Mewbie 1472 ~ Game Ovah~

[Hopkirk]

You had already acknowledged the whole "town goon" thing meaning you placed it there for a reason other than purely a random vote.

You're not "attempting to question back at you" unless you actually use questions.

[BipolarChemist]

How are you?

[Hopkirk]

How am i what?
Or are you merely questioning my general feeling at the moment?

[BipolarChemist]

I'd like to leave this up to your interpretation.

[Hopkirk]

In which case i hope you don't expect an answer since you won't tell me what you what an answer to.

[BipolarChemist]

I asked you a straight forward question: "How are you?"

Your refusal to answer my questions is highly suspicious

[Hopkirk]

freudig

[Pharphis]

lol @ above.

I personally don't see anything wrong with BPC's voting on hopkirk atm since we still have plenty of time for a lynch and more reads is always better than lynching who you find scummy immediately.

I also had no problem with BPC's keeping me at L-1 for reads even though he had a "slight town" read on me

[Hopkirk]

You don't vote people who you think are scum.
You don't vote people without justification.

Those are my views.

[Pharphis]

Is "to pressure" a satisfactory justification?

[penguin_alien]

1.05

With Nine Players alive.. It takes five to lynch

Voting:

King Kenny - Guyett, Alexcellent, cheesetovey, Pharphis [4] [L-1]
XLAV - Karlos4 [1]
Karlos4 - Hopkirk, XLAV [2]
cheesetovey -
BipolarChemist -
Pharphis -
Alexcellent -
Hopkirk - BipolarChemist [1]
Guyett -

Not Voting:

King Kenny [1]

Countdowns

(expired on 2014-02-04 18:31:00)

[Hopkirk]

Is "to pressure" a satisfactory justification?

I think i've already said this but- one vote on someone that's just a vote with no reasoning behind it isn't pressure.

[XLAV]

Mewbie 1472
Moderator: Malakittens
Back Up Moderator: Penguin_alien

[insert some type of cat pic here~]

Players:

King Kenny
XLAV
Karlos4
cheesetovey 1
BipolarChemist
Pharphis

Alexecllent

FSnake

(SE)

Hopkirk (SE)
Guyett 1 (IC)

Semi-experienced (SE) players are here because they have completed at least two games.
The Inexperience Challenged (IC) player is here because he/she has completed at least five games, has been a part of MafiaScum for at least three months, and has elected to be this teaching role. It is recommended they follow the Being a Good IC guidelines.

Playing in the snow: (9/9)

Spoiler:

King Kenny
XLAV
Karlos4
cheesetovey 1
BipolarChemist
Pharphis
FSnake (SE)
Hopkirk (SE)
Guyett 1 (IC)

Safely hidden in an igloo (0/9):

Spoiler:

Back Up Replacements:

Spoiler:

None

King Lenny hasn't posted anything in a while.

[XLAV]

Woops. Sorry about my last post. I didn't mean to quote that.

[Guyett]

Bipolar is looking town to me currently.
If he was keeping Pharaph at L-1 knowing pharaph was gambitting to fish for scum then I think it is a pro town thing to do

[Hopkirk]

Not only did he not see the gambit (see 23) but he says he didn't think para was scum.
But he's not really a scumread for me either.

@Xlav: I know, I'm getting a bad feeling that he's getting replaced- where all his actions will be excused as "oh he was bad town" rather than him responding.

[BipolarChemist]

So are we just supposed to wait him out? It's been 3 days. Either he's given up or he's forgotten about the game.

[Hopkirk]

We wait for them to get prodded. We can do other stuff while we wait but my top scumread atm is king.

[Guyett]

Our Mods V/La ends today so hopefully she'll be on to distribute some prods and whatnot

[Pharphis]

Cheese can you give a scum list with reasons behind each point?

[cheesetovey]

Cheese can you give a scum list with reasons behind each point?

here it is :

guyett is null, he hasn't posted enough for me to get a good read.
alexcellant is town for me. He has been working pro-town by scumhunting ever since he got here and that qualifies him for a town spot.
pharphis is town. I first thought he was scum after the gambit, but with karlos he did seem to be trying to catch scum.
king kenny is my top scum, becuase he is posting at a minimum which makes it look to me like he is lurking, he also said he was gonna use his scumhunting skills in one post, which he never did use. I also asked him for his reads which he did not give.
XLAV is my second scumread because he jumped on two wagons I believe, the first one on pharphis he didn't give very good reasoning.
karl is leaning scum, I actually didn't get a read on karl. I'm going on a gut feeling.
Hopkirk is town. He asks alot of questions which is good, he is scumhunting and is very helpful for town.
BPC null. I think bpc kept pharphis at L-1 to get him talking. That's what you guys said at least, I think. That is a pro-town move, but then he votes my top town read hopkirk and I don't know what to think of him.

[Alexcellent]

Prod dodge! I'll post tonight after work.

[XLAV]

Wagons are meant to be jumped on.

[Alexcellent]

@XLAV, what is your experience with mafia? How long have you been playing for? You may have already mentioned this but I couldn't find it anywhere in the thread and I'm curious

@BPC, what do you think of Hopkirk right now?

[BipolarChemist]

I'm currently neutral on Hopkirk. I see a lot of questioning coming from him, but coming with that is I don't see any questioning of him. Any conversation is good at this point, with both Kenny and Karlos not posting in about 4 days and seemingly nothing happening about it.

I don't know how to proceed at this point with nothing happening. There is the option of hammering but we still have time and I'd like to hear from Kenny. I'd also like Karlos' opinion, but neither is going to happen.


Guyett: You are the first vote on Kenny, do you find your vote to be justified more so than before?
Cheese: Who would you prefer to see lynched?
XLAV: Who do you see as scummier, Karlos or Kenny?