Micro 267 - Indie Game: The UPick - Game Over!

[My Milked Eek]

Oops, should've bene a pm, misclicked, don't mind me >_>

[Alduskkel]

My Milked Eek replaces Hermy, as you all may have guessed.

Vote Count 1.15

TierShift (2) - XScorpion, Desperado
Who (2) - Trine, Turkish Van
My Milked Eek (2) - Who, TierShift
Grimgroove (1) - BROseidon
BROseidon (1) - My Milked Eek

Not Voting (1) - Grimgroove

9 alive, 5 to lynch.

Deadline is on December 14th, 12 p.m. PST.

Countdown:
(expired on 2013-12-14 12:00:00)

[My Milked Eek]

So, hi guys!

Gimme a few moments to catch up.

Unvote.

[Grimgroove]

Also, that quote has no relation to the point that you're making. Mixing up facts!=bad trajectory.

You said "so much of this" in response to the same quote where penguin_alien responded to with a statement of seeing sound logic and a townread to boot.

"So much of this" looks like the same thing to me really. It means you couldn't agree more. Despite the facts having been mixed up.

[TierShift]

Grimgroove, we haven't really interacted so far, can you give out a read on me? Can you also answer xS's earlier question as to why you are not voting?

[Grimgroove]

I've been distracted away from this game recently.
Your 180 in 260 isn't too bad, I've seen it done by scum before but never this early in their game. Can't really comment on later things for now, but will have more time tomorrow. I'm still mostly in five pages ago.

[XScorpion]

I don't like TierShift's recent posts but I'm very afraid that they're noobtown.

My sentiments exactly. I'd be willing to make a fair wager that Tier is just scum though.
Tier, what do you think of Who?
Who, what do you think of Tier?

[Who]

@Who thanks for telling me that hermy thing, hadn't realized that before, omg that is scummy like how did I even not see that. XS, now I have someone to vote for, a replacement being pressured from the get-go is something I like.
VOTE: hermy

I'm no language analyst but the language of this post seems to be leaping up and down yelling "SCUM!" That said, it could also be newb-town.
Also, other than my superficial complaint with it, it doesn't seem that bad. He could be scum thinking that I'll be lynched today and that if he is not on my wagon he gets townypoints and that that sets up a wrong hermy-wagon for tomorrow. He could be newb-town who means what he says. They're both possible. If Eek flips town then Tier would probably be my next target of suspicion.

@Eek
Your predecessor did not leave you in a very good state.

[Trine]

@Eek
Your predecessor did not leave you in a very good state.

Thank you for the scumclaim, who.

[Trine]

I think the scummers in Russia can hear my twitching right now from that post.

[BROseidon]

You said "so much of this" in response to the same quote where penguin_alien responded to with a statement of seeing sound logic and a townread to boot.

"So much of this" looks like the same thing to me really. It means you couldn't agree more. Despite the facts having been mixed up.

You're still not addressing my point re: mixing up facts versus having a bad trajectory.

Bad trajectory is indicative of scum because it indicates someone attempting to imitate an "honest" read, but not really understanding how to go about it. It results in a sloppy line of reasoning that doesn't make sense.

Mixed up facts just means someone made a blunder about a position.

Imagine the game as a series of points and connecting lines, with the points being events/statements/facts, and the connecting lines being the narrative formed from those points. You're trying to use an argument pertinent to the way the lines are connecting the points to apply to something that was a mixup about a point was.

Do you follow?

[BROseidon]

@Who thanks for telling me that hermy thing, hadn't realized that before,

omg that is scummy like how did I even not see that.

XS, now I have someone to vote for, a replacement being pressured from the get-go is something I like.
VOTE: hermy

Thanks TierShift for pointing this out.

This is what was making me not like TierShift. The bolded is overemphasis; Tiershift really wants us to know that he didn't see what Who pointed out and that he's sorry for it.

VOTE: TierShift

[Alduskkel]

Prodded Turkish Van.

[Turkish Van]

Day off is tomorrow.

Catching up

because a post a day keeps the prod away

~

[Turkish Van]

Catching up when I wake up *

[Turkish Van]

Other head posting now.

Would still lynch Who. Torn on whether TierShift is lynchbait or scum overplaying his hand as per BRO's comment.

I look forward to MME's catch-up; just finished a game with him in Little Italy where I was vaguely scum reading him more because he wasn't as town as my town reads but less scummy than my scum reads, if that's coherent. Hermy's play left me with no compunctions about lynching the slot, but I want to hear his impressions.

I get that it's an awkward position to be in, to be talking to someone who knows you when you don't know their identity, but the timing of it feels less curious and more 'looking for ways to derail the case.'

huh?

How would knowing the identity of the person dancing with him help him derail the case?

Knowing who was arguing the case isn't as important to everyone else as discussing the case itself. By engaging in trying to find out a hidden hydra head's identity, he was distracting from the point at hand and increasing the odds that people would forget that he'd never addressed the actual issue.

BRO, you pointed out TierShift's reaction to Who's post. Do you think he's buddying or propping up a scum buddy?

GG, as you catch up, I'd like your take on Who.

--PA

[Trine]

Loving how who is suddenly like "your" wagon peng. Not that I care which player takes credit for a scumlynch, seeing myself as the first vote on the wagon is reward in and of itself.

[TierShift]

@Who thanks for telling me that hermy thing, hadn't realized that before,

omg that is scummy like how did I even not see that.

XS, now I have someone to vote for, a replacement being pressured from the get-go is something I like.
VOTE: hermy

Thanks TierShift for pointing this out.

This is what was making me not like TierShift. The bolded is overemphasis; Tiershift really wants us to know that he didn't see what Who pointed out and that he's sorry for it.

VOTE: TierShift

Yes, I do really want you to know I feel sorry. I shouldn't be discovering things that happened the first pages, while having already been in the game for 10 pages and outing my opinions and suspicions, should I?

I don't like TierShift's recent posts but I'm very afraid that they're noobtown.

My sentiments exactly. I'd be willing to make a fair wager that Tier is just scum though.
Tier, what do you think of Who?
Who, what do you think of Tier?

I think who's start was pretty weak (with the desp thingy) but from there the logic on the hermy scumread was pretty sound. I like his 382, even though he is setting himself up for an easy me vote tomorrow, he sounds genuine and as a slightly paranoid town.

[Trine]

So, hi guys!

Gimme a few moments to catch up.

Unvote.

Hello, how is this going?

- Zoya

[BROseidon]

BRO, you pointed out TierShift's reaction to Who's post. Do you think he's buddying or propping up a scum buddy?

Could see it as either, would bias towards buddying based on the fact that I have enough other scumreads that numerically it works out that way.

[Turkish Van]

Loving how who is suddenly like "your" wagon peng. Not that I care which player takes credit for a scumlynch, seeing myself as the first vote on the wagon is reward in and of itself.

...did I say it was my wagon? If so, apologies; no credit-snatching intended. 3 AM posting =/= coherent penguin, apparently.

--PA

[XScorpion]

Can everyone give a reads list for right now?
Personally:

Scummy- Who, Hermy/Eel, Tier
Null- TV, Des
Town-Bro, GG, Trine

[Alduskkel]

Prodded Desperado.

I would also like to call attention to the looming deadline.

[Grimgroove]

Catching up tomorrow (within 24 hours from now) at the latest.

[Grimgroove]

That looming deadline does come as a surprise. Let me make that 14 hours. Need sleep