Mewbie 1472 ~ Game Ovah~

[Hopkirk]

"I don't see any questioning of him. ": So how is other people not asking me qs my fault? You were voting me and couldn't even give any reason for me being scum.

All of bipolar's qs have been answered before (recently), seems like bios trying to look town by asking "town" questions.

@Mod: Can we have the kenny and karlos prods now?

[BipolarChemist]

I'm sorry that I'm trying to get people talking, because frankly it seems pretty dead right now.

[Hopkirk]

You're only trying to get people to talk about stuff they've already said.

Hey bipolar, want to do a read list?

[Guyett]

@ bipolar Alex asked the same question to me when he entered. I still think my RVS became justified.

[BipolarChemist]

You're only trying to get people to talk about stuff they've already said.

Hey bipolar, want to do a read list?

And you're trying to shut down any conversation at all. I can do a read list when I get home later today.

[BipolarChemist]

@ bipolar Alex asked the same question to me when he entered. I still think my RVS became justified.

I asked you the same question because Kenny is now at L-1 and has clammed up. If Kenny did post again, do you think he could change your mind?

[Hopkirk]

“I see a lot of questioning coming from him”
“And you're trying to shut down any conversation at all.”
Pick one.

I want to see original questioning. For example, you asked Cheese who he wanted lynched when he’d said 4 post before that Kenny is his top scum. What does this actually help you with? You don’t seem to be hunting scum.

@Bipolar: What could have changed guyett’s opinion when Kenny hasn’t done anything else? The wagon has one more person than before.

[Pharphis]

I may have already said this but BPC is right in that no one is asking hopkirk many questions and he is asking plenty. It's a little surprising, tbh, but I'm also guilty of not really asking many or any questions.
I feel the same way about guyett but he hasn't posted anything scummy for me to get a read from.
They both seem town simply for being active enough and asking the right questions, but with neither of them really being questioned much it makes me a bit uneasy.

Still ,it's hard to question those who are participating when there are two people who have been under the spotlight since their first posts and have now been absent for days.

[Guyett]

he claimed? I missed it

[Hopkirk]

"no one is asking hopkirk many questions "
This reflects badly on the rest of you, not on me. I can't ask myself questions and

you're choosing not to

ask me any.

Pedit: Who claimed?

[Guyett]

Kenny hasn't claimed...

my opinion on him hasn't changed

[Hopkirk]

I think you misread the word clammed.

@Bipolar and pand: You say i'm not being asked questions but...don't ask me questions? Ask me questions if you want questions asked of me or you're just massive hypocrites.

[BipolarChemist]

“I see a lot of questioning coming from him”
“And you're trying to shut down any conversation at all.”
Pick one.

I want to see original questioning. For example, you asked Cheese who he wanted lynched when he’d said 4 post before that Kenny is his top scum. What does this actually help you with? You don’t seem to be hunting scum.

@Bipolar: What could have changed guyett’s opinion when Kenny hasn’t done anything else? The wagon has one more person than before.

My questioning may not be original but the point is to actually get some posting. Opinions change and thoughts are everything. Cheese may say Kenny is his top scum suspect, but getting him to expand on the subject may lead to something.

Silence can be just as revealing as speaking and Guyett was the first vote on Kenny. His opinion on the matter could matter greatly.

When barely any posting is happening, not many questions can really be asked because there is nothing to question.

[Hopkirk]

So you want me to answer what? You're still not responding to this question.

It's a bit annoying that the scummiest people both need prods.

[Pharphis]

I think you misread the word clammed.

@Bipolar and pand: You say i'm not being asked questions but...don't ask me questions? Ask me questions if you want questions asked of me or you're just massive hypocrites.

You keep changing the abbreviation for me and it's surprisingly confusing. "Phar" works
Ok, here's a question... Why should we not lynch you?

So you want me to answer what? You're still not responding to this question.

It's a bit annoying that the scummiest people both need prods.

Answer what?

VOTE: Hopkirk

[Pharphis]

I'm also not saying we shouldn't let kenny off for this. I'm not saying we HAVE to lynch kenny today, either, but hopkirk is making me uncomfortable

[Hopkirk]

Burden of proof.
You have provided no reason that i am scum so there is no evidence i need to prove wrong. It lies with you to provide reasoning.

"Answer what?"
You're not even making sense now. You two say you don't like the way i'm not being asked any questions and that makes me scummy- that's basically saying i'm scummy because of YOUR actions rather than mine which is a basic fallacy.

I'm asking him what he wants answered as obviously he wouldn't be saying "Hop should be asked more questions" without asking questions about my motivate or actions unless he's stupid/really hypocritical/scum.

What is making you uncomfortable. You haven't said why anything I've done is bad you've only said why things you+others do in relation to me is bad.

[Pharphis]

I misunderstood what your post was saying hence the "answer what".
I think I get it now.

I feel like you're directing the way the game is going by asking a lot of questions but not being questioned yourself. I understand that it is hypocritical in a sense to say that others should be asking you more questions, but that's how I feel about it.

Anyway,

VOTE: king kenny

[Hopkirk]

Why would i look suspicious for not being asked questions? If you view not being asked questions as scummy then logic should clearly tell you that it's a reflection on the people NOT asking the questions.

Even when i directly ask for questions you have none. What questions do you want me to be asked?

[Pharphis]

That's because I can't think of any atm. That's a good sign (imo) but the point remains that while you're interacting with others not enough people are interacting with you. I want to gauge what others say to you and how you respond to them, not just how others respond to your questions.

I'm aware i'm making a bit of a deal out of essentially nothing but I'm bored after a few days of waiting for players to return

[Hopkirk]

So you want to explain the logic that nobody in the game thinking there's anything to suggest I'm scum makes me scummy? Because if it's "bc he hasn't been accused" rather tha "because of what he's said/done" then it's not real logic.

[Pharphis]

I don't believe I said you were scummy. I'm just saying the interaction has been one way

[Hopkirk]

A vote implies logical backing. If it doesn't then it has no reason to be.

[Pharphis]

A vote implies logical backing. If it doesn't then it has no reason to be.

logical backing = very broad term.

My backing is I wanted to see how you or others would react. It did not say you were scum

[Hopkirk]

Conclusions?