NY 173: Knight-Errant 2 - GAME OVER!

[Marquis]

VOTE: Bomber

Bomber has to be scum. I mean look at their play yesterday. It was horrible and now they were just content on hopping on some wagon at the start of the day. They don't even give a reason. They aren't sheeping a town read otherwise they would have said so.

Hopkirk is in the same boat coming in here saying nothing but voting.

I don't agree with this, but I approve of the mindset. Some people were concerned about BC yesterday, but what with the awkwardly high (town) placement on PV's scumlist and interactions with the dead, I think he is very likely town.

I need to look back, but for now,
VOTE: Hopkirk.
We may attempt to readlist today.

Iago

First post of Day 2. They got a beastcharizard innocent.

Actually I also think that might be in order. We were only holding off (well I was anyway, Jafar seemed to have the right of this one) on lords and ssk on the assumption they were masons. I can't do tags on this stupid phone though.

oh wait yes I can it's just a huge pain

VOTE: lords of the unreal

Iago

I can answer both those questions, it's because both of them have been lurking as though there were a nobel prize for it

Iago

First posts of Day 3. I think their target died or something.

Nice bob kill I like it


Also twisted advice is likely town I guess

vote unreal

Khan is not sk either

These might be breadcrumbs. 1270 could be useful for speculating about his target last night but not that useful.

Also, I did a little bit of rereading last night, and I don't think I've been giving notscience enough credit. I'd rather look into LOTU/Lemni today, as they didn't particularly come out looking better than I expected.

Iago

Only thing that bothers me about Anti is the fact I started pushing Cho-Scum and now this day phrase he votes our hydra due to a wiki page. Something feels off.

A) Cho is now "Cho-Scum" despite the fact that she was a lean at worst two lines ago.
B) This is just not a good reason to ultimately throw Anti in your suspect pool.

VOTE: Cho

Last but not least, this vote is just incorrect!

Iago

I'm town, confirmed.

[Marquis]

@Mod: replace Cho with Marquis, please!

Almost made it the whole game without slipping too.

VOTE: Turkish Van

[Marquis]

policy lynch when TV was being discussed

Vote for Turkish Van.

Antihero, vote for Turkish Van.

I don't want scum to shut this wagon down before it even gets anywhere.

[Marquis]

I'm at the point where I can feel a town win close by. This reminds me of the last K-E.

Antihero, please rein me in if I start getting too crazy.

07. M God, T Cop, M RB, T RB
18. M E-Watch, T RB, M RB, T Cop
41. T RB, M RB, T Cop, M E-Watch
44. M God, T RB, M RB, T Cop

[Marquis]

Oh, I thought you were wrong. I only saw the first Mafia Godfather name and not the last.

I know what you're implying though and I feel like I would have played more fearlessly and less quietly if I was Mafia Godfather.

[Marquis]

[Marquis]

You're not SK, you're mafia.

[Marquis]

Bye bye. I'll be back later.

[Marquis]

You're not SK, you're mafia.

:rolls eyes: I have exactly two games here in 75+ where I've bussed a partner. One was Open 459, one of my first games on site, and Day One bussing led to a town romp. The other was Mini 1527 where I was utterly screwed anyways and took a Hail Mary on living another day (and definitely shouldn't have). Get a better working theory, please and thank you.

--PA

I actually said that in reference to your incorrect ideas about how the setup is determined- the four roles on the chart are determined in one fell swoop, or one move, from start to finish. It's not determined by hopping from one point to another, which totally negates the point of the setup because that would allow for any combination of a random four on that chart.

I think that because of your interpretation you probably aren't the Serial Killer, who would know about the powers in play already and consequently wouldn't come to the mistaken conclusion that you did, or even think of potentially faking that sort of conclusion about the game setup. Again, there's a slim possibility you faked not knowing how roles were determined, but at this point I'm just going to take whatever process of elimination puzzle pieces I can get.

[Marquis]

Titus is female.

Kublai Khan is scum.

[Marquis]

Also, at first I trusted Turkish Van's application of self meta on the idea that scum wouldn't risk doing it. Then I realized that I'm too lazy to check it and on policy don't like it because I still have the feeling Turkish Van is mafia.

The idea that you don't bus that often, and therefore didn't bus now, is one that I don't just like on policy, but that I also don't like because it sounds way too much like a probability fallacy.

[Marquis]

Ah. I'm not paying that much attention to the setup. I didn't know for sure if there was a cop. I thought it was just bluster.

There was a possibility of a Doctor instead of a Cop.

I don't know whether to take you at face value or not.

[Marquis]

checking in, no motivation rn

[Marquis]

anti, can we combine a concrete townread list and work outward from there?

my townreads

anti
marquis
titus (weak)

jbomber (very weak because it only existed yesterday)

[Marquis]

also

3 of the 7 players alive are scum.

i'm not saying random lynch, but random lynch.

[Marquis]

Oops! I completely forgot to type "properly".

cho is dead. long live marquis

[Marquis]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: antihero

[Marquis]

whoops i blanked out for a sec

UNVOTE:
VOTE: khan

[Marquis]

@mod: v/la for 1-3 days? because really sick

[Marquis]

one of you has to be town, but i don't even have an inkling of who it is

[Marquis]

titus just

stop

and unvote

i'm not going to ask you to vote khan right now

but i'm asking you to not let a hammer happen just yet

[Marquis]

jfc

two of you have to be town

but it feels like all five of you are really weak mafia or something like what the fuck

[Marquis]

let's sort this

[Marquis]

Titus

jbomber732


zMuffinMan

Turkish Van


Kublai Khan

[Marquis]

approximately where i am right now in my reads, line breaks and all, town to scum

[Marquis]

wait no


Titus


jbomber732


Turkish Van
zMuffinMan



Kublai Khan

pedit whatever i'm going with anti's list

[Marquis]

you basically asked for permission to hammer. you don't get any brownie points for that, especially if the game isn't going to end with that lynch anyway.

[Marquis]

best mason

[Marquis]

[Marquis]

bah go town