NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[Nachomamma8]

You see why I might ignore your argument when it depends on a player to be either horribly retarded or scum, right? There's a considerable amount of bias on both sides of the fence so your best choice at this point in time would probably be to scumhunting elsewhere and let the fresh blood sort you two out.

[Ythan]

Gc you know there's a crying smiley you can use instead of bothering with letters right.

[Ythan]

this one

or maybe this

[Ythan]

can we fucking kill mollie

[Desperado]

Disclaimer: The jokes in this video have absolutely nothing to do with this game of mafia and are meant solely to amuse.

Vote Count 6.4

Kagami (6) - DeathNote, Elyse, Marquis, Ythan, pirate mollie, Nachomamma8

<--- Lynch!

Ythan (1) - Green Crayons

Not Voting (4) - Kagami, Bulbazak, tman2nd, Yates

The deadline for Day 6 is Monday, April 17th, at 8:00 PM EST. With 11 people alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline in (expired on 2014-04-17 20:00:00).

Kagami has been lynched. She was the

Mafia Ninja 1-Shot Strongman!

[Desperado]

It is now Night 6. The deadline will be Friday, April 11th, at 10:00 PM EST. Deadline in (expired on 2014-04-11 22:00:00).

[Desperado]

pirate mollie has been killed. She was a

Vanilla Townie!

[Desperado]

Disclaimer: The jokes in this video have absolutely nothing to do with this game of mafia and are meant solely to amuse.

Vote Count 7.0

Not Voting (9) - DeathNote, Nachomamma8, Yates, Elyse, Marquis, Ythan, Bulbazak, tman2nd, Green Canyons

The deadline for Day 7 is Friday, April 25th, at 8:00 PM EST. With 9 people alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline in (expired on 2014-04-25 20:00:00).

[Elyse]

Ythan looks better and GC looks worse after Kagami's flip.

[Nachomamma8]

Do one of them have to be scum?

[Nachomamma8]

Vote: Elyse

[Green Crayons]

Ythan looks better and GC looks worse after Kagami's flip.

But Ythan is more scummy than the EPM/NS/Kagami slot was. No regrets.

VOTE: Ythan

-----

If I'm going to assume that Ythan is just an infuriatingly bad player, and not scum, (which is a mistake I made with Zekrom, but whatever), then my first inclination is to throw a vote on Nacho.

(1) Didn't like his non-response to an inquiry re: pisskop's supposed attempted derail of a scum lynch (yes, "supposed" because I haven't reread the thread so I don't even know if Elyse's accusation is valid or not!).
(2) Didn't like the juxtaposition of unwilling to read through previous days (in re: pisskop's derail), but willing to be the arbitrator in Ythan v. GC which would require reading previous days to some extent, as our little spat predates his replacement.
(3) Kagami's commentary re: scum kills looks like seriously trying to communicate with another partner. Although that could reasonably be a partner who was not another replacement, it feels more likely that it was to a fellow replacement.
(4) Super easy to choose bussing Kagami as a replacement.

-----

Strong town:
- tman2nd
- Bulbazak
- Marquis

Probably town:
- Yates
- DeathNote

Scum possibilities:
- Ythan
- Nacho
- Elyse (Yes, I know I've been reading Elyse town all game but there's just

something

that feels off. I don't know how else to explain it, and can't quite put my finger on it.)

[Green Crayons]

In re: Elyse, I just have this nagging feeling like I've been being played all game.

[Green Crayons]

But, as a matter of lynch preference atm: Ythan > Nacho > Elyse.

[Nachomamma8]

Vote me please. I will eventually convince you that you're town, but I'd rather you not idiotically tunneled on practically confirmed town.

[Nachomamma8]

When you say "don't worry, the guy I'm voting was more scummy than flipped scum", you're being biased as fuck and need to check your life.

[Green Crayons]

Believe it or not, I can vote one person and still evaluate other players. Doing two things at once: something I did just yesterday!

-----

If I'm going to assume that Ythan is just an infuriatingly bad player, and not scum, (which is a mistake I made with Zekrom, but whatever), then my first inclination is to throw a vote on Nacho.

(1) Didn't like his non-response to an inquiry re: pisskop's supposed attempted derail of a scum lynch (yes, "supposed" because I haven't reread the thread so I don't even know if Elyse's accusation is valid or not!).
(2) Didn't like the juxtaposition of unwilling to read through previous days (in re: pisskop's derail), but willing to be the arbitrator in Ythan v. GC which would require reading previous days to some extent, as our little spat predates his replacement.

(3) Kagami's commentary re: scum kills looks like seriously trying to communicate with another partner. Although that could reasonably be a partner who was not another replacement, it feels more likely that it was to a fellow replacement.

(4) Super easy to choose bussing Kagami as a replacement.

Following up on the bolded, these posts in particular:

The slot isn't scum, mollie, ns has been lurking in all of his games from the looks of it.

I'm caught up with the major events and have been looking at VCs and the posts surrounding them. I should be done with a full read during the day tomorrow.

My initial appraisal is that the day 1 formerfish counterwagon to zekrom's wagon deserves scrutiny, and I'm trying to work out last two night kills.

Peregrin's kill especially makes little sense, unless the scumteam are not mafia at all, but are in fact forest fires taking the form of mafia (which would be decidedly non-normal).

It seems pretty unlikely to me that the scum made use of daychat when they had it, given the terrible play from zekrom and the terrible claims (also, prob no mod-given fake claims), so I'm going to do some meta-diving when I've finished reading.

This reads as scum saying "holy shit scum team has been stupid."

I think Deathnote, Mollie, and Ythan are town for various reasons. Two of these are play-based reads, and one who I'm pretty sure is the mason (sorry if this outs you, but it's kind of obvious).

Deathnote town makes me think marquis scum, on the grounds that the counterwagon to sthar was entirely town-led, but I really want nacho's input. The pisskop attempt to counterwagon marquis as the mala wagon built up is pinging pretty hard; nacho-slot being scum would suggest marquis town, probably.

And here Kagami is yelling to her partner who to kill. I don't have a feeling one way or another if she would have thrown her partner into the mix.


Those posts combined look like she's trying to tell a fellow replacement (rather than an existing player) that, basically, the scum team has been stupid with its night kill choices, and that her partner should take a stab at one of her offered targets.

Once again, I recognize that a replacing scum might do these things when their partner is an already-existing player. But it just feels more like Kagami's fellow scum was also a replacement. ~*~ Gut Talk. ~&~

[Marquis]

gc we're not lynching ythan

[Marquis]

VOTE: deathnote

[Marquis]

oh sorry i thought you said yates

but yeah either way i'm not lynching a y name today

[Elyse]

Do one of them have to be scum?

no

[Yates]

Hey Elyse, what makes you say this?

Ythan looks better and GC looks worse after Kagami's flip.

[Yates]

Wait. Never mind. I misread that and thought I saw something. I am p-sure I'm town reading scum. This bothers me.

Nacho - why are you voting Elyse?

Marquis - why are you voting DN?

I have a pretty strong town read on 3 of the 4 people above so I'd like to start here.

[Ythan]

Dawn of
The Seventh Day
-309 Hours Remain-

[Ythan]

VOTE: Green Canyons