Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic Mafia (Game Over)

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Ugh...

I disagree with this so much if we are just policy lynching him.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

I rather lynch sure scum or atleast as close as we can get to sure scum.

[Cephrir]

I can't help feeling like we could be using our time better

[Aegor]

Then use the time in a way you find productive instead of complaining about a solid wagon.

[Aegor]

And the resistance to lynching AD with no real effort being made by the detractors kind of makes me want to lynch him more.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Ok tell me how AD is the scummiest player here. How is he scummier than Pere who naked votes points possible scum. How monkees actions comments points possibly to being his scum buddy. His antitown action of placing on TD ( who flipped town). This guy is suspicious as anything and points strongly to being scum

also are we going to accept Aronis claim blindly or are we going to double check his claim till we can be sure he is not fake claiming.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

If AD is scum I am all for lynching him but if this is a policy lynch than lynching him is a bad move... prove to me AD is scum and needs to be lynched.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

* putting a vote on TD because he was asked to and had no good reason to do so...nor could explain why TD was scummy and needed to be lynched.

[The Goat]

I have no problem with this specific policy lynch. I do, however, have major problems with anyone who tries to lynch sans claim.

[GreyICE]

I have no problem with this specific policy lynch. I do, however, have major problems with anyone who tries to lynch sans claim.

Interesting.

Goat, tell me why you believe this is a policy lynch.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Goat
Why do you have no problem with this particular PL.? What makes this difference say on Vezo who has been sort of lurking...

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Pere needs to be wagoned sooner than later and I prefer sooner.

[Aegor]

Ok tell me how AD is the scummiest player here.

He has eight posts.

How is he scummier than Pere who naked votes points possible scum.

Because PV has more content. He could still be scum, though. I largely agree with your case against him, but why not lynch AD today and PV tomorrow?

also are we going to accept Aronis claim blindly or are we going to double check his claim till we can be sure he is not fake claiming.

I think it is a genuine claim.

If AD is scum I am all for lynching him but if this is a policy lynch than lynching him is a bad move... prove to me AD is scum and needs to be lynched.

You cannot "prove" anything. The question is rather whether there is a case against someone. AD's total lack of content is scummy, and his lynch has other practical benefits as well.

My lynch pool right now is {neil, AD, PV}.

[Kdub]

Day 3 - Vote Count #4

Aegor (1)

- Antihero

vezokpiraka (0)

-

Aronis (0)

-

Albert B. Rampage (0)

-

farside22 (0)

-

The Goat (0)

-

PeregrineV (1)

- TheFuzzylogic99

neil1113 (1)

- Albert B. Rampage

Cephrir (0)

-

Antihero (0)

-

TheFuzzylogic99 (0)

-

GreyICE (0)

-

ActionDan (4)

- GreyICE, Aegor, farside22, vezokpiraka

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (6)

- Aronis, The Goat, PeregrineV, neil1113, Cephrir, ActionDan

13 votes available
7 votes needed to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2014-05-17 12:38:11)

Mod: In the votecount it shows I'm voting myself. Is that correct?

Nope, it's been fixed.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

I guess I am dense bc as far as I know lurking is nessarily scum. It can be ..but it is not a solid scum tell.

Why should we lynch Pere first bc AD is not scum ( or atleast not lynch worty yet in my opinion) and Pere is scummy . I am not buying the AD is scum and you or anyone on the AD wagon have given anything solid yet.

Beside the lack of content why is AD scum?

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Edit....Is not nessarilly scummy.

[Aegor]

Beside the lack of content why is AD scum?

That should be more than enough reason.

If someone has no content, how can there be ADDITIONAL reasons for that person being scum? The person has provided NO REASONS. Having other reasons is MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE with a complete lack of content.

[Aegor]

*NO REASONS = no content upon which reasons for thinking him scum could be based

[The Goat]

I have no problem with this specific policy lynch. I do, however, have major problems with anyone who tries to lynch sans claim.

Interesting.

Goat, tell me why you believe this is a policy lynch.

Because of this, mainly.

Ugh...

I disagree with this so much if we are just policy lynching him.

[The Goat]

Goat
Why do you have no problem with this particular PL.? What makes this difference say on Vezo who has been sort of lurking...

By "this particular policy lynch", I mean "lynching someone because they are not posting at all."

I do not agree with a lot of "policy lynches," because many times they really aren't. Many times, it's just a few toolbags hiding behind a phrase to start a wagon on someone they dislike.

In this, instance, however, I see nothing wrong with lynching someone who is not contributing or even posting at all. That behavior is in no way town.

[The Goat]

Pere needs to be wagoned sooner than later and I prefer sooner.

Why?

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Kdub-
Can you replace Action Dan , he has beeen MIA for 7+ days.

Also Peregrine has been Mia 6 days... if he is not VLa than he needs to prodded and prob replaced.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Goat

* Pere pretty much avoided talking about Monkey

* ABR ask him to vote for TD. Without any good reason he put a vote on TD( who flipped town). He could not defend his vote on TD. Basically it was a naked vote.based on nothing

* Monkey's read on him is pretty odd. It feel like Monkey was trying to make a read on him but did not know how. Seems like Peregrine very might be Monkey scum buddy

* Pere placement on TD seems very suspicious

- like Action Dan be has disappeared of late.

[Aegor]

mod: TheFuzzylogic99 has requested replacement or, if necessary, prods for PV and AD

[Aegor]

VOTE: PeregrineV

He has been posting in plenty of other games, and Fuzzy's analysis is correct.