Mewbie 1493~ Game Ovah

[saturnine]

Oh and I forgot to vote

Vote: Not_Mafia

because that post did nothing to convince me and I think he's a more viable wagon than Josh at this point

[goodmorning]

Why does that convince you? Not saying it was a scummy post in itself or anything, just doesn't seem like enough to change anyone's opinion about a possible wagon.

Because it addressed all the ickiness I was feeling about him without me enumerating that ickiness.

[saturnine]

Hmmm, I see.

What do you think about a possible Josh_B wagon then?

[goodmorning]

Eh. I still think he's probably Town.

[I Love Fairies]

oh god that post tho

Vote: ILF

This is why my vote is still on you. You continually refuse to explain to me exactly why you think I'm scum. Do you honestly expect some sort of genuine, intelligent defense from "oh god that post tho" and a vote? How the hell is that fair to me? If you want to call me scum, if you want to start a bandwagon on me, if you honestly do think I'm scum, so be it. But at least defend your reasons. At least STATE some fucking reasons.

[I Love Fairies]

Eh. I still think he's probably Town.

Why?

[goodmorning]

oh god that post tho

Vote: ILF

This is why my vote is still on you. You continually refuse to explain to me exactly why you think I'm scum. Do you honestly expect some sort of genuine, intelligent defense from "oh god that post tho" and a vote? How the hell is that fair to me? If you want to call me scum, if you want to start a bandwagon on me, if you honestly do think I'm scum, so be it. But at least defend your reasons. At least STATE some fucking reasons.

I voted for you for all the reasons I've said before.

That was my reasoning for

unvoting

NotMaf.

Eh. I still think he's probably Town.

Why?

An aside: During this Day phase, you've suspected:

Right now, I'd be most willing to lynch Mr Glidder, IMD, and Saturnine.

I'm more confident in Goodmorning being scum than I am any other player in the game right now,

That's literally everyone but Josh. You asking me this question therefore either shows a massive disconnect in your thinking or you haven't been sharing, both of which do not point to Town.
So here's the deal. I'm happy to answer your question after you do two things:
1. Post a case on me;
2. Provide a reads list that does not include NKA. Include basic designations (town, lean town, null, null-scum, etc).

[imkingdavid]

It is an interesting point, as saturnine pointed out, that Josh has gotten away with so much crap that no one else would have been able to, due to his VT claim. If not for that early claim he would have probably been lynched so long ago. So much role-fishing and setup speculation. I think it is possible that he could be scum playing at VI, but it's also possible that he is who he says he is and is just not used to how stuff is done around here. For instance, 299 makes it hard for me to find him scum unless he's just bullshitting and trying to play the VI on purpose. But I think Occam's Razor applies in this case.

If I ignore the claim and posts like #299, then I would probably be voting him. But damn, I don't know if I'd feel comfortable lynching him. At least, not today.

At this point N_M is pinging me but I'll need to look at more specifically why. I also need to look at Glidder because I realized I somehow don't know my read on him.

I'm a little hesitant to say ILF is town (my "^town" bit was wholly about the particular response she gave to my vote, not my actual read on her) because I feel she is trying too hard to play the victim, though GM is going at her a bit rough. I do agree with GM that I'd like to see the two things she requested at the end of her last post (a case and a non-NKA reads list).

Sat is null and GM is town.

[Mr Glidder]

But damn, I don't know if I'd feel comfortable lynching him. At least, not today.

Then when? I doubt he'll ever be nightkilled (either because he's scum, or because scum want to keep his behaviour around).

I also need to look at Glidder because I realized I somehow don't know my read on him.

Spoiler: humour

Your read on me is town.

Less funnily, you last mentioned me in 394 and said I was leaning scum for *reasons*.

[I Love Fairies]

I'm a little hesitant to say ILF is town (my "^town" bit was wholly about the particular response she gave to my vote, not my actual read on her) because I feel she is trying too hard to play the victim, though GM is going at her a bit rough. I do agree with GM that I'd like to see the two things she requested at the end of her last post (a case and a non-NKA reads list).

Sat is null and GM is town.

How about this: GM provided her case against me and provides a non-NKA reads list and then I'll do the same, only with my case against her.

I think it's only fair.

[goodmorning]

I think the entire point here is that I've made my opinions pretty clear thus far.

[Mr Glidder]

Hello people where u @.

How about this: GM provided her case against me and provides a non-NKA reads list and then I'll do the same, only with my case against her.

I think it's only fair.

Your reluctance to (kind of) take initiative and go first is noted.

PEDIT:

I think the entire point here is that I've made my opinions pretty clear thus far.

I went and skimmed your ISO, and all the recent stuff is focused on one or two players. A refresher would be nice.

[Josh_B]

alright people, give me the names of two people that you want to lynch and why.

[Malakittens]

2.03

With Seven Alive.. It takes Four to Lynch

Voting:

*I Love Fairies - goodmorning [1]
*saturnine -
*Josh_B - Mr Glidder [1]
*Mr Glidder - Not_Mafia [1]
*imkingdavid -
*Not_Mafia - saturnine [1]
*goodmorning - Josh_B, I Love Fairies [2]

Not Voting:

imkingdavid [2]

Mew Count Downs

Day 2 ends in.. (expired on 2014-05-07 22:40:00)

[Josh_B]

Let's run the wagon back up on Mr Glidder.

VOTE: Glidder

[Mr Glidder]

For some purpose, I presume?

To answer your question though: Right now I want to lynch either you (because of your scads of fuddleduddle murkydurpy posts) or ILF (because of lack of content and the recent "you go first" post). IKD and GM I see as town because their posts mostly match my opinions. N_M is still pretty null to me, call that a third option. saturnine started town but has gotten a bit weaker into nulltown territory due to what I perceive as a dropoff in post quality. So I guess my current preferred lynch order is something like

1. Josh_B
2. ILF
3. Not_Mafia

with the other three being "won't vote for unless something changes".

[I Love Fairies]

My point is that no one actually cares what my actual reads are, only that I provide them. There is literally no point in me really posting anymore.

[Josh_B]

My point is that no one actually cares what my actual reads are, only that I provide them. There is literally no point in me really posting anymore.

That's not true. I like your reads. They're easy to read. they have a lot of content. GM and Glidder are just trying to get you lynched. That's what scum do. But as you can see from the vote count nobody is buying it. The more they press on you the scummier they look. GM is probably scum, but we only get to pick one at a time.

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: Josh_B

[Josh_B]

WOOT! I'm down with that. VOTE TO GAME OVER. or just vote joshb that's the same thing.

[goodmorning]

My point is that no one actually cares what my actual reads are, only that I provide them. There is literally no point in me really posting anymore.

I actually do care what your actual reads are; it's because I don't know (other than "gm is scum cause I trust myself") that I asked you to post them.

My point is that no one actually cares what my actual reads are, only that I provide them. There is literally no point in me really posting anymore.

That's not true. I like your reads. They're easy to read. they have a lot of content. GM and Glidder are just trying to get you lynched. That's what scum do. But as you can see from the vote count nobody is buying it. The more they press on you the scummier they look. GM is probably scum, but we only get to pick one at a time.

You're right that it isn't true. That said, she hasn't posted any reads. If she had they probably would be easy to read, I'll give you that. They don't have content because she hasn't posted them. That's not the point here; also, Glidder is trying to get

you

lynched. That's also what Town do. But as you can see from the votecount there're plenty of days left til deadline and we seem to be using them somewhat constructively. The more she refuses to post a readslist, the scummier she looks. ILF is probably Scum, and she's probably today's lynch unless Josh keeps spouting things with no basis in reality.

[Josh_B]

o be using them somewhat constructively. The more she refuses to post a readslist, the scummier she looks. ILF is probably Scum, and she's probably today's lynch unless Josh keeps spouting things with no basis in reality.

GoodMorning you're probably scum. And you haven't posted a read list either, so the hypocracy of scum continues.

[Mr Glidder]

Hm.

I'm fairly sure that one of Josh_B and ILF is scum. But given the level of defense going on, I'm not so sure they are both scum.

[I Love Fairies]

My point is that no one actually cares what my actual reads are, only that I provide them. There is literally no point in me really posting anymore.

I actually do care what your actual reads are; it's because I don't know (other than "gm is scum cause I trust myself") that I asked you to post them.

Oh, but I did give my reasons.

[I Love Fairies]

^^^^ Note that the above post was an attempt to display just how annoying it is when GM claims that she has posted various reasons against the people who ask her what she thinks of people.