Yay!
In post 365, Wake1 wrote:Being the Tracker, I already knew Yates was lying, and was more than thrilled to go about asking these questions for my own entertainment.
It does not matter. You still did not need to claim.
The reason I role-claimed is because I've caught Scum, and I knew sooner or later Yates was going to get dead if he didn't come off it.
I would have taken his death over yours, given that you are the actual Tracker. If he had died and you had not claimed, we would have been better off.
In post 368, Yates wrote:Look - obviously it wasn't my intent to out Wake. It's not like I could just *assume* there was a tracker in this game. That was just bad luck.
Yeah, but that is what happened. Wake's counter was dumb, but it was still a huge risk to take.
Finally, I think you are overly concerned about having an outed tracker
with a guilty result
. The reason for him to counter at this point is for precisely the reason you wanted him to stay hidden - protection. Assuming there's only 1 other scum, they are now playing a game of Russian Roulette. "Can I kill Wake before he tracks me?"
Or, he remains hidden and crumbs, giving us more usable info without letting the scum know he even exists.
In post 396, Peabody wrote:Aegor is probably DBK's partner because:..Aegor believes Wake, but for some reason feels the need to argue with him? I see this as an OMGUS for finding his scum partner.
My complaint was perfectly reasonable. Just because I think someone is town does not mean that I think that person is flawless.
2) This looks like partner coaching partner.
He was dead already. His new claim is even more absurd (A for his effort, though). It was still possible that DBK was a PR that targeted 2 mastinas but did not want to claim. I was simply acknowledging all possibilities.