Newbie 1455: How We Met The Mafia (Game Over!)

[DoctorPepper]

Vote Count 2.03

Not voting(2)

- JasonWazza, RachMarie

MauriceMoss(1)

- phokdapolees

RachMarie(2)

- MauriceMoss, TwilightsCall

TwilightsCall(1)

- Skelda

phokdolees(1)

- Dessew

Vote History:

MauriceMoss - RachMarie
JasonWazza -
TwilightsCall - MauriceMoss, RachMarie
Skelda - MauriceMoss, TwilightsCall
Dessew - MauriceMoss, UNVOTE, phokdapolees
phokdapolees - RachMarie, MauriceMoss
RachMarie -

With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.

The deadline is Tuesday, January 7, 2014, which is in (expired on 2014-01-07 11:00:00).

Mod notes:

None.

[RachMarie]

Back from TN and back to regular net, but both NS and I are very ill

more later.

[TwilightsCall]

I guess I havn't posted in a while.

Rach, what exactly was the..um...point of your last post? Your responses to Dessew were fine, but I'm struggling to find a purpose to you listing out a whole bunch of information we all already know.

Meanwhile, Jason is playing a great game. That slot is going to be virtually unreadable with all the replacements in it. Maurice continues to deflect and not post anything of value. Phok apologizes again. I'd like to say that I'm having trouble trusting people because I don't have enough information on them to get a proper read, but what's really happening is no one is giving reads for me to trust or not.

Dessew at least is posting with thought, I'm floundering with a lack of new information to work with as my primary two suspects are no longer good, Maurice seems to be pushing a Rach lynch for no reason other than because TeedyKay told him to. Skelda is voting me because I voted someone who I clearly declared I thought was scummy on Day1, and no one else has posted anything memorable.

However, Dessew providing opinions and things to think about has inspired me to not give up. Let me try and dig some information out myself then.

Skelda's ISO:

He was a big fan of Maurice Lynch day 1, hammered Teedy anyways. Jumped back on Maurice at the beginning of Day2, then switched to me for a bad reason.

So Skelda. What are your current thoughts on Maurice? What are your current thoughts on me?

My thoughts on Skelda are that I don't like the way he was seemingly townreading Maurice because of a high volume of fluff posts. I feel like his vote on me was more Target of Opportunity than any sort of conviction, but I could be wrong since...he hasn't told us yet. All in all, I'm going to read him as null. He hasn't posted anything that I can really analyze well (oh this is going to be a pattern isn't it), and as much as I don't like his abandoning his Maurice vote, I feel like its more overreading than it is scummy. Still, he hasn't done anything to convince me that he's town, so null he stays.

phok's ISO:

Only two (of the five lol) posts that he made have any sort of substance to them, through which he casts doubt on me, Rach, and Maurice. He also declares intent to hammer after saying he won't be around to hammer...? I fail to see the purpose of doing so, other than to say 'hey guys I'm not gonna help out, but trust me, I'm helping out.'

I don't think there's a lot on him, but taking into account Bitmap's posts and the above, as well as Dessew's PoE analysis, I think I can comfortably get behind a wagon on him if it starts. Considering the current state of the game, I'd put him near the top of my suspects list.


Other stuff that isn't enough to warrant its own section:

Maurice please post an opinion Not just who you want lynched, I know you want to lynch Rach, but WHY do you want to lynch her?

I really didn't like Jason's contribution, but I'll give him a 'leaning town' because of TSO. I need to stop forgetting that these people replaced in over other people with posts. I keep forgetting that TSO, DMS, and Bitmap were once things.

In the end, my scumreads are shaky and my town reads are mostly gut, but here's the list anyways.

Leaning Scum: Rach, phok
Null: Skelda, MauriceMoss
Leaning Town: Dessew, Jason

I think I can comfortably say that a Rach/Phok scumteam is a possibility. I wouldn't bet money on it, but I don't think its an overly premature call. Only a little premature.

[RachMarie]

Well I was planning to include the analysis too, but I am very sick and have to go bed. My doc gave me a nebulizer treatment today and I am coughing my head off. With NS also being sick, I have not yet gotten my meds, and will do that tomorrow somehow.

[JasonWazza]

Post

Read soon to be updated sig (phone post)

[MauriceMoss]

Oh wow seriously?

[MauriceMoss]

Oh never mind.

[Dessew]

No actual content, because I had to ISO to have something to post noteworthy, just clarifying, that on D1 a mislynch is considered to be better than no lynch for various reasons. (Hint for one of them: do some math.)

[DoctorPepper]

Skelda has been prodded

[Skelda]

A little pathetic that I managed to receive a prod despite all those dodges.

Anyway, I'm wary of voting Rach because I know and have seen first-hand how lynchable she is. That may not be quite fair, but Rach when she is town is an easy target for scum, so I'll need a pretty big case to vote that way.

[RachMarie]

Been very sick first time out of bed. Now back to this

Not sure what you meant by that Dessew, but at my friend's I had almost NO net because they shut off their modem when they were not using it due to lack of gigs and even after we bought some extra gigs at 10 bucks a pop, they still had a tendency to shut down the router most of the time. They are not as tied to the net for either work or play as we are.

When I say wonky wifi at the hotel, I do not mean the speed (which was slow even when it did work), but it just did not work at all more than half the time.

Now onto the game:


RachMarie(3) -

TeedyKay

, MauriceMoss, phokdapolees
MauriceMoss(1) - JasonWazza

TeedyKay

(===[]) - TwilightsCall, RachMarie,

Acidic_TACO

, Dessew, Skelda


On the wagon:

TwilightsCall, RachMarie,

Acidic_TACO

, Dessew, Skelda


Off the wagon:

TeedyKay

, MauriceMoss, phokdapolees, JasonWazza


Dropping the conf town reads we get:

On the wagon
TwilightsCall, RachMarie, Dessew, Skelda


Off the wagon
MauriceMoss, phokdapolees, JasonWazza

in general its one on and one off the wagon

Which means one of
TwilightsCall, RachMarie, Dessew, Skelda is very likely to be scum

and one of
MauriceMoss, phokdapolees, JasonWazza is likely to be scum.


I have a fair bit of towny feel for Dessew and Skelda which leaves TC I need to check on a couple of things on D 1 but IIRC he also had a wagon on him before it shifted over to the dude we lynched.

off the wagon I need to really look at D 1 again who did phokd replace? And I dont have much of a feel at all for Jason which bothers me because usually I get a strong read on him (albeit wrong sometimes but at least its strong lol)

VOTE: TC

[TwilightsCall]

Can I ask what gives you a townread on Skelda?

[RachMarie]

its a weaker town read than some but mainly based on other games where I have played with him hence why it is weaker I still need to relook at D 1 and do some ISO it has been a while with the trip to TN and being so sick, I felt though I had to do what I could since I have been so absent. I do apologize for that, but it never occurred to me to ask her about her net service because I thought EVERYONE was on unlimited net nowadays.

[MauriceMoss]

So is anything going on up in this trailer?

[TwilightsCall]

You know Maurice, you don't have to stop playing just because you aren't at L-1 anymore. If you'd like to actually post some reads, it would help all of us out a lot.

[MauriceMoss]

Yes it is obvious I'm the only one who isn't posting at this time. Please, forgive me.

[TwilightsCall]

I never said you were the only one, I'm saying that since you are around to post you should be sharing opinions. As someone who survived getting to L-1, you are much more likely to get town-read by people, and thus your opinions are a lot more trustworthy than someone who is under suspicion, which happens to be a significant number of the inactive people.

If you're satisfied with being a part of the problem though, I guess no amount of trying to get this game going will help.

[MauriceMoss]

Up to this point everyone is part of the problem which is why I keep checking. I still vote rach even though it may be misguided. We just really need more info.

[Skelda]

Seriously, though. I have nothing to add when I come.

I still think TC is bad and Rach is town.

[DoctorPepper]

Force-replacing Jason Wazza and phokdapolees for reaching 3 prods in this day phase. If anyone would like to help me get replacements, it would be much appreciated. I can no longer extend the deadline because I was only allowed to extend it for one week.

[phokdapolees]

I guess I'll post a reads list, since I don't really know what else I should write. Townreading Dessew and Skelda, and haven't really seen a whole lot out of Jason, but also leaning town. I'm starting to feel a little bit better about Rach with the wagon analysis, and I've been liking Twilight's recent posts. Meanwhile, Maurice hasn't really contributed anything of value in a while after the wagon on him started, so I'm content with my current vote.

Sorry phok, you've qualified for your third prod today.

[phokdapolees]

Aww come on man I was making a post as you made that post

[TwilightsCall]

So deadline is coming up. Anyone feel like working out a lynch of some sort?

[phokdapolees]

Plz let me keep playing DP, if you have to prod me one more time over the course of the game feel free to replace me, but I legitimately was making that post as you posted

Alright, this is your last chance

[DoctorPepper]

GamerRaptor replaces JasonWazza