Mini 1564 - Nyctapolis (~owari~)

[InsidiousLemons]

FTL, why do you think, purely from my reads, that I'm newbtown? Also, I feel like tanz's post could be interpreted as either newbtown or newbscum.

[Faster Than Light]

i'm judging from all your posts (not many) and all of tanz posts

i just picked the most recent, appropriate and relevant example to quote.

[Faster Than Light]

also, you said it yourself. tanz post can be newb town or newb scum. but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

there is a significantly larger possibility of him scum in comparison to you.

and looking at the other posts he has posted, not very townish either

[dwsnsl5]

This game posts more often than I am used to. so sorry for not being here. Plus, I was in the city all day and couldn't post much. but just from reading through everything once more I am beginning to a few many couplets.
Cheery Dog loves Iamsteve
InsidiousLemons loves Remilia Scarlet
No one loves Shattered Viewpoint
and IL and FTL don't really know their true infatuations with tanz.
did I get that right?

And even though there is like 5 pages of posts, there isn't much content. I realize I haven't contributed much either, but that will be fixed soon enough.
For Tanz,
in your second post you said that you knew what you were doing. Then later, after IL says something about you, you revert to "im new and nervous"..Why the flip flop?

[dwsnsl5]

Sorry Midnight here,

This game posts more often than I am used to, so sorry for not being here. Plus, I was in the city all day and couldn't post much. But, just from reading through everything once more I am beginning to see a few couplets.
Cheery Dog loves Iamsteve
InsidiousLemons loves Remilia Scarlet
No one loves Shattered Viewpoint
and IL and FTL don't really know their true infatuations with tanz.
did I get that right?

And even though there is like 5 pages of posts, there isn't much content. I realize I haven't contributed much either, but that will be fixed soon enough.


And for Tanz,
In your second post you said that you knew what you were doing; then later, after IL says something about you, you revert to "im new and nervous"..Why the flip flop?

[Cheery Dog]

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

[undo]

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

Would newb scum make a t/s list on page 4?

[Cheery Dog]

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

Would newb scum make a t/s list on page 4?

I don't understand why anybody ever makes t/s lists, having the ability to make them isn't alignment dependant.

[Tanzklaue]

For Tanz,
in your second post you said that you knew what you were doing. Then later, after IL says something about you, you revert to "im new and nervous"..Why the flip flop?

I am new and nervous on this site. i have played my fair share of mafia games.

up to now, not much of interest happened except remilia bleeding town and the fake vig shot. can't say too much about the rest, they are null for me (have even all people who signed up posted yet?)

[InsidiousLemons]

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

I'd also like to know this.

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

Would newb scum make a t/s list on page 4?

I don't understand why anybody ever makes t/s lists, having the ability to make them isn't alignment dependant.

I like to make read lists simply because I find them easier to read than a paragraph of reads. I do agree with the last bit.

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

Would newb scum make a t/s list on page 4?

Why wouldn't they? I understand now that it's certainly not the best time to make one, but why would it define whether you're scum or town?

[InsidiousLemons]

For Tanz,
in your second post you said that you knew what you were doing. Then later, after IL says something about you, you revert to "im new and nervous"..Why the flip flop?

I am new and nervous on this site. i have played my fair share of mafia games.

up to now, not much of interest happened except remilia bleeding town and the fake vig shot. can't say too much about the rest, they are null for me (have even all people who signed up posted yet?)

I feel like I'm giving you too much credit, but I just can't see you as scum.
Also, yes, everyone's posted, but not everyone's posted much of substance.

[Empking]

but your post can only be newb town. see the difference?

Why can it only be from newb town?

Would newb scum make a t/s list on page 4?

I don't understand why anybody ever makes t/s lists, having the ability to make them isn't alignment dependant.

Definitely voting CD. I think the change of subject to 'ability' is something only scum would do.

[InsidiousLemons]

@Mod: VC Please?

[undo]

I don't understand why anybody ever makes t/s lists, having the ability to make them isn't alignment dependant.

So you're saying players should only post things that are unquestionably indicative of a town alignment? What sense does that make?

Should we just refrain from scumhunting? Because "having the ability" to scumhunt isn't exclusive to townies either.

[Cheery Dog]

I don't understand why anybody ever makes t/s lists, having the ability to make them isn't alignment dependant.

So you're saying players should only post things that are unquestionably indicative of a town alignment? What sense does that make?

Should we just refrain from scumhunting? Because "having the ability" to scumhunt isn't exclusive to townies either.

I'm stating that scum are able to think along lines of "this is a townie thing to do", the more fruitless, more likely it's scum actually doing it.

[pieguyn]

dwsnsl5 has requested replacement. Searching...

[notSakura]

remilia bleeding town

Explain this, I've gotten nothing I'm really looking for out of those two.

I'm getting townvibes off of CD's posting.

[Raging Bull]

Faster than light, what is your vote on me for?

And I dont see why people think SV is scum. His actions stand out way too much, especially his tone of expecting a lynch already.

I also feel like scum wouldn't draw that much attention to themselves right off the bat, but pretty much this exact thing happened tk mmea few games ago and the bastard ended up being scum who won. I'm nit saying it's likely, but it's certainly a possibility.

I will note this however since I do not know SV's gameplay.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

Who do I have to sleep with to get a lynch around here??

[iamsteve]

Remilia Scarlet:
#10: null (first post)
#11: filler
#24: answering my question+filler
#29: neither a clear scumread nor a clear question
#33: #29 evaporating, fair enough
#37: filler. kind of "defending" my entrance, but without giving neither me a townread nor SV a scumread.
#77: again the same. "defending" my entrance, not townreading me, and not scumreading IL nor asking him anything.
#78: okay I guess
#80: Interested in SVs "crotchety reaction" to my opening. hm. Don't see why honestly. Where is this going to lead?
#87: *see CD paragraph
#92: okay, reasonable questions
#98: don't get it

The unfocused "filler" posts #24,#37,#77 I see as scummy. Granted, he's creating some activity with CD which is a pro-town thing to do, can't neglect that. So, let's see where this goes.

CD: Odd case. "terrible shot" could be a scumslip I suppose, but I find his explaination plausible.
SV: No hard reads on him, but it looks like he's just asking to get lynched so far. Also: terrible shot, but since it's a fake shot it didn't need to be good I guess.

undo: His read on me (#62) is bogus. Basically scumreading me for questioning people because he didn't agree with one of my questions being good scumhunting, while I have already spoken to 3 players then. I give him the benefit of a doubt that he believes it's a fair enough read, but then it is at best a hunch, still he sounds overly convinced about it. Maybe to make a wagon jump look less wagon jumpy.
Apart from that: His read on SV is nullish, so are his remarks on t/s lists.

So I'll go with that for now.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: undo

And a lot of nulliness going on so far.

P-Edit: Hi SV! What happens if we lynch you?

[pieguyn]

thenewearth replaces dwsnsl5 effective immediately.

[iamsteve]

CD: Odd case. "terrible shot" could be a scumslip I suppose, but I find his explaination plausible.

I refer to CD's explaination there!

[iamsteve]

And: Hi thenewearth!

[pieguyn]

bump

[pieguyn]

x 2