Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[Aegor]

More specifically, mastin has just been posting tons of "analysis" that is actually more IIoA and then saying that it vaguely leads to feelings that someone is somehow scummy, but no more specificity can be provided, of course.

[mastin2]

More specifically, mastin has just been posting tons of "analysis" that is actually more IIoA and then saying that it vaguely leads to feelings that someone is somehow scummy, but no more specificity can be provided, of course.

I fully admit the IIoA parts are IIoA, but I haven't posted JUST IIoA. (As for you wanting specifics. The thing about vague is that it's kinda the

antonym

of specific. As in, when I say I have vague feelings...I don't have the ability to specifically pinpoint things and tell you in detail what they mean because that's specifics that're the opposite of what I actually have.)

[Squirrel Girl]

More specifically, mastin has just been posting tons of "analysis" that is actually more IIoA and then saying that it vaguely leads to feelings that someone is somehow scummy, but no more specificity can be provided, of course.

She has offered promises of clarifying stuff.

I'll admit I've had to be after her to avoid that...but I feel I've had to do the exact same with you, so if you think it's a scumtell could you please stop doing it also? I think vagueness can be pro-scum, but I certainly see town do it a lot more than I'd like, It isn't a case I'm going to support much.

[Kdub]

zMuffin's behavior with regard to the wagons on you/HKC yesterday

What are you seeing there? I didn't see anything that twigged me much one way or t'other from him.

I explained this in 2002, and you disagreed. I'm a bit puzzled why you asked me this again.

VOTE: Aegor

Leaving it up to penguin to decide the lynch. I'd probably prefer mastin over Aegor tbh, but it's clearly either me or Aegor today and I know Aegor at least has a chance to flip scum.

[Aegor]

Kdub, would you be willing to vote mastin? I am happy to vote mastin. If you vote, I will follow.

[Kdub]

Is anyone else up for a mastin lynch? I'd go for it if we could get another.

[Mac]

I don't think we should lynch anyone until mastin clarifies what she is talking about. I'm on the fence about mastin right now, prefer Aegor at least, but I won't know about her for sure until she's a bit clearer about where she's coming from.

Why don't you move your vote to mastin and actually press her, instead of only offering to if others will follow?

In the meantime, I'll doc penguin tonight but I'm meh about it all really.

[penguin_alien]

I'm not up for a mastin lynch. Leaning Aegor, but I want to reread some stuff first since there's time. Plus letting those who want t hear from mastin hear more.

[Squirrel Girl]

I explained this in 2002, and you disagreed. I'm a bit puzzled why you asked me this again.

Probably because I didn't understand it then either, and you just sort of shrugged at me when I asked about it. I'll agree that you caught me reacting the same to the same confusing statement on two occasions.

Kdub, would you be willing to vote mastin? I am happy to vote mastin. If you vote, I will follow.

Ew.

Is anyone else up for a mastin lynch? I'd go for it if we could get another.

Ewwwww.

I want to reread some stuff first since there's time.

I would love it if you would do so and commit enough to feel comfortable offering opinions. I am not very super stoked with your efforts thus far. I mean, I'm actually missing Jake here at this stage, you can take that as a reflection on your gameplay however you will

[mastin2]

She has offered promises of clarifying stuff.

Just don't expect it today. (Probs-not tomorrow, either, circumstances depending.) Final weeks of college and all that, slightly V/LA in that I don't want to have my rl suffer for my mafia games. (But I'm otherwise fine since I think I can get it done before deadline, depending on when deadline is. I can likely squeeze in time tonight if deadline were to be, say, tomorrow [same will be true tomorrow], but obviously, I have other things I'm juggling that I'd like to tackle first if not.)

I don't think we should lynch anyone until mastin clarifies what she is talking about.

It'd help if you asked me on what.
And also, for your own take on things. Like, I raised a buncha stuff that might not be strictly analyzed, but had implied analysis behind it, making it not pure IioA; there's stuff like my take on Aegor hammering HKC for instance.

I'll do what I can to show where I'm coming from, but how about you show me where you are, and not only that, but on the things I have, give your take on them?

[Kdub]

Why don't you move your vote to mastin and actually press her, instead of only offering to if others will follow?

If the support isn't there for a mastin lynch, then my vote would be pointless. Like I said, I have no issue with mastin's play. I'm just going by the evidence of his predecessor's actions, which he can't really answer for.

In the meantime, I'll doc penguin tonight but I'm meh about it all really.

If you don't protect penguin tonight and have him confirm your action, you die tomorrow. The risk/reward of you doing anything else just doesn't make sense.

[Squirrel Girl]

I'll do what I can to show where I'm coming from, but how about you show me where you are, and not only that, but on the things I have, give your take on them?

Do you realize that your current reads are functionally mirroring what Mac and I both indicated our reads were at the start of the Day phase? You're like the last kid on the swing set wanting to try to explain to the other kids how to swing or something I make funny faces about it, but at the same time I'm bringing it up because it's really weird to me as a conversation topic. You feel very disassociated from the game right now.

[Aegor]

Still here. Nothing to add.

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 4.4

[3] Aegor (Mac, Squirrel Girl, Kdub)
[3] Kdub (mastin2, BROseidon, Aegor)

[1] Not Voting (penguin_alien)

With 7 alive, it is 4 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-06-11 08:00:00)

[borkjerfkin]

BROseidon was prodded.

[BROseidon]

Don't got nothin'.

[Aegor]

Someone please hammer one of us, or I will hammer myself.

[mastin2]

You feel very disassociated from the game right now.

Kinda goes without saying?

Butyeah, I'm on V/LA for today. And I want tomorrow off as well, but deadline's five days away and this'll still give me three.

[Aegor]

I am not waiting that long.

[mastin2]

I'd prefer you keep a lynch on Kdub, since you're going to flip town I'm fairly certain.

[Squirrel Girl]

I am filled with nutty rage for both of you...also for BRO, but that's nothing new.

@BRO - why aren't you replacing out?

[Kdub]

BRO, why are you voting me?

[BROseidon]

@BRO - why aren't you replacing out?

Why are you being unreasonably rude?

[BROseidon]

BRO, why are you voting me?

PoE

[BROseidon]

@BRO - why aren't you replacing out?

Why are you being unreasonably rude?

Also, I would have used nastier language here, but I respect bork too much to force him to warn me.