Newbie 1488: Igloo-Town Tragedy (Game Over)

[Billi bilaði]

But seriously why are more people not voting billi for his scum slip?

If we are going to ignore it just put me out of my misery

so I don't have to watch town lose this game.

It's not misery, It's frustration

You slipped so sure we could sit here and look for your partner but nobody is even doing that. I'm not going to waste my time cause there's people out there who actually think you didn't slip. One of those are probably your partner so my lynch pool is narrowed.

You're so sure I'm scum that you don't want to bother looking for the other mafia because not enough players believe you. And you insinuate that if you are not sheeped you want to be lynched and then you wont even read the game anymore.
You are so not playing as a townie in my book!

I never said I wasn't going to read the game

and I am playing like a townie. Granted it's a stubborn one who wants his way or the highway but that's me, thats what I do. I don't expect you to believe me not do I really care if you do. I'll keep doing my thing and you keep doing yours.

If I had to hammer it down scum is probably you/ddd. Though it could be a lurker.

If this first red bit isn't insinuating that you will stop reading the game, then I'm not as good in the kings english as I believed I was.
You may be playing like a townie, but, as I say, in my book, it is not as a townie that is helping the town.
You certainly don't have to change your playstyle for me, but I'm surely, as well, going to point out how that playstyle looks to me.

[Jake from State Farm]

Oh I see you don't know what "put me out of my misery" means.

If I'm put out of my misery, that means I'm lynched and yes at that time I would stop reading the game. As long as I'm alive I will be reading.

I'm helping town by telling them who I think is scum and why. I also point out when people make incorrect statements about me. I can't force people to listen to me cause if I could you would be lynched. If I see suspicious things aka your scum slip, I point them out.

Right now we have 1 scum slip, a couple of Lurkers. I can't read the Lurkers for shit and I'm always down for lurker lynch if there wasn't something else obvious, but there isn't.

I guess there is only 1 way you can know for sure they there is a rb'er but in my gut I don't feel like that applies here.

[Billi bilaði]

Oh I see you don't know what "put me out of my misery" means...

I know it full well.
I question your reading of the game, though, based on the second part I highlighted, in regards to the first part, and what happened inbetween.

[dawn_to_dusk]

VOTE: Private
neither jake nor billi are suspects so it wont lynch someone but not scumhunting can be suspicious. there is one main person not scumhunting according to random's analysis. i tried to give a town-read on private but looking back on it, it was very weak.

Vote private

Same reasons as stated by dtd
Getting a strong town read on dtd, and a weak town on Jake.

Can we consider these two posts for a moment? These two people each reference each other as the reason they are voting for me? Considering that this is a newbie game, I am almost hoping that these are two newbscum who just hardcore slipped. How is your primary reasoning each other? Especially you, randomidget, instead of relying on your own reads, you cite someone who contributed nothing to your own reads? I feel as though you are, at the very least, trying to absolve responsibility for this vote.

I have a presentation to make, and homework to finish, but for now, my vote will be parked on

VOTE: Randomidget

From what I see, it was useless to say the same thing twice. Random may have been about to vote you but I beat him to it so he just said that my reasons for voting were the same reasons that he would have used.

[Jake from State Farm]

Oh I see you don't know what "put me out of my misery" means...

I know it full well.
I question your reading of the game, though, based on the second part I highlighted, in regards to the first part, and what happened inbetween.

Huh?

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Vote Count 2.03

• PrivateI (3) -
  dawn_to_dusk, Billi bilaði, randomidget
  
• Billi bilaði (2) -
  Jake from State Farm, jklash12
  
• Jake from State Farm (1) -
  Debonair Danny DiPietro
  
• randomidget (1) -
  PrivateI
  
• Debonair Danny DiPietro (0) -
  
  
• jklash12 (0) -
  
  
• dawn_to_dusk (0) -
  
  
• Zephyrus (0) -
  
  
  
  
  
• Not Voting (1) – Zephyrus,

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is 11PM EDT April 20
Countdown: (expired on 2014-04-20 11:00:00)

[/i][/area]

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Apologies, was out of town Friday afternoon and Saturday and was just busy today; will get back to this tomorrow.

[jklash12]

VOTE: Private
neither jake nor billi are suspects so it wont lynch someone but not scumhunting can be suspicious. there is one main person not scumhunting according to random's analysis. i tried to give a town-read on private but looking back on it, it was very weak.

Vote private

Same reasons as stated by dtd
Getting a strong town read on dtd, and a weak town on Jake.

Can we consider these two posts for a moment? These two people each reference each other as the reason they are voting for me? Considering that this is a newbie game, I am almost hoping that these are two newbscum who just hardcore slipped. How is your primary reasoning each other? Especially you, randomidget, instead of relying on your own reads, you cite someone who contributed nothing to your own reads? I feel as though you are, at the very least, trying to absolve responsibility for this vote.

I have a presentation to make, and homework to finish, but for now, my vote will be parked on

VOTE: Randomidget

haha

It is actually funny if you look at those 2 post. dtd votes saying he was using random's analysis and then random votes saying dtd's reasons which in the end makes it a complete circle.

VOTE: Private
neither jake nor billi are suspects so it wont lynch someone but not scumhunting can be suspicious. there is one main person not scumhunting according to random's analysis. i tried to give a town-read on private but looking back on it, it was very weak.

Vote private

Same reasons as stated by dtd
Getting a strong town read on dtd, and a weak town on Jake.

Can we consider these two posts for a moment? These two people each reference each other as the reason they are voting for me? Considering that this is a newbie game, I am almost hoping that these are two newbscum who just hardcore slipped. How is your primary reasoning each other? Especially you, randomidget, instead of relying on your own reads, you cite someone who contributed nothing to your own reads? I feel as though you are, at the very least, trying to absolve responsibility for this vote.

I have a presentation to make, and homework to finish, but for now, my vote will be parked on

VOTE: Randomidget

From what I see, it was useless to say the same thing twice. Random may have been about to vote you but I beat him to it so he just said that my reasons for voting were the same reasons that he would have used.

Why are you defending random? Do you think he is strong town?

[dawn_to_dusk]

im defending myself. i can see how it looks like im defending random, but all in all, im trying not to get lynched. as is everyone.

[Randomnamechange]

Really? Not a single post in this entire time?

[Jake from State Farm]

Really? Not a single post in this entire time?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Look Jake, lots of people were supposed to be posting between 12:30 am and 6 am in the Eastern time zone; that's like the busiest time for site traffic. Or the complete opposite, one of the two.

Anyways, I'm glad we've come back to PrivateI because he pled for his life last time after not contributing and then proceeded to double down on that not contributing thing. The DTD/random circle of life is amusing but I don't think it means anything at all.

VOTE: PrivateI

[Randomnamechange]

GUYS PRIVATE IS AT LYNCH 1. DO NOT HAMMER YET.

[Jake from State Farm]

So ddd was trying to get zeph to answer your questions all for show?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

So ddd was trying to get zeph to answer your questions all for show?

Nope, but you tell me; should I pitch my town read on him because he won't answer my questions? Should he still be a town read but I threaten him with a lynch to get him to participate? I don't think either of those are reasonable at this point so I'm rather stuck in looking rather lame on that front.

[Jake from State Farm]

Why do you have a town read in him anyway?

And yes when a player refuses to play and answer questions you should not town read them. The fact you are is odd

[Billi bilaði]

Newbie question: What does L-1 mean? Lynch 1?

It is things like this that make me lean towards Zephyrus being town. But I'm not leaning so hard that I'm in danger of falling over.

[Jake from State Farm]

Yeah I guess that could be looked at as a slight town tell but if a person has never played before I'd imagine they would ask that regardless of alignment.

[Zephyrus]

We still have about 4 days till we need to decide, don't quick hammer PrivateI. We want him to talk.

[Jake from State Farm]

And u too

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Newbie question: What does L-1 mean? Lynch 1?

It is things like this that make me lean towards Zephyrus being town. But I'm not leaning so hard that I'm in danger of falling over.

And asking for a day one no lynch and his random role speculation at the start of day two...

[Randomnamechange]

Zephyrus, please can you answer DDD's questions?

[Jake from State Farm]

Newbie question: What does L-1 mean? Lynch 1?

It is things like this that make me lean towards Zephyrus being town. But I'm not leaning so hard that I'm in danger of falling over.

And asking for a day one no lynch and his random role speculation at the start of day two...

Those are more likely to come from town?

:scratches head:

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Newbie question: What does L-1 mean? Lynch 1?

It is things like this that make me lean towards Zephyrus being town. But I'm not leaning so hard that I'm in danger of falling over.

And asking for a day one no lynch and his random role speculation at the start of day two...

Those are more likely to come from town?

:scratches head:

The second is the tone of the post; the first is absolutely the case in my experience.

[jklash12]

I am stating intent to hammer. Private I has been on my scum list for awhile and his play today hasn't changed my mind. So unless Private gets in here and proves he is innocent I am perfectly fine to hammer him.