Mini 1525: Tales of The Abyss Mafia GAME OVER!

[pitoli]

I only checked the thread because I got up in the middle of the night to pee lol. If you're going to say something say it quick kbai

[Mac]

if you are a joat why the fuck didnt you cc Minami who is surely scum in your eyes????

[pitoli]

Where in the game rules does it say there can be only one JOAT?

[pitoli]

It was mainly the distinction "Cowardly JOAT" that made me think, even before the game started, that there was a possibility of more than one JOAT.

[Mac]

have you ever played in a game where town has had two roles with multiple powers?

pedit what does the cowardly have to do with your role? I think you need to full claim

[pitoli]

And Mac - as long as we're positing that there can only be ONE of any particular role in this theme game, why are there TWO vanilla neighbor claims?

[pitoli]

have you ever played in a game where town has had two roles with multiple powers?

pedit what does the cowardly have to do with your role? I think you need to full claim

I'm not going to full claim, it's definitely not in our best interests for scum to know what my remaining actions are.

But come the fuck on, Mieu was hiding Night 1, isn't that cowardly enough for you already?

[Mac]

And Mac - as long as we're positing that there can only be ONE of any particular role in this theme game, why are there TWO vanilla neighbor claims?

now you're just being ridiculous because I'm not saying that at all and I'm not going to waste my time addressing this.

[pitoli]

And Mac - as long as we're positing that there can only be ONE of any particular role in this theme game, why are there TWO vanilla neighbor claims?

now you're just being ridiculous because I'm not saying that at all and I'm not going to waste my time addressing this.

Okay, so I'm scum AND ridiculous now? Progress!

[Mac]

You're getting there!

If two people claimed cop in a game, would your first reaction honestly be "ooo they could both be town!"

[GuyInFreezer]

Hey pit
"JoaT", "Jack of all trades", or "Jack-of-all-trades"?

[pitoli]

You're getting there!

If two people claimed cop in a game, would your first reaction honestly be "ooo they could both be town!"

No, but Minami and I haven't claimed the same thing because our abilities are CLEARLY DIFFERENT WHY IS THAT SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND
So when they claimed I decided to give them the benefit of the doubt.

[Mac]

YOU ARE CLAIMING A HIDING ROLE DURING NIGHT ONE, AND THEY HAVE CLAIMED COP NIGHT ONE. HOW ARE THEY ANY DIFFERENT

[Mac]

Mac, I read your hyrule game for the first time and had a minor heart attack, but am okay now.

Why? I'm pretty sure my play is nothing like Hyrule since I'm town as fuck here

[pitoli]

Hey pit
"JoaT", "Jack of all trades", or "Jack-of-all-trades"?

Did I fucking stutter the first time?

[Nachomamma8]

You also know that I adore you, so don't paint me a hater when I'm not.

I hope this post wasn't addressed to me.

It was.

WELL THEN

if your idea of adoration is fucking getting the person trying to clear you lynched. then yes!

but this is good to know Nacho, I will take small comfort in this from the grave.

No I like you as a person but you're scum

[GuyInFreezer]

Aw I wanted you to spell it out for me again

I believe pity's claim. I'll elaborate on it later.
For now, lets just say that my full role name is "Town-aligned

fonic

JOAT."

[Nachomamma8]

And Mac - as long as we're positing that there can only be ONE of any particular role in this theme game, why are there TWO vanilla neighbor claims?

NO
I AM THE ONLY NEIGHBOR

[Nachomamma8]

Aw I wanted you to spell it out for me again

I believe pity's claim. I'll elaborate on it later.
For now, lets just say that my full role name is "Town-aligned

fonic

JOAT."

Hey gif, what's the scumteam?

[Nachomamma8]

No me, no Kaze, no Rufflig, no pitoli.

Your pool is Prohawk/Tammy/Mac/Fuzzylogic.

[pitoli]

YOU ARE CLAIMING A HIDING ROLE DURING NIGHT ONE, AND THEY HAVE CLAIMED COP NIGHT ONE. HOW ARE THEY ANY DIFFERENT

I would see that as a balance issue if it was a straight up Cop and Hider, that would be weird to see. But as a 1-shot investigation each? Maybe this is just my inexperience talking.

[pitoli]

Aw I wanted you to spell it out for me again

I believe pity's claim. I'll elaborate on it later.
For now, lets just say that my full role name is "Town-aligned

fonic

JOAT."

And what's your super special reason for not claiming in full?

[Nachomamma8]

You're getting there!

If two people claimed cop in a game, would your first reaction honestly be "ooo they could both be town!"

No, but Minami and I haven't claimed the same thing because our abilities are CLEARLY DIFFERENT WHY IS THAT SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND
So when they claimed I decided to give them the benefit of the doubt.

Different abilities, but JOAT

[Nachomamma8]

Mac, I read your hyrule game for the first time and had a minor heart attack, but am okay now.

Why? I'm pretty sure my play is nothing like Hyrule since I'm town as fuck here

Yeah but you had a lot of posts there and that was scary to see.

[GuyInFreezer]

I'm gonna figure it out later.
But I do think that I nailed the setup.
Will think on it some more and post what I think when I'm sure what I think is right.

P-Edit: for *reasons*