Scummies 2014 - Nomination Thread!

[EspeciallyTheLies]

nth Guyett!

Awesome flavor; very engaging!

[fferyllt]

Nominate Untrod Tripod's POTUS Mafi for best flavor. As a spectator, I enjoyed the hell out of how the roles and abilities fit the theme. It looked like the players had a great time with the flavor, too.

[fferyllt]

Nominate Untrod Tripod's POTUS Mafi for best flavor. As a spectator, I enjoyed the hell out of how the roles and abilities fit the theme. It looked like the players had a great time with the flavor, too.

[fferyllt]

Nominate Untrod Tripod's POTUS Mafi for best flavor. As a spectator, I enjoyed the hell out of how the roles and abilities fit the theme. It looked like the players had a great time with the flavor, too.

[fferyllt]

sorry about the triple post. gateway timeout induced?

[Untrod Tripod]

okay, we get it! jeez!

[Alduskkel]

I'll

2nd

that. Lizard people controlling the government is just too perfect for a game themed on the POTUSes, plus UT's flavor read like excerpts from a wonderfully clichéd conspiracy theory/sci-fi thriller novel.

[Oversoul]

Lol fferylt

3rd

[bubbajack8]

Nominate This scum team of T S O, sthar8, and Majiffy for Best Performance Scum Group. As the mod I enjoyed watching T S O and sthar8 overcome Majiffy's early lynch and eventually win the game. Town literally admits they had no chance at lynching T S O, or sthar8. Their play was absolutely amazing.

[Guyett]

2nd

(grumble grumble stoopid guyett fake hammer)

[Jake from State Farm]

Do games have to be completed to be nom'd?

[bubbajack8]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=30907

Yes.

[mastin2]

Nominate kanyeknowsbest for Paragon of Mafia Hunters

.
(Or perhaps

Most Memorable Moment

, though Paragon's more applicable in my opinion.)

Not only did he nail every single scum in kdub's Mobile Suit Gundam SEED game...but he

also

pulled a

picture-perfect Hoopla gambit

. He fakeclaimed PGO to avoid the nightkill (and did so successfully!) and got the final scum to admit to being scum. (Although, as mentioned, he was already fairly certain of it anyway.) To put it another way, the game would have assuredly not been a town win if not for him playing his cards EXACTLY right.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

SECOND KANYE!

[Cabd]

Thirded, and those that think town can't gambit can eat shit, because that was perfectly done.

[Belisarius]

4th Kanye

Although I'd intended to nom him even without the vengekill.

[talah]

5th kanye

Marvellous effort that.

[Venmar]

Nominate kanyeknowsbest for Paragon of Mafia Hunters

.
(Or perhaps

Most Memorable Moment

, though Paragon's more applicable in my opinion.)

Not only did he nail every single scum in kdub's Mobile Suit Gundam SEED game...but he

also

pulled a

picture-perfect Hoopla gambit

. He fakeclaimed PGO to avoid the nightkill (and did so successfully!) and got the final scum to admit to being scum. (Although, as mentioned, he was already fairly certain of it anyway.) To put it another way, the game would have assuredly not been a town win if not for him playing his cards EXACTLY right.

Paragon is a body of work award, I would disqualify this nomination if it's based off of only one game, which is what you made it sound like.

[Desperado]

You can add Faraday's A Song of Ice and Fire uPick to it, then. He balled out there too.

[Matias]

Kanye is really a fantastic mafia player across the board, more so than people give him credit for

[pieguyn]

6TH KANYE

[AGar]

Nominate kanyeknowsbest for Paragon of Mafia Hunters

.
(Or perhaps

Most Memorable Moment

, though Paragon's more applicable in my opinion.)

Not only did he nail every single scum in kdub's Mobile Suit Gundam SEED game...but he

also

pulled a

picture-perfect Hoopla gambit

. He fakeclaimed PGO to avoid the nightkill (and did so successfully!) and got the final scum to admit to being scum. (Although, as mentioned, he was already fairly certain of it anyway.) To put it another way, the game would have assuredly not been a town win if not for him playing his cards EXACTLY right.

Paragon is a body of work award, I would disqualify this nomination if it's based off of only one game, which is what you made it sound like.

Usually the Paragon nom comes off of one game and then the BOW is considered at the end, from what I recall.

[Belisarius]

Even if Kanye does nothing for the rest of 2014 doing nothing but posting cat macros, I'd still count this one game as reason enough to disregard the rest.

[mastin2]

Even if Kanye does nothing for the rest of 2014 doing nothing but posting cat macros, I'd still count this one game as reason enough to disregard the rest.

Let's face it, kanye's enough of a badass that he could probably lynch entire scumteams just from posting cat macros anyway.

[Venmar]

Basis of the award was made on one game barely 1 month into year is all i'm saying, never said Kanye is a bad player.