies, Hermy, YellowKingValley, Venrob
(3)

Hermy

: notscience, NicCage, Egg
(1)

YES YES YES

: Hot Cheetos
(1)

beastcharizard

: YES YES YES
(1)

Egg

: beastcharizard

Not Voting:

PhDScar

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-11-06 21:30:00)

Mod Notes:

[Egg]

We should definitely make a Hermy lynch happen.

[YellowKingValley]

(last voter): Die! Lurking scum! Your claims are lies. Wait we will not (votes Hermy).
Kalimar: Hermy, Innocent Child, was lynched on Day 2.
Kalimar: YellowKingValley, ???, was killed on Night 2.
NicCage, HotCheetos, notscience: PhDScar is scum!

[NicCage]

Right, well hermy can get on and claim when we an intent on her. Two people aren't going to claim right now. So start voting hermy so we can get that claim.

[Egg]

It's Hermy's responsibility to claim before deadline if needed.

[YellowKingValley]

Hermy is at prod no. 2

Scum or town she will be replaced soon. Oh, she is inactive in her other games too (I didn't break rules because I didn't explain in detail).

[Egg]

Then the Mod needs to decide whether or not to replace Hermy ASAP. But again, that's on the Mod, not us. And if the scum team happens to be Nic/Yellow/Hermy, we need the Hermy lynch today and can't settle on a townie. Yes, we need a claim. But we can't let that be an excuse for Hermy or a replacement.

[Kalimar]

If I don't hear from Hermy within 24 hours then I will replace her overnight.

Sidenote: Technically, she already reached her third prod. I think if I replace everyone who hits 3 mechanically, I will end up replacing more people than I want to. I'm trying to be a little reasonable here, as I'd prefer to not replace if I can, but I also don't want to upset the flow of the game.

[Egg]

^good choices.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Hermy hasnt posted here since sunday. But she has posted elsewhere prod dodges.

[Hermy]

*waves*
I'm here.

I see you need a claim.

I'm a jailkeeper (yay, power role!). N1 I flipped a coin and didn't jailkeep Nic. Instead I went for Egg, as he seemed pretty town-y to me on D1.

So... yes. It would be beneficical if I wasn't lynched.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Weird way to claim. Usually it's just

"I'm ____. I did ____ on N1."

Not:

"I'm _____ YAY! I did _______ on N1 instead of _________ because _______ so ________ and _______."

[Venrob]

well jailkeeper is one of the better PR's..... so unless there is a cc, Hermy lynch is out of the question.

[Venrob]

Yes i am here aswell, not posting much do to being busy.... have time to read, though- don't worry, if you need me i'll be here. Not gonna get replaced out!

[PhDScar]

1- shot cop and Jailkeeper? That explains why Nic survived the night Scum ust of thought he'd get Jailkept. It seems that most people when discussing what power roles they would pick as scum wouldn't even consider JK because it's the strongest one. So who here would pick JK?

[YES YES YES]

I choose not to believe that claim (real JK, if there is one, dont claim)

What kind of jailkeeper claims "Yayy power role"?

Bad.

VOTE: Hermy

[PhDScar]

And if the scum team happens to be Nic/Yellow/Hermy,

What?! Why these people as a scum team all of a sudden. Why would Nic fake claim cop fake clear Yellow then attempt to lynch Hermy?

[PhDScar]

VOTE: YESYESYES

[YES YES YES]

1. Why would a jailkeeper be this inactive if they were so excited about having said power role?
2. Her JK is inconsistent with her initial Egg read, according to 122 Egg is null to her.

So her claiming JK makes WIFOM. Either scum picked JK and she's trying to draw one out. Or scum didnt pick JK so she picked the safe claim.

DP

PS, if DB tries to unvote later (he doesnt like voting claimed PRs), punch him

Edit, explain.

[Egg]

I'd actually prefer a counterclaim if we have a JK. Method of claiming is fine. Existence of JK makes sense. I say Hermy is town if uncountered.

Unvote

Can we try Beast or Yes? Or are we stuck with notscience? (All of this barring a counterclaim)

Preview edit: it was hypothetical. Not really thought out. Just a "what if" I thought of.

Vote YES YES YES

Preview edit again: low phone battery. Will try reading but no promises.

[YES YES YES]

Sorry, but the real Jailkeeper claiming would directly fall right into Hermy's plan