NY 173: Knight-Errant 2 - GAME OVER!

[The Knight-Errant]

Vote Count 1.08

Hopkirk (4) - beastcharizard, Twisted Advice, Katarina LeBlanc, MonkeyMan576
Bicephalous Bob (2) - GreyICE, PeregrineV
Katarina LeBlanc (2) - Turkish Van, Antihero
GreyICE (1) - Kublai Khan
Turkish Van (1) - notscience
Antihero (1) - Bicephalous Bob
Kublai Khan (1) - Lords of the Unreal
Lords of the Unreal (1) - MafiaSSK

Not Voting (5) - Metal Sonic, Guzame, burn_209, jbomber732, Hopkirk

18 alive, 10 to lynch. Deadline is set for 3 weeks from now, on April 21st, 2014 at 6:00 p.m., PST.

Countdown:
(expired on 2014-04-21 18:00:00)

[Twisted Advice]

Sorry, what I meant was, hey baby, what's your genus and species?

Iago

[Guzame]

Guzame, you read all eight pages, and the most interesting thing you found was that there were hydras? So, the OP. If you're really that interested in the merits of hydras, there are MD threads for that. Comments on the game content, please.
--PA

Actually, that was my reply to at least 2 pages worth of discussion on the topic of Hydras, not the OP.
But I guess you're right, I should take that complaint elsewhere, not in this game.

And my opinion on the game so far? I honestly didn't see any "scummy" tells so far. It mostly seemed like joking to keep a conversation going to me.
The only thing that struck out to me(besides the Hydra conversation) was that I feel like Hopkirk got attacked very heavily with little reason, while he honestly looks like a townie to me.

[Bicephalous Bob]

Bob--avoids engaging on points, like the coaching accusation. Dismisses people citing earlier games of his without elaboration.

you aren't serious about the coaching accusation are you

please provide a game where I talked trash as scum

[GreyICE]

Knowledge that you have behaved differently in scum games is why meta is worthless, Bob.

My vote is in a good place.

More need to join.

[jbomber732]

Guzame, you read all eight pages, and the most interesting thing you found was that there were hydras? So, the OP. If you're really that interested in the merits of hydras, there are MD threads for that. Comments on the game content, please.
--PA

Actually, that was my reply to at least 2 pages worth of discussion on the topic of Hydras, not the OP.
But I guess you're right, I should take that complaint elsewhere, not in this game.

And my opinion on the game so far? I honestly didn't see any "scummy" tells so far. It mostly seemed like joking to keep a conversation going to me.
The only thing that struck out to me(besides the Hydra conversation) was that I feel like Hopkirk got attacked very heavily with little reason, while he honestly looks like a townie to me.

You set off my scumtell sensor. You don't have ONE major or even minor scumread?

[MonkeyMan576]

jbomber brings up a good point. There has been lots of activity so far not to have any scumreads.

FOS: Guzame

[GreyICE]

PSA: Monkey is town

[Bicephalous Bob]

Knowledge that you have behaved differently in scum games is why meta is worthless, Bob.

My vote is in a good place.

More need to join.

my point is that antihero's meta-accusation is worthless

[Twisted Advice]

Guzame, you read all eight pages, and the most interesting thing you found was that there were hydras? So, the OP. If you're really that interested in the merits of hydras, there are MD threads for that. Comments on the game content, please.
--PA

Actually, that was my reply to at least 2 pages worth of discussion on the topic of Hydras, not the OP.
But I guess you're right, I should take that complaint elsewhere, not in this game.

And my opinion on the game so far? I honestly didn't see any "scummy" tells so far. It mostly seemed like joking to keep a conversation going to me.
The only thing that struck out to me(besides the Hydra conversation) was that I feel like Hopkirk got attacked very heavily with little reason, while he honestly looks like a townie to me.

How much mafia experience do you have? This post is something I would expect from a first-timer.

Bob--avoids engaging on points, like the coaching accusation. Dismisses people citing earlier games of his without elaboration.

you aren't serious about the coaching accusation are you

please provide a game where I talked trash as scum

Why is your vote still sitting somewhere completely worthless? Are you planning on attempting to play mafia at some point, or are you going to just keep only reacting when your name shows up?

Iago

[GreyICE]

PSA: Katarina is also town

PSA: Bob is hitting the stage of scum where he knows that there's people with solid scumreads on him, but he's not quite sure what behavior will make him not be lynched.

[GreyICE]

Bob--avoids engaging on points, like the coaching accusation. Dismisses people citing earlier games of his without elaboration.

you aren't serious about the coaching accusation are you

please provide a game where I talked trash as scum

Knowledge that you have behaved differently in scum games is why meta is worthless, Bob.

My vote is in a good place.

More need to join.

my point is that antihero's meta-accusation is worthless

Also he forgot his original post was addressed to Turkish Van, not antihero.

Ze flail

[Bicephalous Bob]

antihero made the original accusation

PSA: Katarina is also town

PSA: Bob is hitting the stage of scum where he knows that there's people with solid scumreads on him, but he's not quite sure what behavior will make him not be lynched.

no I'm currently at the stage where I self-vote and repeatedly call myself a genius in all caps

[Antihero]

snarky

[Hopkirk]

1.) Which was not present when you attacked me for saying it?

2.) Yes- as a reaction test. Seeing if anyone voting me would unvote when i did then they would be

probable partners for monkey

.
The initial logic i've already said was not the best-it's good for the stage it was made at-thus

the scumread is minor

. Why do you think i can't change my votes?

So to further explain myself here, bolded is both massive cognitive dissonance and somewhat contradictory with the attempt to maintain the logic (while unvoting) in previous post. Basically there is just nothing right here. I'll volunteer to eat the sultan's moldy crackers if this is town.

jbomber--liked his early willingness to go against the grain with a Hopkirk town read and his seeming to be happy at knowing someone in the game from his comment to Mala.

Good point, I hadn't looked at it that way.

Also, nice entry post. Stay a while.

trying to be cute and disarming while not really saying anything :3

Dang it, that totally worked on me.

Iago

If the thing i was trying to bait out happened (not just happened but happened right) then it would make them both shoot up to heavy scum.
Not a hard concept to grasp eh?

[Bicephalous Bob]

snarky

clever

[Twisted Advice]

Hop: That's a very hard concept to grasp, such that I still don't grasp it, and I still can't even tell if you're calling me scum.

Iago

[jbomber732]

PSA: twisted is town

[Antihero]

snarky

clever

/shrug

parallelism

[Hopkirk]

Monkey/206: This seems to be an example of trying to make his scumreads look stupid (taking something I said as something that someone else said later and implying the second person was the first+only one to say it).

@Twisted: Since i'm not referring to you specifically then why would you get that from it? The only point on you that i've made i have considered moot for a while now so why would you say that?

[MonkeyMan576]

In his only other mafiascum game, Guzame was a serial killer and didn't vote until day 8. So I would say his lack of opinion may be a scumtell, or it could be newbtown, but I am leaning scum.

[Twisted Advice]

Monkey/206: This seems to be an example of trying to make his scumreads look stupid (taking something I said as something that someone else said later and implying the second person was the first+only one to say it).

@Twisted: Since i'm not referring to you specifically then why would you get that from it? The only point on you that i've made i have considered moot for a while now so why would you say that?

Oh, I get it. I thought you were saying anyone who voted you for unvoting was scum, but you were saying the opposite. Mmkay.

Iago

[Twisted Advice]

snarky

clever

/shrug

parallelism

this is going to be an easy game dudes

[GreyICE]

my point is that antihero's meta-accusation is worthless

Your response to it, however, is interesting.

But I'll toss you a bone. Find a scum suspect. Make it not shitty players. Unless they're Metal Sonic, because he's scum.

[Bicephalous Bob]

indeed