Mini 1522: AA - MFA (Game Over!)

[Sakura Hana]

Below contains game related spoilers.

They are both guilties on final AA cases
Damon Gant 1-5
Godot 3-5

So I don't think this can be broke flavorwise, since I know i'm town, and it would be irrelevant to KA's alignment flavorwise.

[KingdomAces]

Oh yeah, my opinion on Geists' plan. My main issue with it is that SSK shouldn't state who he's planning on tracking, because the only way that he would actually catch scum making the night kill is if there is only two groupscum and we lynch one of them. Unless someone actually claims scum or we have reliable information otherwise, we should never just assume that the person we lynch is going to flip scum, and only make plans for that scenario. A tracker's chance of tracking the night-kill is already decently minimal. There's no reason to make it completely non-existent.

Sakura, I know that. What I'm saying is that the tone surrounding it is night and day between them, and that is more than enough to call it a difference.

Spoiler: Followup to Sakura's spoiler.

Also, technically 1-4 is the final case of the first game. 1-5 is just a bonus added to the DS version of it.

I'm not saying that you are definitely scum because of flavor. The fact that you claimed a different character first, and changed it when people didn't believe it is the problem here.

Marquis, flavor explanation of EdgeworthHider please.

[Bert]

What bothers me is how hard it is during this game to get a decent sized wagon of any kind going against Marquis, whereas Sakura's wagon just ballooned to lynch -2.

[geists]

Geists, what Bert quoted was what I was referring to as well. If it was a bluff, why did you call it five posts later, without me being on in the intervening time.

It was never about you. It was a small lie to feed to Sakura-scum.

Also, I appear to have lost the train of thought that I was on before. Anyone have any questions for me while I try to find it again?

Am I right in my spec on your role?

i would vote sakura but frankly i'm tired of everything i do being construed to be "omg scumwords"

Convenient way to not join your scumbuddy's wagon. You have my permission to bus.

Below contains game related spoilers.

They are both guilties on final AA cases
Damon Gant 1-5
Godot 3-5

So I don't think this can be broke flavorwise, since I know i'm town, and it would be irrelevant to KA's alignment flavorwise.

KA being scum has nothing to do with Godot being a bad guy(which he isn't, Hawthorne is the main bad guy of 3-5). Godot does make a good SK though, now that I think about it.

[geists]

What bothers me is how hard it is during this game to get a decent sized wagon of any kind going against Marquis, whereas Sakura's wagon just ballooned to lynch -2.

Marquis tomorrow. Get rid of roleblockers today.

[KingdomAces]

Am I right in my spec on your role?

Probably.

[Bert]

What bothers me is how hard it is during this game to get a decent sized wagon of any kind going against Marquis, whereas Sakura's wagon just ballooned to lynch -2.

Marquis tomorrow. Get rid of roleblockers today.

Heh. Sakura has more chance of being town than Marquis IMHO, and Marquis could be a roleblocker too.

However, now that I think about it, Mafia JOAT is possible for Sakura. Bah.

[geists]

However, now that I think about it, Mafia JOAT is possible for Sakura. Bah.

Doubt Marquis is roleblocker. Joat is possible. Same dif.

[Sakura Hana]

tbh i dont have any more energy to argue here with obvscum at this point, My gambit didn't work as intended and i'll pay the price for it, good luck tomorrow because you'll need it.

Vote: Sakura

*me leaves thread*

[Mac]

do we really think sakura has a 1 shot doc and we have a town doc too

[Cabd]

do we really think sakura has a 1 shot doc and we have a town doc too

Not particularly, no. If she by some miracle flips town then we go from there and look at the other PRs but hey.

VOTE: sakura

[theslimer3]

So Slimer, how would you describe your own play so far this game as compared to our last game together in Mentor/Mentee?

Well in the previous game I couldn't find a read. In this one, I can't catch this game without 4-6 pages inbetween. So I'd say a big difference.


But what I can say is

but it's really going to suck because she probably isn't.

Miles Edgeworth, 2-shot Town Hider. Mac's clean

This

really hoping sakura is town

UNVOTE:

and this is what i wanted to do

i want sakura and i to target the same person.

sakura town, target town: target and i die, lynch sakura. we live, sakura either town or scum lets me find another conftown
sakura town, target scum: i die alone. lynch the target
sakura scum, target town: well if scum decides to kill my target we know who to lynch
sakura scum, target scum: i die i guess. still lynch the target

and now i go back to my paper. finals smh

of course i'm hoping GIF is using hide > roleblock tho since it really depends on mod

and this

Doesn't seem like scum kuniving. Looks more town strategizing to me. Tell me how I'm wrong if you'd think so.

[GuyInFreezer]

VoteCount 2.03 (FINAL)

Sakura Hana (Lynch):

Mac | giests | Bert | MafiaSSK | Sakura Hana | Cabd

Not Voting:

theslimer3, Kalimar, KingdomAces, Marquis

Deadline: (expired on 2013-12-19 09:00:00)
With 10 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

----

Mod Notes:

Lynch!

[GuyInFreezer]

Everyone was surprised to see him once again; Damon Gant, the chief of police himself.
His presence itself was enough to silence the whole courtroom with awe for few minutes.

"...Now let us continue the trial", said the judge, finally snapping out of the silence.

The trial, at first, proceeded smoothly, largely in Gant's favor.

However, as the trial progresses, new witnesses were introduced, new evidences were found, and new points were made.
Contradictions were found, and the lies to cover up the contradictions spawned even more contradictions.

Eventually, the evidences of him helping out murderers to kill borkjerfkin were found in his safe hidden in his office.

"...What do you have to say with all this, Mr. Gant?" The defense attorney asked with glee.
At first, there was yet another silence.

And then...


Then...


And finally...


Before finally he accepted his defeat and confessed his crime.

"Now I believe is the best time to hand down the verdict." The judge said with the solemn voice.

"I hereby declare the defendant Damon Gant, Chief of Police..."

No evidence laws were harmed during this trial.

Sakura Hana, Damon Gant (

Mafia Godfather Jailkeeper

), was sentenced guilty and sent to detention room Day 2.

Now it is Night 2.
Deadline is until December 8, 6:00 PM EST.
Countdown until deadline: (expired on 2013-12-08 18:00:00)

[GuyInFreezer]

Director Hotti was sneaking out of his room and was roaming around.
He was hoping to see any cute girls who might be in the court.

But then, he had to see the most unexpected to see - the murderers planning their next move.

"Hey, how did you get here?"

"Umm.... Eh.... I don't know.... Hmmm....."

"Guys, take care of him."

Cabd, Director Hotti (

Town Doctor

), disappeared Night 2.

Sal was staying in his room gobbling his T-bone steak and thinking of the next scenario of the "The Pink Princess," until he got hungry again and walked into the cafeteria.

"D00d the food r0x0rz in this cafeteria... *drool* ...WTF? Who are j00 guys?"

Geists, Sal Manella (

Vanilla Townie

), disappeared Night 2.

Now it is Day 3.
Deadline is at December 22, 6:15 PM EST.
Time until deadline: (expired on 2013-12-22 18:15:00)

[GuyInFreezer]

VoteCount 3.0

Not Voting:

theslimer3, Kalimar, KingdomAces, Marquis, Bert, MafiaSSK, Mac

Deadline: (expired on 2013-12-22 18:15:00)
With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.

----

Mod Notes:

Start!

[KingdomAces]

First, Marquis still needs to explain how Edgeworth being a hider makes any sense at all.

Aside from that, theoretically SSK could be scum with Sakura, but for the moment I see absolutely no reason to doubt him. Also, even though Marquis's claim is incredibly suspect, I'm willing to call Mac near conftown because MacScum would require Marquis and Mac to be on the same team, which would first require the setup to be 3 scum + SK. Once again, possible but there's too much calling it unlikely to act on it right now.

Bert needs to use his ability today. That will make him near conftown and give us something else to work off of.

That leaves:
6. Marquis
8. theslimer3
12. Kalimar
13. KingdomAces

As the only possible scum left. If Marquis manages to give a reasonable explanation, then we should be leaving him alone also leaving just slimer, Kalimar, and myself. This is probably selfish of me, but since I really don't want to accidentally lynch Bert today I suggest that he targets me, since I'm the only unclear person who doesn't have a fairly decent chance of being Scum from my POV.

[Marquis]

On phone will elaborate later but:
Doctor would be on channeler
I didn't trust sakura
Stupid massclaim causing town pr reveals
I claimed 2-shot hider to live
Edgeworth is actually cop
Theslimer3 is guilty.

vote theslimer3

[KingdomAces]

I believe that, but we shouldn't be quicklynching anyone because Bert needs to use his ability today before that happens.

[Marquis]

Well if anyone's at L-1, theslimer3 has to be on the wagon to prevent a quickhammer from him. And that's not happening
I was thinking I shouldn't claim so early, but meh what's done is done

[Bert]

Someone has to put someone at lynch -2. Then, I can put that person at lynch -1 and post my request to IC-rize in one post. Prevents derp hammering

/phone

[Bert]

Marquis was going to be dead today, after Sakura, so this might be Despwrado-tracker gambit from Castle again...

[Marquis]

That's a really silly suspicion and once I get home I'll explain why

[Bert]

I would like to use the ability on Kingdom Aces

[Mac]

i would like you to use that too.