NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[bazinga]

we can vote mala

[pirate mollie]

we can vote mala

[Malakittens]

we can vote mala

No.

Mala is busy as fuck and doesn't have a day off until wed, go screw yourself for saying I'm scum when I have very little time~

[Malakittens]

I'm also just not in the mood to argue with you over the fact I prod dodge and you just now want to lynch me due to it.

[Ythan]

If you're a kitten why do you live in a fishbowl? Did you eat the fish and move in? What about water?

[pirate mollie]

I didn't even remember you were playing.

I would feel wonderful lynching you I think.

VOTE: mala

[Ythan]

Mollie of all the things going on.

[pirate mollie]

she has been absent ythan think about it

[Ythan]

Thought about it. Decided to lynch scum.

[evilpacman18]

Jesus. Remind me never to play two games again. Catching up.

[evilpacman18]

read the last 10 pages. sthar caught my attention.

I don't like sthar. He posted a read list "in the interest of transparency" meaning he's more concerned with peoples' perceptions of him than posting reads because they convict him into lynching/defending certain people, etc.
Also he's got like a third of the playerlist chalked up to VI (including myself, which I can't remember playing with him but whatever) which normally indicates a town read (it is a VILLAGE idiot, after all), but in the case of someone like fish, who he says he doesn't really believe the claim, meaning he's reading him as scum, it's either a mislabeled null-read or intentional dissonance. Either way, his dismissal of so many players as VI is some indication that, again, he's more interested in looking actively engaged than being so. zekrom's 959 is more typically dull posting from him but I think he accidentally tripped over the discovery that sthar doesn't actually have much at all and for a full playerlist reads post, it leaves me at least still quite unsure of what sthar thinks.

Oh well in 987 sthar specifically says "VI is not a read"
well
1. yes it is (it is a VILLAGE idiot, after all)
2. so you completely avoided posting reads in your read list

it's interesting who fell for those posts and started town reading you when they're both terrible too. Maybe some scumbuddies in there, who knows

I'm going to sleep, it's 4:30AM but I had a few other people I was gonna look into. Needa figure out UT, not reading Deathnote as scum so much anymore and zekrom will sort itself out so my UT read isn't as bound to association tells, have to re-evaluate. Don't like Gooner. or pisskop a little

Lots of townreads too:
Marquis, mollie, elyse, nikanor, ythan, RC, Yates, Fish, GC, PV...

good night

[Porochaz]

mod

Desp can you clarify the deadline here. In your first day post you say the deadline is the 17th and every deadline would not fall on a weekend yet in every other post you have said deadline will be the 16th on the sunday?

I have given up here. You all have 24 hours to say who you want to vig by underlining it. Zekrom doesn't get a vote and if you don't do it by tomorrow 1pm GMT you forfeit your vote. Sound fair? I don't care.

vig - Radiant Cowbells

[Ythan]

Sthar and Zekrom are scum together. Which one has more votes now...

[Ythan]

Marquis (4) - DeathNote, PeregrineV, Porochaz, Untrod Tripod
Sthar8 (3) - Elyse, Green Crayons, pisskop
Formerfish (3) - Nikanor, Matias, Ythan
Zekrom25 (2) - Formerfish, Marquis
Untrod Tripod (1) - Zekrom25
Elyse (1) - Gooner
RadiantCowbells (1) - RadiantCowbells
Malakittens (1) - pirate mollie

Not Voting (5) - OhGodMyLife, Malakittens, sthar8, evilpacman18, tman2nd

[Ythan]

I'm gut reading Ythan as scum, so I could go for that lynch, but I think there are better targets.

That you would suggest a gut lynch in this game defies my expectations of sentience.

[Ythan]

Yeah not gonna vote Marquis. Sthar's trying to discredit her, and doing a poor job of it, in order to deflect some heat from himself. I believe that this will be a more constructive alternative.

VOTE: Sthar8

[Green Crayons]

A suitable alternative is not one that is not as good. GC u r dumb.

Willfully obtuse Ythan is willfully obtuse.

-

You

think Formerfish is "obvious scum." (Post 1041.)
-

You

wanted obvious scum (Fish) lynched, or a "suitable alternative." (Post 1041.)
-

I

am saying sthar is scum, and have not subscribed to your Formfish is "obvious scum." At most, Formerfish's play on balance has been scummy, but far from "obvious scum." (Post 709.)
-

I

am saying that because I think sthar is a pretty good scum candidate, and because

you

yourself have acknowledged that sthar gave you the "heebie jeebies," (Post 1032)

I

think that sthar fits under

your

request for a "suitable alternative."

-----

Literally GC walled to make the point that another character "gave me the heebie jeebies" and that I should lynch them instead of scum. And has done shit else lately.

Is it possible for you to be more bad at being scum?

[Desperado]

mod

Desp can you clarify the deadline here. In your first day post you say the deadline is the 17th and every deadline would not fall on a weekend yet in every other post you have said deadline will be the 16th on the sunday?

I have given up here. You all have 24 hours to say who you want to vig by underlining it. Zekrom doesn't get a vote and if you don't do it by tomorrow 1pm GMT you forfeit your vote. Sound fair? I don't care.

vig - Radiant Cowbells

Yes, sorry; the deadline should be Monday February 17. I will edit all VC's to reflect this.

[Green Crayons]

I have given up here. You all have 24 hours to say who you want to vig by underlining it. Zekrom doesn't get a vote and if you don't do it by tomorrow 1pm GMT you forfeit your vote. Sound fair? I don't care.

@Zekrom's night kill:

I've whittled my list of acceptable deaths down to PeregrineV and EPM. I'm happy for either to go, so I don't care if he makes a game-time decision as to which gets picked.

-

vig: PeregrineV

-

vig: evilpacman18

I agree with whoever said we shouldn't narrow it down to one person. So I'm giving options!

[Desperado]

The deadline for Day 1 is Monday, February 17th, at 8:00 PM EST. With 21 people alive, it takes 11 to lynch. Deadline in (expired on 2014-02-17 20:00:00).

^This deadline counter is accurate; sorry for any confusion.

[Malakittens]

I didn't even remember you were playing.

I would feel wonderful lynching you I think.

VOTE: mala

nu.

VOTE: Mollie

[Nikanor]

I didn't even remember you were playing.

I would feel wonderful lynching you I think.

VOTE: mala

nu.

VOTE: Mollie

can you two please be serious. these votes are both awful.

Vote: sthar8.

[RadiantCowbells]

Can we not vote Sthar right now please?

[Yates]

vote zekrom

the more we extend this day the more Im wondering the point in this whole vig shot deal. I dont trust him to do whats right if he's town, which I have never really felt and I don't see the big advantage of doing it is.

Wait. Why would Town be worried about a vig claim? Why wouldn't you let scum worry about Zek? The way I see it he's either the vig, as he claims, or he is scum and the real vig is [properly] not countering. You know why? Vig's counter claim with a shot in the night. Bottom line; if Zek is scum he is likely killed tonight. If Zek is NOT scum, he is NOT killed tonight and proves his role in the morning.

Am I missing something here?

FoS: Porochaz

It's the weekend and I'm doing a lousy job of catching up but in reading backwards this popped up as crazy.

[Desperado]

bump