Newbie 1505 (Game Over)

[Bulbazak]

I assume RVS is over

Why would you think we are still in RVS?

I can only assume Reisse is scum or a powerrole in some way for his paranoid plays. Which I am NOT willing to gamble on a reisse lynch.

Unvote

Vote Reissebach

[OkaPoka]

Because my previous Newb game Day 1 was 2 pages, that game was really weird.

So I don't know the meta that much.

It is a great game btw

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=44815

[mallowgeno]

@mallow

I realize that I'm town, but there is no reason except for my word that you should cross me off your list of potential suspects.

I still don't like that you are saying we shouldn't trust you. It sounds like a double bluff in that you are trying to say don't trust you because you could be scum and by that wanting us to think you are town.

[Zaicon]

Vote Count 1.4

OkaPoka (2):

, mallowgeno, kyndy101

reissebach (2):

AxleGreaser, Bulbazak

AxleGreaser (1):

reissebach

kyndy101 (1):

OkaPoka

No Vote (3):

3dicerolling, Doogal121, mishai

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!

Deadline is Friday, Jun 6, at 7:00 PM CDT, which is in (expired on 2014-06-06 19:00:00).

Due to some personal matters, I will unfortunately be un available for the next 5 or 6 days. Hopefully it will be five and I would get a chance to get back to the forum before the deadline, but there is the possibility that i would not...

I completely understand if you all feel the need to replace me, although I would prefer to remain in the game.

Due to the nature of the game, activity is required from every player, so I'm going to have to replace you.

[Zaicon]

Xayzeck replaces reissebach.

[Xayzeck]

hey oka

hey kyndy

hey bulba

how have you guys been

[Xayzeck]

i would love to read this, but it feels like a tad of a clusterbunch of posts that don't really motivate me

so summary would be nice

or any important points such as:
scumslips
claims
L-1 wagons
main scumspects of the town

I'll skim the previous pages tomorrow, but for now

UNVOTE:

let's have fun, yeah?

[Doogal121]

Vote: Kyndy

Three reasons
1. She is really trying to blend in and lay low.
2. She tries to get a derailed bandwagon (oka) back on track.
3. Deadline is coming and a no vote is not an option any more.

And, one OOC reason, if She needs to be replaced next week anyway, we are going to have to adapt to a new player and try to reread the slot. Sorry Kyndy, and I hope your surgery goes well.

[3dicerolling]

hey oka

hey kyndy

hey bulba

how have you guys been

[Bulbazak]

2. She tries to get a derailed bandwagon (oka) back on track.

How was it derailed? It was still one of the leading wagons.

Speaking of...

Unvote

Vote OkaPoka

[3dicerolling]

I see what you're saying bulba, but my gut just doesn't like the Oka wagon for some reason. What my gut does like is this.

VOTE: Mallowgeno

[Bulbazak]

Why is Mallow scum? He looks pretty town to me.

[3dicerolling]

Why is Mallow scum? He looks pretty town to me.

Why do you always assume the person I vote I think is scum? Sometimes I vote null reads, sometimes I vote leaning scum reads, sometimes I vote straight up scum reads.

And the fact you think mallow looks pretty town bugs me. Read all the posts he has made.

[OkaPoka]

@Mod

Mishai prod please?

Mallow is just saying what bulba is saying in my opinion.

I actually am considering to not vote kyndy because rereading the previous game, kyndy is playing almost EXACTLY how she played last game. But my vote will be kept. I am waiting for some Xay reads.

I don't think Bulba is scum, I think Bulba is just extremely careful about everything he does and wants best for town, I could be wrong though. Has anyone played against a bulba scum before?

[Xayzeck]

Has anyone played against a bulba scum before?

i have

we were scum together once

i don't remember much of it because he kept walling the thread so i didn't read a lot of it

[OkaPoka]

What is your read on Kyndy??? to everyone who hasn't answered.

[Bulbazak]

Why do you always assume the person I vote I think is scum? Sometimes I vote null reads, sometimes I vote leaning scum reads, sometimes I vote straight up scum reads.

Because the default interpretation for a vote is "scum read". I also like to inquire into other's reasoning if I don't understand the vote.

And the fact you think mallow looks pretty town bugs me. Read all the posts he has made.

Could it be that I'm using a different set of criteria than you?

Has anyone played against a bulba scum before?

i have

we were scum together once

i don't remember much of it because he kept walling the thread so i didn't read a lot of it

We were also town in Mafia Among the Chosen, where I called Varsoon scum correctly d1 and got his partner lynched.

[kyndy101]

hey oka

hey kyndy

hey bulba

how have you guys been

Hey Xay! Long time no see! Hahaha. Sorry for thinking you were scum last game, BTW...

Vote: Kyndy

Three reasons
1. She is really trying to blend in and lay low.
2. She tries to get a derailed bandwagon (oka) back on track.
3. Deadline is coming and a no vote is not an option any more.

And, one OOC reason, if She needs to be replaced next week anyway, we are going to have to adapt to a new player and try to reread the slot. Sorry Kyndy, and I hope your surgery goes well.

Ok... then.. I do see where you find point one. I... Point two? That wagon twas derailed? When did you classify it as derailed? I don't think any wagon is on the tracks, actually. Anyone could be scum. But I think Oka just seems.. More scummy...
Point three is why I decided okascum

OOC: thanks, I hope so too!

[AxleGreaser]

Has anyone played against a bulba scum before?

i have
we were scum together once
i don't remember much of it because he kept walling the thread

so i didn't read a lot of it

i would love to read this, but it feels like a tad of a clusterbunch of posts that don't really motivate me
[...]

I'll skim the previous pages tomorrow,

but for now
UNVOTE:

This not reading the stuff thats in the thread thing will both bug me and appear to be scum motivated.

Spoiler: your predecessors posts and _NO_ amish tells...

amish tell
I am not sure how to play in face of replacements like this. (I cant not consider nor post about Reissebach, replacing does not buy a free NULL read) >

but

<
it is fair that I don't require (or try to make) you) defend your predecessors posts, if I couldn't find good towny explanation for them neither can you (even if you are town). (also see Amish tell)
However that the predecessor made such posts, is still a reason to lynch your slot and townies pointing out why they regard your predeccessors slots as scummy is still a towny thing to do even if noone is in a position to provide the alternate (if any) explanation..
Given that your predecessor had got up to the point of saying he wouldn't discuss it further, I see it is clear there is no explanation for some parts of it.
How abouts we all be reasonable people and have fun finding scum.(while the scum have fun hiding)

Why you must read the other (non reiseebach) stuff in the thread....

You played(substitute) with Oka and Lyndy in newbie 1492 which is Oka previous game.

You could read their play in the CONTEXT of the entire thread, and you know do towny stuff.

or

You could hide in the I am not motivated enough to read the thread vibe.... and hope your predecessors posts somehow get forgotten.

So yeah lets have fun playing mafia...

[Xayzeck]

Dont even know what the above post is about, but I would love to lynch it because its sooooo awkwaaaaaard

[AxleGreaser]

You played(substitute) with Oka and Lyndy in newbie 1492 which is Oka previous game.

@everyone (except kyndy as he was there.... and xay joined around page 11)

If you read Oka previous game be craeful do NOT just read his ISO read the game (it will hurt) or at least read my TLDR below

Because my previous Newb game Day 1 was 2 pages, that game was really weird.
[...]
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=44815

OKAs game

Spoiler: TLDR

In RVS
Player A put players S

at L-1 didn't notice and didn't say they had.

Player B

'drunk' RVS hammers

players S... without noticing. (

NO intent post

)
Player A unvotes player S

not noticing the hammer.

Player S Flips scum!!!!!!!!
Players A & B

claim confirmed town status... for huh?

(I know the odds are not even but drunk IDGAF voting as town and scum are both plausible)

any then it gets actually weird....

Player B

fake claims doctor...

.
after while
Oka (remember Oka the first game newb, who was town in that game)

Oka CC the doctor as Oka is actually the 1sBP

lots of really big font (double size=2 x huge)

SHOUTING

then player B

(who is town) self hammers complete with table flipping rage gif?

I am not sure what you can take from that game and expect to be the same in this one.

Plausible things:
I can obtain an estimate of the skill level I can expect from Oka
I can find out whether or not when (town)Xay replaces in does he in fact go back through the game and read it. (and ping TSO as scum...)
I can get a better feel for whether or not, a towny Lyndy really does distance herself from he reads in such a self deprecating way as town.
There is stuff, that I can expect to be a bit consistent, but be vewy vewy careful out there folks that is a scary misleading game.

[AxleGreaser]

Dont even know what the above post is about, but I would love to lynch it because its sooooo awkwaaaaaard

So what is the scum motivation in me writing "sooooo awkwaaaaaard" or do you regularly, as town, lynch anyone you can socially stigmatise?

If you mean you want to lynch because I am actually thinking about the game and trying to solve it please say so...

[OkaPoka]

My game was pretty much lynch all liars, think of all possibilities and started lynching. Which could've ended miserably but Xay held through.

[3dicerolling]

Why do you always assume the person I vote I think is scum? Sometimes I vote null reads, sometimes I vote leaning scum reads, sometimes I vote straight up scum reads.

Because the default interpretation for a vote is "scum read". I also like to inquire into other's reasoning if I don't understand the vote.

I guess.

And the fact you think mallow looks pretty town bugs me. Read all the posts he has made.

Could it be that I'm using a different set of criteria than you?

That or you could be scum.

Has anyone played against a bulba scum before?

i have

we were scum together once

i don't remember much of it because he kept walling the thread so i didn't read a lot of it

We were also town in Mafia Among the Chosen, where I called Varsoon scum correctly d1 and got his partner lynched.

[Xayzeck]

So what is the scum motivation in me writing "sooooo awkwaaaaaard" or do you regularly, as town, lynch anyone you can socially stigmatise?

If you mean you want to lynch because I am actually thinking about the game and trying to solve it please say so...

awkward is usually scum

and your posts feel so messy, reading them is hard, and i want to lynch you for it

but i understand this is a newbie so i'll refrain from doing so