Robin Williams Mafia - rememberance - game over

[dybeck]

Well the point was the exact opposite of what it achieved... To get everyone back on track to find scum and start talking about Reinoe's silliness.

I mean

stop

talking about it not

start

obviously.

[Baezu]

I'm more and more thinking Dybeck is town.

Why is dybeck town? You say "more and more". What has dybeck being doing that has been convincing you that he's town?

Man I hate this post from plagiarist. It just sounds wrong

[Titus]

I like it. Why do you hate it?

[farside22]

Vote count

:

Reinoe (0)
adelina (0)
peregrinev (0)
baezu (1) Obscurity
burn_209 (0)
Obscurity (0)
dybeck (4) alelina, not the mafia, Reinoe, Brandi
cloud nine (0)
POWERFUL TOWNIE (1) peregrine
Domo (1) plagiarist
Evil Regals (0)
Brandi (0)
ELMO TEH AZN (1) evil regals
Not the mafia (3) dybeck , elmo, Titus
Titus (0)
The Plagiarist (2) powerful townie, Domo

Not voting:
Cloud nine, burn_209, baezu

With 16 alive it will take 9 to lynch
Deadline:
(expired on 2014-09-20 07:30:00)

Prodding: not mafia, plagiarist and cloud nine.

[The Plagiarist]

I'm more and more thinking Dybeck is town.

Why is dybeck town? You say "more and more". What has dybeck being doing that has been convincing you that he's town?

Man I hate this post from plagiarist. It just sounds wrong

I get the feeling he's misguided town, not scum.

How about the questions that were actually directed at you?

Ask me the questions, Bridgekeeper.

[Baezu]

I like it. Why do you hate it?

I just don't like how he said, I'm more and more thinking. It sounds scummy but I'm probably just paranoid lol

[dybeck]

We have 4 days to make a decision. NtM has carefully gone silent, except for his one prod-dodger post to re-ignite the wagon on me. Clearly I have a vested interest because the world's favourite alternative lynch seems to be me, but we really shouldn't let him lurk his way to safety.

[Not the mafia]

Quoting NtM's post is a really bad reason to vote me. It accuses me of being scum for speculating and probing. That's what everyone should be doing. I'd love to see more of that. I will carry on being suspicious of everyone because THAT'S THE GAME OF MAFIA!

Excessive inquiry is not what helps scum. Apathy is what helps scum.

I agree that it should be important to interrogate other players. The point was that your reasons for suspecting me are terrible. It seems like a leap to say that I'm scum, just based on the reasons you gave. If you could back up your claims rather than spout out conspiracy theories, that'd be great.

[dybeck]

Four minutes forty-two seconds must be a new record for suddenly appearing after being called out as lurking scum.

[PeregrineV]

unvote

for now. After reading NTM's recent posts I don't really feel like he's scum.

Dybeck's posts aren't great.

I want to note that Reinoe never initially claimed to have a post restriction, and his response to the complaints feel as though he genuinely has one. He said something to the effect of "I'm only going to say this once, you don't have to read it that's why it's in spoilers,"

We don't need to be all "the boy who cried wolf", why even focus on something like a fake post restriction when in the past it was from a town player?

It seems like a pointless distraction for the town.

vote: dybeck

@Evil: Why assume someone pointing out inactivity levels is scummy? He wasn't even claiming to cast suspicion on those who haven't posted in several days.

The above probably reads weird but I was typing my thoughts as I caught up.

It looks like you are calling out Reinoe for "pointless distraction for the town." and then voting dybeck for ???

Is ???= biggest current wagon or pointing out the "pointless distraction for town"?

I wasn't calling out Reinoe for anything. I'm saying Dybeck's posts were the pointless distractions. With his "let me make this clear" post. It was a pointless post that he tried to make seem important.

I generally find posts that attempt to clear things up useful, since they are trying to create mutual understanding through the clarification.

[PeregrineV]

PeregrineV, if you were to vote based on the amount of information that you have so far on this game, who would you vote? How much had you read when you answered this question?

Which question?

Right now, I really forgot, but I may or may not accept your Not-the-mafia reaction explanation for now. Otherwise, I would be OK with his lynch. (assuming nothing else changes by the time I finish reading).
Baezu is more suspect than normal, as is powerful townie. Trying to decide if reinoe is scum or not, I like dybeck for town.

[PeregrineV]

Quoting NtM's post is a really bad reason to vote me. It accuses me of being scum for speculating and probing. That's what everyone should be doing. I'd love to see more of that. I will carry on being suspicious of everyone because THAT'S THE GAME OF MAFIA!

Excessive inquiry is not what helps scum. Apathy is what helps scum.

I agree that it should be important to interrogate other players. The point was that your reasons for suspecting me are terrible. It seems like a leap to say that I'm scum, just based on the reasons you gave. If you could back up your claims rather than spout out conspiracy theories, that'd be great.

Perhaps you could vote one of your non-dybeck suspects? And explain why. That would help move you from awkward noob scum to maybe awkward newb town.

[PeregrineV]

Vote: Baezu

[Not the mafia]

I'm reading and responding by mobile. I hadn't been called out for lurking by the time I started replying. You still haven't explained to me your thought process in making me out to be scum by the way.

[PeregrineV]

I'm reading and responding by mobile. I hadn't been called out for lurking by the time I started replying. You still haven't explained to me your thought process in making me out to be scum by the way.

I think your 116 and 124 really suck, and do not come across as town at all. I'm conidering Obscurity's explanation, but that would only give you a null leaning scum, since your not actively scumhunting. And you apparently are accusing dybeck of being scum FOR scumhunting (224).

Perhaps you could vote one of your non-dybeck suspects? And explain why. That would help move you from awkward noob scum to maybe awkward newb town.

[dybeck]

I'm reading and responding by mobile. I hadn't been called out for lurking by the time I started replying. You still haven't explained to me your thought process in making me out to be scum by the way.

The motivation of scum is just to stay alive - the nightkills will take care of the rest, because you already knows who is scum. If you were town, I would expect to see a lot more evidence of looking around to see who might be scum rather than just defensiveness.

There is something in your posts that seem notably self-centric. Even your incessant attacks on me give me a feeling of an effort to discredit the accusations against you by seeking to undermine the town-credentials of the person making them.

Your horrible appeal to emotion in the middle of the day is a symptom of the same disease - self-preservation over active scumhunting.

Add to this the fact that you went so noticeably into lurk mode the moment you came under suspicion from a number of people, and then immediately popped back to life when you realised someone had noticed what you were up to - has all the hallmarks of someone whose only motivation is to stay alive, not to seek ways to secure a town win.

The interesting thing about going for my lynch rather than trying to establish your own town-credentials is that it's a horrible strategy. If the only town-credentials you've established are that I might be scum, because even if you get me lynched, I'll flip, and everything your case was built on will evaporate.

@Titus

- I would be really interested in hearing your reads on people.

[dybeck]

I

really

hope PV is town.

[PeregrineV]

I

really

hope PV is town.

Seems a silly hope, but I'll take it as a compliment.

[reinoe]

Spoiler: Dear Diary 9/15/2014 4:21pm

Dear Diary, I just got off work today. It was a really bad day: again. I got a coaching call because apparently I did not go over the specific co-payments required for one of our customers. She was taking a prescription that was not covered and instead of telling her that the prescription was not covered I simply told her that the "x plan is the plan that will best fit your health insurance needs because it has the lowest rate". Thanks to government regulations, each prescription call requires the representatives to go over a crapton of pointless information that doesn't matter and doesn't affect anything.

I didn't get written up or anything. That would have been just fucking terrible but it still sucks. I need some some boneless wings and icecream to make myself feel better.

[reinoe]

hmmm my scumreads keep making decent cases on each other.

[Baezu]

I

really

hope PV is town.

Ya. I can't tell yet whether or not he is :/

And I second your requests for a reads list from Titus.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

PV from what Ive seen seems town. Reinoe is also town.

[Evil Regals]

Also thinking wifey could be scum too.

WHY ARE THERE SO MANY SCUMMY PEOPLe

I"M ALSO STARTING TO HATE NTM MORE AND MORE

;;

[Evil Regals]

fuck it

VOTE: ntm

[Evil Regals]

why mods made vigs~