Newbie 1517: Crossroads Mafia (Game Over)

[Malakittens]

VOTE: Shadow

I'm up for a Shadow and/or N_M lynch today.

I haven't liked Shadow's recent posting more than N_M. I could see N_M taking adv of his town meta by fabricating it into his scum meta.

[Malakittens]

VOTE: Shadow

I'm up for a Shadow and/or N_M lynch today.

I haven't liked Shadow's recent posting more than N_M. I could see N_M taking adv of his town meta by fabricating it into his scum meta.

[Glass]

If only the "and" was an option.

[penguin_alien]

Vote Count 2.07:

With eight alive, it takes five to lynch!

Clusk92 (L-4): acryon
Billi bilaoi (L-4): Clusk92
Glass (L-5):
shaddowez (L-3): Not_Mafia, Malakittens
acryon (L-5):
Bins (L-5):
Not_Mafia (L-3): Glass, shaddowez
Malakittens (L-5):

Not voting: Bins, Billi bilaoi

V/LA:

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-08-09 20:56:55)

I'll update the OP tonight...

[Bins]

nvm i'm like half asleep so in the morning i go for serious


i'm not sure about n_m actually and i think his lynch wouldn't give as much info as the other people who have more suspicion on them atm. so yeah definitely thinking i'd prefer shaddow. i'll probably vote in the morning if i wake up and my mind hasn't changed.

[Billi bilaði]

Not_Mafia ignores my questions, and, to a large degree, the game, so...

VOTE: Not_Mafia

[Billi bilaði]

...

If nothing in your follow-up post contained any defense of Clusk, why did you take your vote off of him?

Because shadow has increased in scumminess quite substantially, and Clusk has actually gotten townier in my books since I voted him (Mala's post in particular affected that). The reason I haven't voted for Shadow yet is because I want to see Shadow's response to my post.

I think that N_M is not getting enough attention.

VOTE: N_M

All is welcome on the N_M wagon.

What happened to the shaddowez suspicion?

[Not_Mafia]

What do you want me to answer?

[acryon]

...

If nothing in your follow-up post contained any defense of Clusk, why did you take your vote off of him?

Because shadow has increased in scumminess quite substantially, and Clusk has actually gotten townier in my books since I voted him (Mala's post in particular affected that). The reason I haven't voted for Shadow yet is because I want to see Shadow's response to my post.

I think that N_M is not getting enough attention.

VOTE: N_M

All is welcome on the N_M wagon.

What happened to the shaddowez suspicion?

Yeah, I'm a little wary about putting N_M to L-1 before this gets sorted out. I ISO'd you Glass, and there doesn't seem to be much indication that you thought N_M was scum outside of the post were you actually voted him. We know you think Shadowz is more scummy than N_M, but why do you feel N_M is scum?

[Glass]

What happened to the shaddowez suspicion?

Right now I am willing to lynch N_M or shadow, would prefer shadow (yes, I am aware that I am right now voting N_M).

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I ISO'd you Glass, and there doesn't seem to be much indication that you thought N_M was scum outside of the post were you actually voted him. We know you think Shadowz is more scummy than N_M, but why do you feel N_M is scum?

You are somewhat correct that I didn't express explicit concern over N_M, but I did say the following:

Given how my reads on the active players are mostly town, I think it is very likely we have some lurkscum in our midst.

The lurkers being N_M, Shadow, and Clusk. So you can say that my willing to lynch N_M is somewhat PoE and me being okay with a lurker lynch in this situation.

[Billi bilaði]

What do you want me to answer?

The questions I directed at you.

[Billi bilaði]

...
The lurkers being N_M, Shadow, and Clusk. So you can say that my willing to lynch N_M is somewhat PoE and me being okay with a lurker lynch in this situation.

acryon might be considered with the lurkers.

[Not_Mafia]

Which are?

[Billi bilaði]

I'm not going to read the game for you.

[Glass]

This back and forth

[Not_Mafia]

...Fri Aug 01, 2014 12:55 pm...

...Sun Aug 03, 2014 8:32 pm...

...Tue Aug 05, 2014 6:18 pm...

Are you just posting to be within the timelimits of a prod?
Happily waiting for a scurry-lynch?

If you mean these. These look rhetorical and I don't see what kind of response you'd expect.

Yes I should be more active but I haven't had anything to say
Yes

[acryon]

...
The lurkers being N_M, Shadow, and Clusk. So you can say that my willing to lynch N_M is somewhat PoE and me being okay with a lurker lynch in this situation.

acryon might be considered with the lurkers.

This is fair. I am mostly only available to post during the day on weekdays, so I have unfortunately been absent from some of the bigger discussions.

[acryon]

...Fri Aug 01, 2014 12:55 pm...

...Sun Aug 03, 2014 8:32 pm...

...Tue Aug 05, 2014 6:18 pm...

Are you just posting to be within the timelimits of a prod?
Happily waiting for a scurry-lynch?

If you mean these. These look rhetorical and I don't see what kind of response you'd expect.

Yes I should be more active but I haven't had anything to say

Yes

While I agree with your reasoning for not answering those questions, I don't like the bold.

I liked your response Glass, so there's not much holding me back at this point.
VOTE: Not_Mafia

[Glass]

VOTE: Shadow

Shadow, N_M are L-2.

[Clusk92]

If it's just between these two wagons for the lynch today I'd prefer a Shaddow lynch.

Don't want both being put at L-1 though, two claims would be bad, so I may hold off for now

[Clusk92]

Now he's backed out so suddenly of scumreading Shaddow because of a silly reason (imo) suggests the possibility of a Billi and Shaddow scumteam and he may have felt his bussing of Shaddow went too far and backed out.

Considering I've had my vote on Billi for a good portion of the day (and part of D1), wouldn't it be dumb for us to be bussing each other if we were both scum?

WIFOM argument is bad, very bad.

Also that's why he might have backed out - he realised it's too risky

[Billi bilaði]

Not_Mafia (when RachMarie) has already claimed VT.

[Glass]

Shadow, N_M are L-2.

[Clusk92]

Not_Mafia (when RachMarie) has already claimed VT.

Oh yeah, forgot about that

[Clusk92]

Fuck it

VOTE: Shaddow