Salamence 1478 wrote:2. Vi, why did you damn NS like that while blocked? For all the shit you gave me in the dead thread, ID LOVE to hear the reasoning for guiltying someone who was most likely obvtown WHEN YOU HAD AN UNCONFIRMED SANITY.
I'm impressed that you claim to have read the dead thread and yet didn't catch the memo that I was not in any way intending to indicate that I had results on my scumpartners, as evidenced by me justifying my reads by my Neighborhood. If I wanted you to know that I had mod confirmation, I would have said so. More's the point, I believe I and a few other people have made it clear that investigating Neighbors is a last resort - I really did have a 100% success rate at reading Neighbors up until now
without
the aid of other power roles. I'm not blaming you for not realizing this because it would have required you to know that I'm the single biggest proponent of Neighborizer as a nontrivial power role on this site. Third, there was a Townie in this game who was around during Day 3 who knew that I could not possibly have had two Cop results by that time (and SPOILERS, it was
you
). Had you called me on it I would have readily confirmed that I had no mod-given information about what I had said (while engaging in futility with trying to keep my Cop role secret).
In other words kindly don't be a dumbass.
----
Natirasha 1442 wrote:I mean I have a rule and that's 'always treat your neighbor as confirmed town in the absence of setup information', so I would still defend my play.
This, much like "always claim Serial Killer in your first post", is a bad rule; and treating your Neighbor like a Mason even more obviously a bad rule than that; and refusing to acknowledge that it's a bad rule makes you a bad player.
-----
At first I was going to say that the better team won even though the scum essentially did nothing (I need two hands to count the egregious, nontrivial, and obvious misplays Town made) but then I found out who the scum were in this game. This was a startlingly strong performance from the scum team. Salute!
-----
Thanks for modding, FakeGod! I know what it's like to put your soul into a game and have people kick you in the chest for it.
Though in my case the chest-kicking didn't entirely stop postgame.
Everything you say and do matters. People will respond in ways you may never see. May those responses be what you intend.