Mewbie 1493~ Game Ovah

[I Love Fairies]

vla.

don't know when I'll be back.

[Malakittens]

Wisdom replaces Saturine.

[Wisdom]

hai

[Not_Mafia]

Hello. So I've heard that when you're in LYLO you're always scum

[Wisdom]

mhm. scum don't let me live when im town so i rarely make it to lylo

too bad they cant control my replace ins!

[Wisdom]

so, how would you summarize this game for me, nm?

[I Love Fairies]

vla.

don't know when I'll be back.

Situation resolved itself.

so, how would you summarize this game for me, nm?

Day 1
: The first post was Josh claiming Vanilla Townie. Everyone got really upset about that.
: Bandwagon started on Josh.
: Bandwagon stopped because everyone thought that no scum would attract that much attention to themselves.
: We spent so much time on Josh that we weren't sure who to go for.
: Bandwagon started on SNS because of his reads list (apparently).
: Secondary bandwagon started against Mithrandar (a replacement who was later replaced by Mr Glidder).
: SNS was lynched. He was town. (goodmorning, Not_Mafia, imkingdavid, mafioso, snscompt1).
: Mithrandar (Mr Glidder) had two votes on him: Ilf and Josh.
: Not Mafia had one vote on him: Mithrandar (Mr Glidder)

Day 2
: Mafioso was killed in the Night.
: Big shitstorm between Josh, GM, and myself.
: Josh tried to push for Mr Glidder.
: I tried to push for GM.
: Josh was lynched. He was town. (Mr Glidder, Not_Mafia, Imkingdavid, goodmorning)
: GM had one vote: Ilf.
: Not Mafia had one vote on him: Saturnine (that's you, Wizzy)

Day 3
: You can read Day 3. It just started.


Those are all the major events of Day 1 and Day 2.

[goodmorning]

WISDOM

so, how would you summarize this game for me, nm?

Mr G is confScum, and your slot seems the likeliest partner.

Not that I'm NotMaf, but I felt like it had to be said.

[Mr Glidder]

That post makes me think it's saturnine after all, though a bus is possible.

Who's bussing who then?

@Mr Glidder: I think you'll find that I haven't been on either lynch so far. In fact, I'm not sure I've ever had a vote on SNS or Josh. It's weird to think that I'm "scummy" because my vote record isn't tarnished by townie blood.

By itself, not being on either mislynch is pretty much null. But as I said, the two Josh_B wagons are so weirdly separate from each other that, combined with him being lynchbait for most of the game, you being the only to not ever vote for him just stands out. The SNS wagon okay I might have to look over again.

[I Love Fairies]

So what you're saying is that I must be scum because I'm pretty much the only person to not lynch town? I personally think both the converse and inverse would apply. Seems pretty WIFOM to me.

[goodmorning]

That post makes me think it's saturnine after all, though a bus is possible.

Who's bussing who then?

You're bussing NotMaf.

[Mr Glidder]

Okay so the SNS wagon:

IKD

on (1),

IKD

off (0), saturnine on (1), GM on (2),

J_B

on (3),

J_B

off (2), saturnine off (1) (puts lurktastic N_M slot to L-1, then N_M replaces in), N_M on (2),

IKD

on (3),

mafioso

on (4),

SNS

self-hammer (5).

Josh_B

's D1 wagon: saturnine on (1),

my slot

on (2),

mafioso

on (3),

sns

on (4),

mafioso

off (3), saturnine off (2),

mafioso

on (3),

sns

off (2),

my slot

off (1),

mafioso

off (0).

Josh_B

's D2 wagon:

me

on (1), N_M on (2), GM on (3), GM off (2),

IKD

on (3), GM hammer (4).

N_M being scum fits into this; he's the second vote on the final lynch of one of his two counterwagons (the other being my slot), the rest of which is town and GM. GM's SNS vote was town (once explained). saturnine's vote on SNS, which started the wagon aside from IKD's single vote, looks null to me, as does how he left the wagon for N_M's slot. So looking at this wagon, I'm more convinced that N_M is scum, and my opinion of others doesn't really change.

[Wisdom]

Mr G is confScum

There's a confscum? How come we're not lynching them then?

[Wisdom]

I don't see anything in ILF's summary to indicate that either?

[Wisdom]

Anyway, I'll try to read soon

[goodmorning]

Mr G is confScum

There's a confscum? How come we're not lynching them then?

We're waiting for you, and also he keeps talking which is handy. I don't think he knows he's confScum yet.

I don't think ILF picked it up either.

[Mr Glidder]

Mr G is confScum

There's a confscum? How come we're not lynching them then?

We're waiting for you, and also he keeps talking which is handy. I don't think he knows he's confScum yet.

I don't think ILF picked it up either.

I was going to continue ignoring this hyperbolic assertion, but since you appear to be serious, please select one of the following:

1. By "confScum", I mean "They have scumslipped in [this post]".
2. By "confScum", I mean "I have [an incriminating result] on them".
3. By "confScum", I mean "I have [benign results on others] so PoE".
4. By "confScum", I mean "I'm that sure of my read on them".
5. By "confScum", I mean "I'm that sure of my read on that slot".

[Malakittens]

3.01

With Five Alive.. It takes Three to Lynch

Voting:

*I Love Fairies -
*wisdom -
*Mr Glidder -
*Not_Mafia -
*goodmorning -

Not Voting:

Mr Glidder, Not_Mafia, goodmorning, I Love Fairies, wisdom [5]

Mew Count Downs

Day 3 ends in.. (expired on 2014-05-21 23:48:00)

[I Love Fairies]

Mr G is confScum

There's a confscum? How come we're not lynching them then?

We're waiting for you, and also he keeps talking which is handy. I don't think he knows he's confScum yet.

I don't think ILF picked it up either.

Picked what up?

[goodmorning]

That Mr G is confScum.

[I Love Fairies]

You serious? Are you really serious?

Josh and I were the first one's to point out that Phlox, Mithrandar, and then Mr Glidder were all obvscum.

Did I get everyone? I think so. Right now, I'd be most willing to lynch Mr Glidder (sorry, the past 2 people for that role slot were super scummy) IMD, and Saturnine. I'm conflicted as to who I want to put my vote on, but I'll take a gamble and put it on IMD. It should go without saying that in the threads current state, I'm not really willing to lynch any of the members of this game that I did not mention in my list of who I'd like to lynch.

VOTE: IMD

I don't like a N_M lynch or a Josh lynch, but I'm okay with a GM or Mr Glidder lynch. Seeing as the GM lynch doesn't seem to be happening, I'll switch my vote to Mr Glidder.


UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mr Glidder

I believe the scum team is GM and Mr Glidder. However, I'm less certain about GM than I am Mr Glidder at this point, so I retract my previous statement and will say I'd rather lynch him instead of GM.

We should wait for Saturnine to come back before we make any decisions.

I really honestly don't want to lynch either of the current wagons. People need to look back at N_M's previous games. His behavior is the same in all of them regardless of alignment. Sure, his lack of reasoning would be scummy, but because he doesn't usually give much reasoning, it's not alignment indicative for him.

With Josh, I can see myself lynching him to a point, but given that if we mislynch we have a fair chance of losing (I think) I don't want to vote on anyone besides my preferred lynches. Like I said before, I'd be okay with lynching Mr Glidder or GM. I don't want this game to end Day2 because scum are guiding a mislynch with nonalignment indicative information.

I see that instead of trying to fix the problem (of people calling you out for not posting reads), you're continuing to prolong it via snark and buckpassing.

We can only deal with so many people at once. If you're not giving us a reason to finish hounding you and move elsewhere, well then we won't.

Mr Glidder:

Both of his predecessors were horribly scummy. Both times, the players who preceeded him were on the chopping block, and they were only spared because of their inactivity. As it is now, I feel like Mr Glidder is only picking out arguments from whatever the current situation is and making something that seems reasonable to appear more town. It

appears

as though he's posting a large amount of content, but in reality, he's adding little to nothing. He's only bolstering arguments that are obviously already strong so that he can ride off of the coattails of those arguments. Besides GM, I'd be most willing to lynch Mr Glidder. In fact, Mr Glidder is quickly becoming someone that I'd like to lynch over GM. Scum read.

Honestly though, unless something happens or someone slips, for the remainder of this game, it's unlikely I will vote anyone but Goodmorning or Mr Glidder. If we don't lynch one of them Today, we lose anyways, so there would be no point in me switching my vote to whoever has the highest vote.

For the past two days, nearly every single one of my posts has been saying just how much I'd like to lynch either you or Mr Glidder/Mith.

[Not_Mafia]

obvscum =/= conf scum. By conf scum GM literally means 100% beyond a shadow of a doubt confirmed scum. Mr G/Wisdom is confirmed in my mind, I could lynch now

[goodmorning]

obvscum =/= conf scum.

[I Love Fairies]

obvscum =/= conf scum. By conf scum GM literally means 100% beyond a shadow of a doubt confirmed scum. Mr G/Wisdom is confirmed in my mind, I could lynch now

Unless in the case of a cop investigation or a positive track the Night after the doctor dies, you can NEVER 100% beyond a shadow of a doubt be certain someone is scum. 95% or so is the highest you can get without a cop investigation or a conclusive track.

Seeing as not a lot more is happening in regards to discussion, who should start off the voting?

[I Love Fairies]

^^^^ Wait wait wait, before we do that, we should let Wisdom catch up and post HIS thoughts as well.