Mini Normal 1609: The Case Of Doctor Pepper (Game Over)

[Anatole Kuragin]

But seriously, grey ice, did you even spend two minutes looking at that game? Hito was scum and was in the neighborhood either from the beginning or from night 1 which is obvious just by looking at the neighborhood QT.

[TellTaleHeart]

So, TTH, you picked Wake instead of anybody else, because you were lurking games that he was in prior to joining? Of all the players in this game, is he the only one you directly observed?

My brother introduced me to this site after I played a game of mafia in RL; he's an older user (Antihero). The first thing I did here was go through and selectively read or skim (mostly skim) some of

his

old games to get at least a little bit of an idea about how forum mafia was played. The ones of Wake's I linked were two of them. The only other player I directly observed was GreyICE. I skimmed a Star Wars theme game and another large game, Knight Errant.

[Anatole Kuragin]

Awesome - from the little experience I've had with Antihero, he seems like a great player and a cool dude.

[Doogal121]

@TTH; Thank you, you answers make sense.

@BBT, I await your answers.

[scrambles]

Being able to quote the QT seems really odd.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

@doogal - what question have you asked me?

@scrambles - great contribution so far. Have a vote

VOTE: Scrambles

[Doogal121]

I'm not willing to walk away from this whole BBT-TTH thing yet...

BBT, when you quoted, you said the thread was locked. Why? Do you only have night chat or something?
TTH: Why, of all players, did you pick Wake as the first one to isolate in discussion?

Everybody who has actually rolled Mafia before: Does Mafia typically have day chat or night chat only? I always assumed they had day chat.

BBT: Did you actually look into the Greyice Anatole LaL claim, or did you just vote it assuming that Greyice was being truthful? If you took him at his word, why didn't you look further?

Here is another question:
BBT, do you just look at the last post and throw a vote down or do you read the thread?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

My bad.

I'm not willing to walk away from this whole BBT-TTH thing yet...

BBT, when you quoted, you said the thread was locked. Why? Do you only have night chat or something

Not relevant.

BBT: Did you actually look into the Greyice Anatole LaL claim, or did you just vote it assuming that Greyice was being truthful? If you took him at his word, why didn't you look further?

Nah, I just believed it. I didn't look further, well because, I believed it.

Here is another question:
BBT, do you just look at the last post and throw a vote down or do you read the thread?

Have you ISO'd Scrambles? Do you disagree with my previous statement?

[Anatole Kuragin]

How is scrambles any more suspicious than flubber, csareo, rufflig, etc. if your only basis is they haven't said much?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I can't vote all four of them can I?

I chose the latest to actively lurk. That happened to be Scrambles. Like, he is posting, but may as well not be posting because he hasn't said anything.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

After reviewing;

Csareo's posting hasn't been too bad.

I could happily vote Rufflig or Flubber. Flubber was completely off my radar. He looks just as bad as Scrambles. Would happily lynch either of them right now.

[Anatole Kuragin]

Do you think not posting much makes them scummy?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

If they're actively lurking, yeah, it makes them scummy.

[Anatole Kuragin]

I find that to be a really lazy and counter-productive way of looking for scum, particularly for someone purporting to be looking for scum by analyzing productivity.

[Doogal121]

Thanks.

I'm Ok with leaving my vote on you BBT.

If you are just going to randomly sheep instead of engage and pressure, you are not helping the town and most likely scum.

For the record, the whole Greyice thing is sitting in my craw really bad as well and I'd be willing to switch my vote if needed.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

So, if Scrambles and Flubber continued to contribute in the way they are, you're happy with that? We just continue ignoring them?

[Anatole Kuragin]

So, if Scrambles and Flubber continued to contribute in the way they are, you're happy with that? We just continue ignoring them?

They'll either replace out or start playing, likely. Townies lurk/are lazy/get disinterested in games. It's a total crapshoot to just start chainsawing through lurkers and is just going to waste days.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

AK - You're seriously telling me you're OK with Scrambles 154 given everything that's going on in this thread? He completely abstained from commenting on anything of note.

[Anatole Kuragin]

I'm telling you there is no indication he is scum in that post given everything that's going on in this thread.

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: GreyIce For using lynch all liars as a scum read like a lawyer from hell.

Maybe if I skim the wiki I'll get it but right now I don't understand the idea behind lynching between neighbors aside from the AK site meta, which I see as heavily contested right now.

[Boonskiies]

vote flubbernugget

He confessed he was scum in another game in a different thread.

vote flubbernugget

He confessed he was scum in another game in a different thread.

Wouldn't that be discussing ongoing games, ergo modkill?

Flubbernugget appears to be alive in approximately 8 games, atm. I don't think anyone would be surprised if he was scum in at least one of them. Now, let's just drop this toxic topic.

Good respond. Town points for you

I semi agree with BBT on this one. I have had a slight scum read on scrambles due to the timing of his posts, along with his lack of posting yet obviously keeping up on the thread. That being said....

@SCRAMBLES

- Who are your top scum reads? What do you think of GreyIce and his case on Anatole about Lynching all Liars? Also, what's your read on the neighbor situation?

[massive]

Flubber

: Do you think there are circumstances where a townie should lie? If so, can you give some examples?

Wake88

: What is your experience with alt accounts? Also, if TTH is scum, who is her partner that has played with you before?

Dougal

: Do you have any scum reads?

[Wake1]

Wake88

: What is your experience with alt accounts? Also, if TTH is scum, who is her partner that has played with you before?

I have quite a few, and have seen players alt-slip. It wouldn't be surprising if most members on this site had at least one legitimate alternate. As for the second question, I'm not sure. It's definitely a Scumslip in my opinion, but she's asking the other player if he/she has played with me before, while asking how to go about tackling a read like that. TTH's #3 is completely disjointed and looks like it was meant for the Mafia QT, because BBT never asked or said anything about other players in the game. BBT asks how to start the Day, and TTH immediately starts talking about a player, as if they had been in that conversation... when they weren't.

[Anatole Kuragin]

You can't seriously believe that is "definitely a scumslip"

[Wake1]

I do. I've played enough games over the years to know when something isn't quite adding up. Should TTH flip Scum, I would certainly suspect you of being her Scum partner because of your role in trying to get everyone else to stop digging at the discrepancy.