Event Card Mafia (Game Over)

[AGar]

So AD tracks Iec who admits to targeting the person who AD says he tracked to. I think all are telling the truth but who's to say scum don't have a tracker?

Do you think scum would have a full-tracker or a limited-tracker (both limited players implied JoaT-esque roles)?

[Juls]

Don't know. Is AD claiming full tracker?

[ZZZX]

ZZZX replaces XReckonerX

this fucker

:/

Have we even played with each others?


Well I need alot of catch up, Can someone give me an idea of what is going on so far?

[Prof Fridays]

I guess I want to know what's up with Iec's and talah's roles. Are both of them tracker-like JOATs? Because the odds of two JOATs like that in one faction seem slim to me. If AD's one of the same, then there assuredly is scum between the three of them, because I can't see three investigative JOATs on the town side as a thing. Maybe I'm mis-remembering and Iec is a complete role. I thought he soft-claimed otherwise. I should look that up, haha.

[AGar]

Don't know. Is AD claiming full tracker?

That was the general impression I got from his post. He said "I'm a tracker."

[Prof Fridays]

Prof - do you have any TOWNreads? Anything? Like feed me something here my educated brother.

BROseidon
Bulbazak
farside
Kublai Khan
zMuffinMan

Those are really the only ones I feel relatively confident about. This whole thing with AD recently has shaken my trust in some other town reads I had previously.

5 man scumteam. You personally don't have to carry out the kill.

This is scummy

stupid, not scummy

This is fair, in that I could theoretically be on the scum team without personally carrying out the kill. On the other hand, when we're at a point when a good amount of people haven't really gotten any solid scum-reads, it seems like you might as well take what information you can get, that being the victims and the Geography rooms.

No, because as we've seen already, it's fucking pointless because

no one understands how it fucking worked.

I'd much rather stick to traditional scumhunting, and that you want to deflect attention off of yourself while providing no insight on to

who

would be a viable choice given the limitations of the mechanic is setting off all sorts of alarms and bells.

I understand it. *shrugs* It's not very difficult, you just have to follow the logic.

Although, I will admit, I rather neglected to think about where TIP ended up in the rooms. I think I was a bit too jumpy on that one, but that doesn't necessarily write him off my list.

UNVOTE: TheIrishPope

I want to see how this AD vs. Iec thing plays out before casting my vote.

[AGar]

Oh. My. God.

Are we really going to only vote people who were in the same room as the NK targets today? Are we really going to be this stupid?

Somebody dayvig me if that's the case please. Please for the love of god do it.

[Prof Fridays]

Oh, hush, you drama queen.

I'm just saying it's something to consider. But at this point we seem to be going elsewhere with AD's claim.

[farside22]

Yeah so I kind of tuned out of this game yesterday and now I think I am slightly behind. Someone summarize why Iec is scum/being voted.

Let's summarize.
I think your reason for why you tracked talah is shitty and 3 tracker town is really hard to swallow.

Dan thinks I am scum because 3 tracks N1 is a lot. Farside either isn't reading my posts or thinks I fabricated PM exchanges with the Mod; it's unclear. TIP is just a hanger-on.

i'm considering the possibility all 3 are town. does that make me dumb?

Why?

[farside22]

Fucking phone posting.

My comment to iec.

I think your reason for why you tracked talah is shitty and 3 tracker town is really hard to swallow.

[mnemonicdevice]

Prof Fridays is probably scum now that I think about it.
Getting less negative vibes from P5.
I can get on the Iec wagon.
VOTE: Iece

Low hanging fruit comment, uh... not much to say about it, pretty obvious that i'm not the best around and I'm not too bad that the lynch would be obviously coming from scum but not too good that it's impossible to lynch me

hmm.

ZZZX replaces XReckonerX

this fucker

:/

Have we even played with each others?


Well I need alot of catch up, Can someone give me an idea of what is going on so far?

Yes ZZZX, you me, and TIP all played together in a game before. From what I remember it was abandoned by teh mod. (I can talk about abandoned games right? If not please tell me)

Lets see....
Here is generally what has happened in the last 50+ pages.
(In order hopefully)
1. I rolled a dice to pick a card. There was then lots of discussion about whether or not i could influence this. Mainly by aronis.
2. There was then lots of voting on aronis, for above reason. The questioning of the dice roll continues until ~page 6
3. Aronis doesn't really care about the wagon on himself, but votes eventually start coming off.
4. Votes start coming onto Tony PF
5. Oversoul made an offensive comment to farside, and votes started piling up on Oversoul
6. People start reading talah as scum, and also PZ, TIP, Venmar, and KA
7. Wagons start on PZ and Venmar
8.People make lists of bulletcatchers and scum reads
9. The game explodes with content every friday (watch out, last week there were 115 posts in 24 hours.)
10. Molla replaces in
11. Wagon on talah gets going
12. Muffin wants to kill everyone with this post (865)http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 1#p5849451
13. Talah and Venmar are at 7 and 8 votes respectively
14. the qwints wagon gets started
15. With only a few hours left, qwints is pushed to lynch
16. Qwints flips a vanilla townie
17. Molla was killed by mafia (we think) and KA by a vig
18. Day 3's event is dia de los muertos
19. Blue goo discussion
20. Lots of debate about geography mechanic
21. Many claims, especially tracker ones
22. Papa Zito starts out with an early wagon on him
23. ZZZX joins the game
24. Iec is under speculation due to tracker claims
25. This post

There, in 25 points, that is most of the game.
Have fun catching up Its a Friday.

[ZZZX]

Well Thanks!

I remeber you and TIP and others like Imp - tammy - saki (a few others a while ago)

anyway I found it weird about how many tracker claims there are. Not sure.

But I got a few things I will talk about . I might post ~10 posts as I quote from pages so be ready

[ZZZX]

Agar: why do you think ad is scum?
He claimed a track on a player in the room and talked about the result.

@iec: how does confirmable ability= track me. Second why did you not track a player you were suspicious of near you? Do you believe there are 3 town players with a track ability? If so why and do not fucking point to the set up from Zor.

@ action dan: why target iec?

@agar: 2 claim limited track and you think both are more plausible as town then a full tracker ?
I'm a bit confused on why.

@talah: if venmar had been further the one room away would you have tracked him?

-^○^-. (My interpretation of man shrugging shoulders)

Iecerint is implying he's a follower or tracker. Just sayin

Why did you not vote for iec here?

I personally find that scummy unless he is confirmed town. Why is he indirectly trying to lead town? This is usually used by scum to direct lynches as they want.

-I will continue to read and post as I see things that are interesting

[ZZZX]

I mean by that he is playing way too passive

[ZZZX]

@All What were the reads about my old slot owner?

[AGar]

If we lynch anyone from the 3 tracker claims, it HAS to be ActionDan.

Has to.

[Iecerint]

I think your reason for why you tracked talah is shitty and 3 tracker town is really hard to swallow.

What do you think I did to talah?

[Iecerint]

Cuz you know for sure that I did something to talah unless I am scum with Dan.

[Iecerint]

Or fortuitous phantom busdrivers.

[farside22]

I mean by that he is playing way too passive

Are you talking about me? Because the him and passive comment throws me off.

[farside22]

@All What were the reads about my old slot owner?

Currently phone posting so I don't remember who, but someone thought reck lack of comments was scummy.
Something like that or it was he wasn't playing like he would for someone that wanted to play.

I think your reason for why you tracked talah is shitty and 3 tracker town is really hard to swallow.

What do you think I did to talah?

Oh crystal ball please make me see all and know all.
Seriously how the fuck could anyone answer that?

[Iecerint]

It doesn't matter if you can know the specific action; the point is that I targeted her and nothing happened. If you're thinking enough about me being scum to vote for me, I would kind of hope you have thought stuff like that through.

For example, I guess you could imagine that I was a rolecop or something.

Though that wouldn't explain why I'd bother claiming anything the way that I did. And it doesn't account for why I would ask Zora stuff D1.

Basically I am having a hard time understanding anyone thinking that I am anything but obvtown, but at least 2 people seem to think that.

[farside22]

It doesn't matter if you can know the specific action; the point is that I targeted her and nothing happened. If you're thinking enough about me being scum to vote for me, I would kind of hope you have thought stuff like that through.

For example, I guess you could imagine that I was a rolecop or something.

Though that wouldn't explain why I'd bother claiming anything the way that I did. And it doesn't account for why I would ask Zora stuff D1.

Basically I am having a hard time understanding anyone thinking that I am anything but obvtown, but at least 2 people seem to think that.

I'm going to take you down farside lane, in a time of niceness and trust.
Oh the sweet moments of never having paranoia or good scum players.
The sweet, sweet bliss of it all. Then one day a player acts like he is mason with a player, claims mason to said player and laughs about forgetting his role. That player was scum.
So if you want to ask about possibilities of things I have seen scum do claiming to target someone without provocation would not shock me. Oh and asking the mod clarification about how your ability works is pretty fucking null. I can't imagine any player not confused by day 1 event.
You want me to believe you are town? Give me a list of scum reads. Tell me who jumps put at you that screams scum. Don't give me back and forth reads with no fucking foundation.

[Iecerint]

It's more like I am trying to decide whether you are town.

[Iecerint]

Well, not quite. Probably most like trying to determine whether AD could be town due to the perspective being rational.