Mini 1597: Runecast Mafia - Day 5

[HighShroomish]

Wow I just realized I missed like four of gp's posts. Never mind. Carry on B_E.

[Burning_Earth]

Godfather?

[HighShroomish]

What.

[Burning_Earth]

Oh sorry I thought I was quoting GP

[LynxKuroneko]

@ gameplay506: Wait, who was doing this?

Also, funny how a player with scum vibes (at least to me) is still defending the current suspect, after not providing anything else to the game. (Typed this out before this. We'll see what happens.)

Of course Burning_Earth's vote is awful... Wait, weren't you practically begging for votes? You got your votes, and couldn't even do a proper claim like you so desperately wanted.

If gameplay506 is town; assuming his next two votes are scum.
If gameplay506 is scum; assuming his next two votes are town.

[HighShroomish]

If gameplay506 is town; assuming his next two votes are scum.
If gameplay506 is scum; assuming his next two votes are town.

Why is this?

[Konowa]

If gameplay506 is town; assuming his next two votes are scum.If gameplay506 is scum; assuming his next two votes are town.

This is shit.

[LynxKuroneko]

Because scum wants town dead and town wants scum dead?

Gameplay506 I believe has 5 votes now, with 2 to lynch.

Scum won't lynch each other...

Wait, are we playing the same game?

Screw it. If you're town and reading the same things as the rest of us are, you wouldn't try to protect gameplay506 so much.

"Also, funny how a player with scum vibes (at least to me) is still defending the current suspect, after not providing anything else to the game." (Notice I'm omitting my following statement, as you have ignored it).

[LynxKuroneko]

And this is my observation. Thank you.

[HighShroomish]

(I ignored the rest of the post because I see no reason to comment on it.)

[Konowa]

But yeah gonna let out the first piece of my awesome claim - I am something like a bulletproof. Maybe weaker, maybe stronger. Not gonna full claim tho.

If gameplay506 really is town, gameplay506 is doing an awful job of it.

[HighShroomish]

@Lynx I would think I'm not thinking the same thing as you all are. Just seems like it, seeing as how, well, I'm doing stuff that you wouldn't do...

[Konowa]

Konowa understand that it is an observation, LynxKuroneko. Konowa is letting LynxKuroneko that it is a shitty observation. There is no precursor to say that statement definitively. Assuming such will just lead LynxKuroneko down false negatives, so on and so forth.

Scum won't lynch each other...

And this is where LynxKuroneko is wrong, bussing happens. What town has to do is determine motivation/intent/all that jazz.

[fferyllt]

VC 1.6

Then sought the gods
their assembly-seats,
The holy ones,
and council held;
Names then gave they
to noon and twilight,
Morning they named
and the waning moon,
Night and evening,
the years to number.

gameplay506

(5): Konowa, d3x, LynxKuroneko, Osseus pseudotripodis, Burning_Earth

LynxKuroneko

(3): HighShroomish, gameplay506, Kthxbye

Ansuz

(1): geraintm

geraintm

(1): Ansuz

TunnelMates

(1): Mantisdreamz

Osseus pseudotripodis

(1): hiplop

Not Voting

(1): TunnelMates

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: August 20, Midnight US Eastern Time

Countdown: (expired on 2014-08-19 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[HighShroomish]

Wait why am I voting No Lynch I don't remember that happening.

@Mod wat I didn't think I was voting for a no lynch

[LynxKuroneko]

@ HighShroomish - Like jumping on a wagon because "everything has been said", then actively defending this particular person under fire when you didn't bother defending any others? Literally the two things you've done this whole time. You're right. Town players don't suddenly hop on a hopeful wagon, then defend one particular person under fire when they're being lead to the guillotine.

@ Konowa - Sure, bussing happens. But I doubt scum would risk losing one of their few members on day 1.

[fferyllt]

Wait why am I voting No Lynch I don't remember that happening.

@Mod wat I didn't think I was voting for a no lynch

I think that might be a bug in the new votecount code. Fixed

/

[Konowa]

Which is why Konowa said that LynxKuroneko needs to take intent and motivation into account when analyzing. There is no set science saying that a scum lynch D1 will be devoid of scum on the wagon or that that a town lynch on D1 will absolutely have scum on the wagon. Or even at this point the final two votes will be based on the flip of the lynch. Making assumptions like that will just lead LynxKuroneko down a bottle of cheap wine pressed by some backwater redneck where the ration of footfungus to grapes is so astronomical it makes Konowa puke just thinking about it.

[Konowa]

Anyways, Konowa would still like gameplay506 to answer post #270. Ignoring that and the shitty half claim does not do anything for Konowa.

[LynxKuroneko]

I understand completely, Konowa. I've been monitoring behaviors and interactions, like HighShroomish hopping on the wagon gameplay506 started against me, and then defending gameplay506 since his wagon's been growing.

So in my mind (much like a town mind, who knows not who to trust until cold hard facts / events take place), if gameplay506 comes up scum, HighShroomish will end up with a red light above his head.

Is there some other kind of logic I should be using?

[HighShroomish]

@ HighShroomish - Like jumping on a wagon because "everything has been said", then actively defending this particular person under fire when you didn't bother defending any others? Literally the two things you've done this whole time. You're right. Town players don't suddenly hop on a hopeful wagon, then defend one particular person under fire when they're being lead to the guillotine.

Hi. I'm HighShroomish. Nice to meet you. I just got a new computer. I'm a shitty D1 player. I've been asking questions as to why gp was being scum read because I wanted to know. I'm sorry if that's what defending is, I will try not to want to understand next time.

[LynxKuroneko]

Hey there. Glad to meet ya. Now why didn't you inquire about anyone else who was suspected like myself?

I mean, you voted for me without hesitation, didn't you? You didn't bother to ask questions. d3x's main suspect was gameplay506, but you went for me instead. Why is that? Oh, right... I already answered that.

[LynxKuroneko]

[HighShroomish]

I just got a new computer

and I agreed with reasons stated. I'm not going to post the exact same thing so people have to read the same thing twice.

[Konowa]

What is HighShroomish's read on gameplay506?