Mewbie 1461 ~ Game Ovah

[Kublai Khan]

No, I didn't have to worry about the doctor or the tracker because I'm a vt. I was incredibly surprised to see that the tracker died instead of the doctor.

And yes, I am pleading with her to re-think the game. If she votes to lynch me, then town loses the game. She said she was leaning that way.

[Aisa]

I feel like I owe an apology to the town; I've been so indecisive and paranoid these last days.

KK, you're doing a pretty good job at swaying me. I'm not sold on Drake yet, but you did change my opinion.
And looking at your ISO, you do have some towntells.

Drake's post 724 is

bad

. What I said at the beginning of the day:

Starting from now, I'm going to treat every single of your posts that contains confirmation bias (or posts with obviously flawed logic, or basically anything that gives scum an advantage) as a scumtell.

Not

one

of his posts this day was decent. He just continues to hilariously try to frame KK by using some random reasoning. It feels less like "I have X and Y evidence about KK and therefore want to lynch him" and more like "I want to lynch KK and therefore I'm gonna think of a reason to do so".

I need to think about it a little more, but I

promise

I will have a definitive answer by tomorrow. Consider my pseudo-vote on Drake.

[Quill]

Finally went back through the game and looked at both KK and Drake, as well as how Bert interacted with them. And the conclusion I've come to is that Drake is our last scum.

I can show all my work if I have to, but here's the short version:

In order for KK to be scum, he would have had to have been playing a very long, very elaborate gambit with us all the way back since Day 2. He acts exactly the way town would in Twilight after thinking he's lynched, immediately bounces back with some long reads but tells town to lynch him anyway to be safe, tries to reason with TSO and I on Day 3 before very begrudgingly giving in, and has spent this day patiently waiting things out. That's not to say scum!Kublai could not have done all those things, but it would not have been optimal play, especially the Day 3 stuff. He takes an amount of time to come to conclusions that is too patient and spread out to be fake, in my opinion.

Drake, on the other hand, comes off much better early on, where I can attribute most of his blunders to newness. But he does defend Bert a little bit on Day 1, and after Bert's dead, he's very flaily, lurking until the end of Day 3, hammering Picard, going rabid for Zekrom's lynch, and now grabbing on any thread of an argument against KK that he can. Again, it's possible this could be new-town play, but I think in the aggregate it adds up to a convincing argument that he's our scum.

My pseudo-vote is firmly on Drake, and I'm ready to make it a real vote when town's ready.

[Aisa]

I think we're ready to lynch Drake.
I don't think I could be more convinced with the lynch than I am right now, so... let's do this.
VOTE: Drake Crusader

[Quill]

Fingers crossed.

Vote: Drake Crusader

[Kublai Khan]

Well, im not scum.

Aisa, any last doubts about quill?

[Malakittens]

4.02

With Four alive it takes 3 votes to lynch

Voting:

*Quill -
*Drake Crusader - Aisa, Quill, [2] [L-1]
*Aisa -
*Kublai Khan -

Not Voting:

Drake Crusader, Kublai Khan [2]

Countdowns

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2014-02-16 22:25:00)

[Kublai Khan]

Eh.. Maybe I'm just overly paranoid.

Time to end it.

Vote: Drake Crusader

[Drake Crusader]

:/

[Malakittens]

Final VC of Day 4

With Four alive it takes 3 votes to lynch

Voting:

*Quill -
*Drake Crusader - Aisa, Quill, [2] [L-1]
*Aisa -
*Kublai Khan -

Not Voting:

Drake Crusader, Kublai Khan [2]

Countdowns

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2014-02-16 22:25:00)

Drake Crusader was lynched. He was a Mafia Goon.

This means town has won!

Quill, Aisa, Kublai Khan were all Vanilla Townies.

[T S O]

Fucking hell.
I want to offer you all an apology.

That was so fucking STUPID of me that I actually punched a wall and drew blood with my rage.

You guys seriously pulled it out.

Aisa and Quill. Excellent.

[Quill]

Well, that's a relief. GG, y'all. Sorry for tunneling in on Zekrom on Day 3; we could have been out of here a lot sooner if we'd just listened to KK.

And Kublai, thanks for keeping my brain intact by not having been playing an elaborate mind game with us ever since we almost lynched you on Day 2.

[Dean Harper]

WHEW.
Thank you all for an excellent first game back on the site!
That was kind of a nail-biter after T S O didn't protect me!
An excellent town besides a couple blunders
Glad you guys managed to work things out and find the last scum.
Cheers and good luck in all your future games!

[Bert]

Congratulations, Town!

Drake, great effort from you in a dire situation I left you in.

Thanks everyone for the game!!! <3

[Aisa]

I'm glad we made the right choice at the end.

Aisa, are you an alt?

I actually have another account, with which I played a couple games some months ago.
I replaced out from my first game (in a way I'm not really proud of) because I was the main suspect D1.
I then joined a second game, from which I replaced out too.
I don't think I'm ever going to use that old account again.

...So I guess I'm technically an alt

[Bert]

I can relate with you about the alt thing and being ashamed about replacing out on an old acc

I do think town played well.

T S O nailed me D1 too.

[T S O]

you just seemed a bit off, Bert, but it was never concrete enough until you jumped on me. That was when I knew - the transition was completely fake.

[Drake Crusader]

Good game mates! Nice playing with you all!

[Captain Picard]

I can't believe it took you that long to kill him after that hammer on me D1, I thought for sure he woulda been a quicklynch on D2

[Zekrom25]

yeah

[Zekrom25]

Drake Crusader is the major target as long as Drake is alive you generally lose

[Zekrom25]

why would you keep Drake alive for so long ?

[Zekrom25]

good game well played everyone

[Aisa]

You have no idea of just how paranoid I was D4. I ended up finding an excuse for every single scummy action Drake ever did.
I also didn't really think Bert was scummy, I thought he had a reason for acting in the way he did. What convinced me that the lynch was at least viable was when he contradicted himself in I-don't-remember-which post, but I still had no idea of what he would flip.

[Zekrom25]

why did i get lynched ?

we could have won day 3