InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Nero Cain]

eh, not voting. Lets see if you can change my mind.

[Nero Cain]

But Neil is more scummy?

sure? Not sure how one scum is "scumier" than the other scum but...atleast for Neil we have him defending lemi so I think that could be a possible buddy and an OS town offers more upside than a Neil town. + I don't like how you and him are pretending like I'm not confirmed NOT bo7. I'm town but from the perspective of any outsider not privvy to my role pm I think this would point to me being less likely to be scum.

[Oversoul]

Is the him in that post directed towards me? I never gave a read on your slot.

[Nero Cain]

him is Neil but...gut read on me plox and why.

[Oversoul]

I got up to page 23, actually. I think you're probably town.

I am compiling a small catchup post (140 pages, may not be small when I finish). Cliff notes for NC town read: argument with Tbone about your actions.

[Svenskt Stål]

ffer, i fucking love you

[Squirrel Girl]

I don't like how you and him are pretending like I'm not confirmed NOT bo7. I'm town but from the perspective of any outsider not privvy to my role pm I think this would point to me being less likely to be scum.

I would think I'm as confirmed on that as you are - you still suspect me. Or is it only scummy when other people do it to you?

[Young and Beautiful]

Can somebody sum up for me why BoP isn't dead yet? Seems like a counterwagon has formed.

This game is getting too draggy and stally, ugh.

- b -

[Squirrel Girl]

Because no one has summed up why BoP should be dead.

[Squirrel Girl]

I mean, I understand there was a rush there - I can't tell you why.

[shos]

because BoP's claim is great.

[Young and Beautiful]

Because no one has summed up why BoP should be dead.

Because BoP is scum.

Because BoP is Titus, and Titus is scum, ergo BoP is scum.


What was her claim anyway? Didn't see it. Probably cant negate her scum-positive game the whole time though.

Ugh, Nero Cain, this is deva ju; except Titus is scum this time.

- b -

[Moogle Dance Troupe]

because BoP's claim is great.

Just so we're all on the same page here, the claim was "great" in that there's every reason to believe BoP is indeed an ascetic.

This doesn't imply that he's town, and based on the ability distributions we've seen, arguably implies the opposite. Ascetic appears to be strictly negative utility if town.

[Young and Beautiful]

Ummm.... Ascetics are always scum-roles.

:/

- b -

[Birds of Prey]

Because BoP is scum.

Because BoP is Titus, and Titus is scum, ergo BoP is scum.

Bad news for you is that I can vouch that Titus can't possibly be scum.

But, I'll even double check the role PM, in case I forgot.

......

Nope, we're town.

And I'm supposing this is only some sort of push, and that you have a legitimate reason that I'll have to go look up.

~P

[Young and Beautiful]

Hello, PeregrineV.

I know you.

And...

your slot is not town.

- b -

[geists]

Ummm.... Ascetics are always scum-roles.

:/

- b -

Not true.

[Birds of Prey]

Oh oh oh!

I know who Lemniscate is now!

She is absolutely, positively town!

The progression of her claims in which she casually drops things with each new post screams town to me.

I should clarify: While both town and scum can claim or fakeclaim seamlessly, Lemniscate's constant "what the fuck" reaction-eliciting claim posts are very likely town. I don't think she as scum would risk muddling her claim up like this; I doubt that as scum Lemniscate's claim would be this ill-prepared. The situation strikes me more like an actual town mason, panicking because she didn't expect herself to be run up as the biggest wagon by far at a time so close to deadline.

- y -

Lemniscate, Jakotsu, Band of Seven Mafia Undead 2-shot Nonconsecutive Ninja

, lynched Day 1.

Titus is 100% scum. Her hydra slip effectively ruined her whole game; as she was banking on it to hide her scum meta. No longer.

VOTE: BoP

Trust me on this one.

- b -

So no actual reason found, but based on this + your other posts, Elf and shos are also town.

[geists]

I'm not going to, but it's really tempting to vote Y&B just to remove some of the noise from the game.

[Oversoul]

No I haven't caught up yet page 40

[geists]

I would love for someone who thinks Mist is town to make a case for that.

[Birds of Prey]

Hello, PeregrineV.

I know you.

And...

your slot is not town.

- b -

But it is.

~P

[geists]

I would love for someone who thinks Mist is town to make a case for that.

I mean look at her ISO. nearly every post has been some form of beetlejuice. Her last post here was on Friday - over 4 days ago - and was in reaction to my vote. Since then, no comments about her except me over here in the corner grumbling.

[Birds of Prey]

I would love for someone who thinks Mist is town to make a case for that.

I mean look at her ISO. nearly every post has been some form of beetlejuice. Her last post here was on Friday - over 4 days ago - and was in reaction to my vote. Since then, no comments about her except me over here in the corner grumbling.

I looked over her iso. Standouts would be Looking at abomination wagon for scum (Xofelf, shos, Beast), shakedown of shos over his claim wording, townread on Lemin, post @ Lemin (2890), human claim.

Really dislikes wagons on her. Responded to Lemin vote and your vote, but no others. And not much in the way of responses in general, except when arguing shos scumrole/scumslip.

Might consider voting her, but if she was some sort of counterwagon to Lemin yesterday, also want to look into that.

[Birds of Prey]

Those are valid points.

However, could you please draw the link between your 3 points -> YnB is scum? You have yet to show this despite your well-written analysis and case.

If the conclusions of your case are: "You are X, Y, and Z, but you are not scum," then there is no need for all the tension; in fact you have just lured a pack of hungry scum for a mislynch on poor YnB. Aren't my kisses enough?

- b -

The first point-
This is a tell that I have used without fail in three other games. Two of which you know of. I trust it. It works.
The second point- only solidifying under pressure, as Mhork is saying, is scummy. Once the pressure starts to alleviate you go back to fluff-posting, which, seeing as it is the third point, isn't something town players do. Having 91 posts of near nothing is bad. And this bad means scummy bad.

I concede defeat. Our play hasn't exactly been stellar, and your case is very valid and sound. I know that it leads to the wrong answer, thus there is definitely a flaw in there that results in a contradiction, but I am unable to find it using logical reasoning as you have provided.

It's like a complicated math problem; the working and methodology is seemingly correct, but for some reason you arrive at the wrong answer. It may take a good eye to spot the possible (careless) mistake, but I can't.

I'm

Jinenji, Town Demon Friendly Neighbor

. Some flavor about being a gentle giant being afraid of humans or something. And I help Kagome collect herbs or something.

I am a Demon. I can visit a player every night, and they will receive a message confirming me as Town the next day.

This explains my "uselessness" et al. We were trying to have fun, and also our plan was to coast using our ability, since it would give us a whole lot of breathing room. Unfortunately, we got run up today, and might be a potential nightkill target now. Didn't expect that.


Oh and sorry Y if I'm claiming prematurely. We're L-4 and a ton of scum is on our wagon.

- b -

La libra de scrap. (álbum de recortes)

Has the person visited night1 confirmed this yet?

~P