I don't remember you ever being this forward in the Song Upick, and with such shitty reasoning.
In post 465, undo wrote:Damn, we're doing bad.
I understand your pain, and fulfilling dying wishes is very noble and all, but we really can't afford another mislynch. So please let's try and go slower this time, shall we.
@FomerFish: why didn't you let Number_0ne defend himself?
@Empking: any reads on other players?
Defend himself against what? From what I saw from his ISO there really wasn't much activity, and a lack of content in the posts that he did make. And I know hindsight is 20/20, but what would we have done with his claim of VT, I'd still lynch him.
In post 467, InsidiousLemons wrote:
Maybe so, but do you really expect us to lynch somebody PURELY because a dead conf-town wanted him dead? If you were a cop maybe, but this is essentially roulette.
Solely because dead conftown wanted them dead, nah, there some other shit rolled in there. Why does the opinion of Innocent Children hold so much sway? Because we know that they are coming from a town point of view. Same with dead conftown. And the wifomy idea that scum never kill someone pinning them down as top suspects doesnt hold water. As scum I have killed the biggest threat just as much as gone for misdirection. As scum I also use this argument to throw a wrench into towns scumhunting because all it does is brew paranoia like bad homemade hooch.
In post 469, iamsteve wrote:The hammer of Formerfish was more antitown than everything I have seen in this game so far. And I'm not only talking about the hammer without claim. He killed all ongoing conversations on this day. There were open questions and ongoing cases towards both Number 0ne and undo.
I could kind of understand that one of the players who have to suffer through this game from the beginning would maybe do this just to end this misery quickly, but a fresh replacement? You don't replace into a game if you don't want to play (I hope) and the players I've seen replacing in so far have tried to bring new life into a game and not shut it down.
So, what were you thinking, Formerfish?
In post 467, InsidiousLemons wrote:
Maybe so, but do you really expect us to lynch somebody PURELY because a dead conf-town wanted him dead? If you were a cop maybe, but this is essentially roulette.
Do you have a better idea then?
Are you really coming at my neck for hammering someone that you also claim to have ongoing cases against? I made a bad call from the limited information I had from his ISO. And then you go on to say that if someone else had hammered it would have been ok, but since I am new to the game I shouldn't have done that. Well, shit happens, and I hammered. Are you calling me scum for it or just muddying the waters here?
FTL, I should have listened to you more in Touhou Varsoon, I'm sorry I let that go down the way it did. Your play here is very similar and that is why I am willing to trust you here. Just saying.
In post 474, undo wrote:I'd like to remind you that there can be 3 scum alive, so with 9 players it may only take two badly-placed town votes to have a potential mislynch. Just saying.
Yet you still lived, even when you got put to l-1. And is there a chance that this is multiball? I never saw the game announcement so I don't know if anything about the set up was revealed. And your breakdown of the night kill is wifom in its purest form.
I'm trying something new. Usually I analyze everything to death and ignore my gut. Gut tends to be right but gets drowned out because I am unable to explain myself well enough. See my push on pecan for days straight in Song Upick. Guy was scummy as fuck but I couldn't get him lynched. Town got endgamed by him eventually. I had a gut read on my brother in some random mini because of his lack of a reach out in his first few posts. I allowed myself to be swayed by him and was endgamed. So, yeah trying something a little different here. That's right! Ice... man. I am dangerous.
In post 481, Faster Than Light wrote:formerfish is scummy as f. but his predecessor, tanz, was very townie so i am wiling to take a leap of faith and call him town
Wrong, and then right, I appreciate the leap of faith. You won't be disappointed.
In post 485, iamsteve wrote:undo: It is still a wall of WIFOM. You are trying to suggest that on RS's suspicion ranking it'd probably be exactly the third player that had most reason to kill RS, because the others were not suspicious enough or too suspicious. Having checked your previous games and in particular your stances on WIFOM I heavily doubt you'd pull this kind of argument as a townie. I agree that Tanz wasn't scummy, unfortunately Formerfish kind of screwed this slot when he replaced him.
FTL: I am fine with RS's wish.
VOTE: undo
What changed between the last post you made lambasting me for what you essentially do here? I didn't answer anything, Undo barely spoke, yet you now feel confident enough to vote him. Is this just a poorly set up bussing job?
In post 486, undo wrote:p-edit: @iamsteve: One thing is WIFOM, another thing is dealing with probabilities. You can't pass without the latter in this game. What exactly do you find WIFOM about my post?
The Undo/Isteve shit comes off as scum/scum to me. Anyone else getting that vibe?
@Raging Bull
- Why do you think that Empking can't be scum because of where he was on the two
mislynches
? It kinda looked like he parked his votes and just sat on them. Also, go check out a town game of his, it looks nothing like his play here. And yeah, I know that I have to get active here, so here is my attempt at that.
@Undo
- How many times are you going to mention how careful we have to be right now? I think your AtF has run its course and now the wolf can just come fucking eat you.
In post 504, Empking wrote:Undo's very very latest posts aren't great, but his post on Formers was good. Plus, I don't still his change in mind on Former as likely to be coming from under pressure scum.
Can you translate this into English, and maybe show exactly which posts you are talking about?
I was kind of hoping that someone would be on, I am a lot better at this shit when I can actually bounce ideas off someone directly.
