Mini 1578: Lord of the Rings!! - GaME OVeR

[Protogonos]

VOTE: ThreetoMango

[Protogonos]

Convince me that protecting Bulb and then submitting no action whatsoever in plausible in any way, and I will consider moving this vote.

[ThreetoMango]

Uhm, protecting Bulb was already discussed, he was our biggest townread at the time.
Not protecting anyone last night was already discussed as well: We are idiots.
Any more questions?

[ThreetoMango]

^
~MTD

[ThreetoMango]

11 hours away from the deadline I mentioned we had 11 hours left and still needed to decide a targeted, and I suggested Guyett. Nobody responded, and I ended up forgetting and going to sleep. Mastin then came in and said that she didn't submit.

- Dice

[ThreetoMango]

^this. I honestly don't know how I forgot about it myself.

~MTD

[Guyett]

[*]

Borimir as bodyguard makes sense.... but is he town given the influence of the ring?

Uhm, how would a scum bodyguard make sense?

Earth to shithead there are prob scum fakeclaims with appropriate flavour names

[Guyett]

Ease of idiot hydra wagon concerns me

[Protogonos]

Guyett, could you please commit to a time at which you will share why you wanted to frame Drew?

[Guyett]

I'll be hone in like ab hiur

[Freja]

Pants head here.

Talking with Toast, we are both in agreement that what makes the PR claims uneasy is the fact that neither of the proven pr's is necessarily a town pr, and while bodyguard is only useful for town we don't know if it is an accurate claim. Since scum is hunting for the ring, or would be if day 1 didn't go so poorly, having a scum flavor cop could possibly be a way to find who is Frodo. Double voter, of course, can go either way.

Personally I think we need to name claim right now. Toast and I agree that all the scum likely don't have obvious scum names like Sauron or The Witch King of Angmar, but at the same time we might be able to use the Flavor cop to test name claims we feel uneasy about. This has extra utility if Aronis is scum, as it means he would possibly have to out his own teammates. Additionally, if we dont end up lynching Mango, he should protect Aronis as well. If Aronis dies at night we would be pretty sure mango has to be scum. If scum doesn't target the Flavor cop then they run a serious risk of losing if both the Flavor cop and the body guard live and we net the second scum.

[Protogonos]

I still do not understand why the Vig has not claimed.

[ThreetoMango]

Toast and I agree that all the scum likely don't have obvious scum names like Sauron or The Witch King of Angmar

What confuses me about this is that Bulba

did

have a pretty obvious name. This makes me think that the name-cop might actually be

more

likely to be scum than town.

Additionally, if we dont end up lynching Mango, he should protect Aronis as well. If Aronis dies at night we would be pretty sure mango has to be scum. If scum doesn't target the Flavor cop then they run a serious risk of losing if both the Flavor cop and the body guard live and we net the second scum.

If this happens, please remember that if we die, that doesn't clear Aronis, though.

~MTD

[ThreetoMango]

I still do not understand why the Vig has not claimed.

Would have to be FH I guess, or has anyone else not claimes?

~MTD

[Freja]

We are the vig.

Given our stance on Bulba this should have been somewhat obvious.

[ThreetoMango]

Just popping in to say I won't be on at all tomorrow.

Also, I got us an avvy \o/

[ThreetoMango]

- Dice

[Fail Hydra]

Honestly, with all the hate and ad-hominem going on in this game, I'm not finding the motivation to post :/

We're Gimli, a simple VT.

I'm not sure why Rach isn't dead yet o.O She needs rope, now. And if you don't agree, go relook at her ISO. She's had literally two votes, one RVS, the other on Aronis (for calling the town 'them' not 'us'). No scumhunting, and pretty much going through this game trying to stay completely unnoticed and be as useless to town as possible.
VOTE: Rach

Still not seeing the mango!scum here, can someone summarize the case for me?

--Piggy--

[Fail Hydra]

VOTE: ThreetoMango

Why?
In fact, I'm also really curious why you would be okay to hammer them too.

[Protogonos]

In fact, I'm also really curious why you would be okay to hammer them too.

First, please let me know how many games you have played with Rach.

Second, 3TM has contributed exactly 0 to this game, admits a PR that basically cannot be verified ever beyond a Flavor Cop investigation, and if then, could still be scum, also admits that a three-person hydra failed to use the power N2 and used it on someone scummy as hell Day 1, and had a consistent townread on flipped scum that could easily have been scum defending a buddy.

[Fail Hydra]

In fact, I'm also really curious why you would be okay to hammer them too.

First, please let me know how many games you have played with Rach.

What does that have to do with you hammering 32M?

Second, 3TM has contributed exactly 0 to this game, admits a PR that basically cannot be verified ever beyond a Flavor Cop investigation, and if then, could still be scum, also admits that a three-person hydra failed to use the power N2 and used it on someone scummy as hell Day 1, and had a consistent townread on flipped scum that could easily have been scum defending a buddy.

Fair enough, if Rach isn't the lynch I'm fine with 32M seeing rope.

--Piggy--

[Protogonos]

It was just a question I want answered; it had nothing to do with hammering 32M.

[Fail Hydra]

I think start to finish we've only played 1 game, but she's replaced into several of mine (and vise versa), but since she pointed out her own meta, all meta on her is automatically discredited imo.

--Piggy--

[Guyett]

Guyett, could you please commit to a time at which you will share why you wanted to frame Drew?

For fun and another reason I will discuss at a later time.

Proto and freida are effectively conf town and aronis is slightly less.

[Guyett]

oh misread that. I'll talk about it tomorrow