Open 536: Faith Plus One Game Over! Mafia Win!

[T S O]

why does no-one agree with my scumread?

[Grimgroove]

Keep your votes on Taylor please.

The claim is ludicrous and their claim of not wanting to protect me plays perfectly into their scummy hands: both real faith healers will presume they need to protect me, resulting in a protection fail and a kill on me.

We asked ETL to claim earlier and she said it would make no difference. This is not what a real faith healer would say. Check post 1398 and move your votes back to Taylor.

[Grimgroove]

Claim: Faith Healer. Which we've only been making obvious since the very damn beginning.

Dare I ask:
Crumbs?

[Grimgroove]

Guyett, please, move your vote back to Taylor. Don't let something as simple as an L-1 fakeclaim fool you.

[Grimgroove]

goddammit

UNVOTE: taylor

sorry mastin

[Guyett]

hmmm

[T S O]

Keep your votes on Taylor please.

The claim is ludicrous and their claim of not wanting to protect me plays perfectly into their scummy hands: both real faith healers will presume they need to protect me, resulting in a protection fail and a kill on me.

We asked ETL to claim earlier and she said it would make no difference. This is not what a real faith healer would say. Check post 1398 and move your votes back to Taylor.

When you die they then get auto-lynched.

The question here is whether you believe ETL/mastin hydra would consider themselves, 1/3 of the scumteam dead, in exchange for you dead and 2 conftown players a fair exchange.

What do you think?

[Grimgroove]

When you die they then get auto-lynched.

I don't think this premise holds up.
More importantly: I don't think Taylor will think this premise holds up. So you can't expect them to take decisions based on that premise.

[T S O]

You die and the optimal strategy is that both Faith Healers claim. Taylor then dies.

Why would they not assume that?

[Grimgroove]

Hmm. True! Good thinking.

Ok, let's see where it goes.

VOTE: helium

[Grimgroove]

You die and the optimal strategy is that both Faith Healers claim. Taylor then dies.

BUT LYNCH TAYLOR IN THAT CASE. DO NOT LYNCH EITHER OF THE OTHER FH-CLAIMERS!!!

[pieceofpecanpie]

Emotions are running high, #1453 felt like a slap in the face as far as FH suggestions go.

There is not enough time to consider the merits of this, but - much like GG's cop claim - I don't want to go against it in Day 1. Taylor stays.

Taylor-lynch: No
Helium-lynch: Okay
Shos-lynch: No
Guyett-lynch: Yes

N64-lynch:

[bubbajack8]

Guys I promise I know how to do VCs xD. Anyway. Taylor is sick, and needs some faith healing. Had quite a wagon going. The town circled around. 1 vote was all that was needed. Taylor looked and said, "BEHOLD I AM DA ALL MIGHTY FAITH HEALER". Everyone scattered. Some went to vote others. Yet others stayed strong saying they were looking through Taylor's lies. As the turkey grows cold, a snicker is heard. Heads turn. Was it Taylor? Or someone else. How many licks does it take to get to the center of a tootsie pop? "The world may never know."

Vote Count 0.19
Taylor (3) : Paschendale, N64Lord, Majiffy Shos (2) : Blueberry, sthar8 Guyett (3) : T S O, XScorpion, helium-3 Paschendale (1) : Taylor sthar8 (1) : shos helium-3 (2) : Guyett, Grimgroove Not Voting (1) : pieceofpecanpie
With 13 alive it's 7 to lynch.
Deadline is in (expired on 2013-12-01 18:00:00)

MODNOTE: Instead of just having the Countdown locked, I combined the times.

[XScorpion]

Taylor you gotta change your vote.

Where? To Guyett, a townread? (Hell no.)
shos, a back-and-forth read? (Leaning town right now.) Probably not.
To helium? (Fuck no.)
To sthar8? (Okay. That one I can be receptive to.)

If I thought our vote was better placed elsewhere...I'd be placing it elsewhere.

Why is Pasch town to you?
...Or, hell, why isn't Pasch scum to you?

Pasch isn't scummier than Guyett or Shos, both of which are better wagons.

Emotions are running high, #1453 felt like a slap in the face as far as FH suggestions go.

There is not enough time to consider the merits of this, but - much like GG's cop claim - I don't want to go against it in Day 1. Taylor stays.

Taylor-lynch: No
Helium-lynch: Okay
Shos-lynch: No
Guyett-lynch: Yes

N64-lynch:

So why aren't you voting Guyett?

[pieceofpecanpie]

VOTE: Guyett

Well I am now. Didn't have time before to check through where the votes were at and what was going down. Now I'm home from work, VC is up, Guyett is a decent sized wagon and a decent lynch for today.

@everyone

Just putting it out there, but Taylor claimed FH so I don't believe they should be lynched today. Same goes for Grim with their cop claim. Regardless of how you think they've played or what alignment they

really

might be, put that to one side for now as there's no CCs and no NKs yet. By all means open it up for discussion again tomorrow. For now, however, I suggest we decide out of the three largest wagons, that's shos (2), Guyett (soon to be 4) and helium-3 (2).

shos lynch: No
Guyett lynch: Yes (voting)
helium-3 lynch: Okay

[Paschendale]

I really don't believe Taylor's claim. That said, I actually do prefer the Helium lynch.

VOTE: Helium

[helium-3]

lol, I don't think anti and I really care anymore and it is a good lynch if it knocks groovy kid out of whatever weird fantasy he is enacting.

[XScorpion]

Yes. Why do I expose myself now, you ask? Because you're fucking lazy asses. A lazy town deserves a lazy cop. I see no reason not to be lazy as well in this kind of envrionment.

Actually... I don't care anymore.

lol, I don't think anti and I really care anymore

Seriously? Can we stop being whiny and actually play the game? I'm honestly getting sick and tired of all of the complaining and bickering and 'oh I don't care anymore so fuck the town I'm just going to role claim and screw my team over'. This is just getting ridiculous and I would feel really good if my townreads on you guys are totally wrong and you're the scum team just so I don't feel like I'm playing with people who aren't actually trying to win.

[50 Shades of Purple]

scorp thing we

have

been playing the game and there really is nothing else to say.

nlord and pasch are making up shit and groovy kid is cheering them on. it is depressing and there is nothing that I can do that will shake some sense into him. he will not be happy unless taylor or I are lynched.

[helium-3]

scorp thing we

have

been playing the game and there really is nothing else to say.

nlord and pasch are making up shit and groovy kid is cheering them on. it is depressing and there is nothing that I can do that will shake some sense into him. he will not be happy unless taylor or I are lynched.

[XScorpion]

scorp thing we

have

been playing the game and there really is nothing else to say.

nlord and pasch are making up shit and groovy kid is cheering them on. it is depressing and there is nothing that I can do that will shake some sense into him. he will not be happy unless taylor or I are lynched.

Fortunately, the game has more than just 4 players, so maybe you can help get Guyett lynched instead?

my play here deserves a D1 lynch :/

Guyett do you really think so? Because it seems to me like you are trying pretty hard to get someone else lynched.

[helium-3]

Yes. Why do I expose myself now, you ask? Because you're fucking lazy asses. A lazy town deserves a lazy cop. I see no reason not to be lazy as well in this kind of envrionment.

Actually... I don't care anymore.

lol, I don't think anti and I really care anymore

Seriously? Can we stop being whiny and actually play the game? I'm honestly getting sick and tired of all of the complaining and bickering and 'oh I don't care anymore so fuck the town I'm just going to role claim and screw my team over'. This is just getting ridiculous and I would feel really good if my townreads on you guys are totally wrong and you're the scum team just so I don't feel like I'm playing with people who aren't actually trying to win.

what do the chances are that you think we are all town being retarded?

[helium-3]

also our vot eis on guy so what

[XScorpion]

Yes. Why do I expose myself now, you ask? Because you're fucking lazy asses. A lazy town deserves a lazy cop. I see no reason not to be lazy as well in this kind of envrionment.

Actually... I don't care anymore.

lol, I don't think anti and I really care anymore

Seriously? Can we stop being whiny and actually play the game? I'm honestly getting <a href="http://magiccards.info/query?s=cname&q= ... er=AUTOANY" class="mtgcardextensionlink" name="Sick and Tired">Sick and Tired</a> of all of the complaining and bickering and 'oh I don't care anymore so fuck the town I'm just going to role claim and screw my team over'. This is just getting ridiculous and I would feel really good if my townreads on you guys are totally wrong and you're the scum team just so I don't feel like I'm playing with people who aren't actually trying to win.

what do the chances are that you think we are all town being retarded?

Earlier in the day I would have said pretty high; now I am not so sure. I think one of my townreads on Taylor or GG is wrong but I don't know which.

also our vot eis on guy so what

There is more to the game than just voting for the person you think is the scummiest.

[shos]

*sigh* imconfused.