NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[sthar8]

I want Zekrom to shoot GC Marquis or EPM.

Why not RC? And why marquis, if the plan is for fish to save the target?

[sthar8]

star and I have never been on the same team

are you scum this game?

are you freaking kidding me

this is more along your likeable scum game than the 1 time I saw you as town

The only time you saw me as town was when I replaced into a 100 page game right before lylo. I had to get serious there fast. I was just wondering if we get to be on the same team finally.

Your reaction looks good though

(also I totally sent a bitch-pm to desp when he sent me a town role. You can check with him in post. I was kinda hoping to be scum with you. Then I realized that ABR wouldn't have replaced out if he were scum.)

[RadiantCowbells]

Why RC?

Let's hear this, no go on.

[Ythan]

Yep, I think my vote on Fish is now concrete.

Why did you wait so long to post this you weirdo.

[Untrod Tripod]

and UT I thought I was a town read for you when did that change

pedit everyone is scum and everyone needs to die

look, it's day 1 and all I have to go on here is reactions. you seemed to be discrediting the chained vig plan, and that's the textbook scum reaction. sorry dude.

[sthar8]

Why RC?

Let's hear this, no go on.

Same reasons as pacman:
1. I have no indication of your alignment
2. You're not contributing
3. There is no indication that you're planning on contributing
4. My knowledge of you as a player suggests that you will be a liability to the town.

Understand, the plan is not for you to die, but if you do I'm not going to cry over it.

[Nikanor]

oh hey so i read the game
Formerfish is scum but we're not lynching him because he claimed The Doctor. he's saying FUCK way too many times for it to be any flavour of sincere.
UT is probably scum protecting Formerfish with this plan. There's no way in hell UT wouldn't assume the presence of a scum roleblocker if he was town.
marquis is town so i'm not sure why he's on the table for a lynch or kill at all. pisskop would be a really good kill, fwiw. killing scum is great usually.

[Nikanor]

dethy is town too, don't kill that guy.

[Untrod Tripod]

hey I'm still scumreading Fish, I just don't want to lynch him until at least Day 2 because there's a chance he's not lying about the doctor claim

There's no way in hell UT wouldn't assume the presence of a scum roleblocker if he was town.

holy wifom batman no I wouldn't

[Untrod Tripod]

he's saying FUCK way too many times for it to be any flavour of sincere.

and you may be right, but this will not be why

[Nikanor]

pretty sure that waiting to lynch a doctor claim until day two is completely pointless. have you never played a normal game before or what.

[Nikanor]

like assuming the scum have at least one non-catatonic member (which might be a stretch in this game? idk), there's no way they're killing formerfish ever. i'd rather get this shit taken care of now and not have to settle for a sub-par lynch today, thanks.

[Untrod Tripod]

I actually don't play normal games that often. Explain.

[Formerfish]

So you would rather lynch the doctor day 1? That seems like an interesting strategy.

[Nikanor]

I actually don't play normal games that often. Explain.

like assuming the scum have at least one non-catatonic member (which might be a stretch in this game? idk), there's no way they're killing formerfish ever.

doctor is a nearly useless role until about halfway through the game, when some power roles are revealed and cetera.
and there's no way we're letting this guy live to halfway through the game.
lynch him today, please and thanks.

[Nikanor]

So you would rather lynch the doctor day 1? That seems like an interesting strategy.

give me a FUCKing break you FUCKing scumFUCK

[Untrod Tripod]

like assuming the scum have at least one non-catatonic member (which might be a stretch in this game? idk), there's no way they're killing formerfish ever.

doctor is a nearly useless role until about halfway through the game, when some power roles are revealed and cetera.
and there's no way we're letting this guy live to halfway through the game.
lynch him today, please and thanks.

does not compute

[Nikanor]

your computer is broken.

[Untrod Tripod]

no your brainputer is broken

if scum will never kill him and he's not useful until halfway through the game I'm not sure what the issue is here by your logic

[Ythan]

Let's not play this entire game with Formerfish okay?

[Nikanor]

my wordputer is broken.

an unrevealed doctor is useful. a revealed doctor is not.
let's pretend for a second that the scum don't have a roleblocker/strongarm/whathaveyou. do you plan on letting him live until night three or four or whenever the scum decide it's not worth letting him live?

[pirate mollie]

my wordputer is broken.

an unrevealed doctor is useful. a revealed doctor is not.
let's pretend for a second that the scum don't have a roleblocker/strongarm/whathaveyou. do you plan on letting him live until night three or four or

whenever the scum decide it's not worth letting him live?

why wouldn't we do this? it boggles the mind. let scum take care of him and wrt bold kind of contradicts what you said about scum never nking him yeah?

jesus christ

VOTE: nikanor

[Ythan]

What's the vote for?

[Marquis]

a really stupid attempted rhetorical question

[Desperado]

bump