Mini 1597: Runecast Mafia - Day 5

[d3x]

@OP- Please answer my question from Yesterday.

@OP- Why do you think you're still alive?

Is it your contention that HS/Josh had not a single Vote on Town for the entire game? Also that AnsuzScum would be pushing a counterWagon on his PR Scum partner over his Vanilla Scum partner D2?

[Thor665]

I'm not following why ScumOP means there has to be multiple nonTown killing factions. The only Night with multiple deaths was the Night with multiple Vig shot Claims. That is aside from Last Night, where our Hider died behind his Target.

Are you even listening to yourself here?

[Thor665]

his CLAIMED target. we're town, so after we flip you need to reassess why he might have died. either he changed his mind or there's some night action Smurfery

I would be intrigued to hear any thoughts from you about what affected a hide action.

The only way you're not scum is if Kthx decided to play terribly.

[Konowa]

Konowa would only consider multiple killing factions if game continues after OPscum is lynched.

[Thor665]

That's a perfectly reasonable standpoint.
I'd still like to see Lynx state what he found by investigating me however. It would make my universe more complete.

[d3x]

@Thor- I'm trying to, man. I'm rather sick right now, but what you're saying isn't jiving with my brain. Why do you not believe that we have 2 1-Shot Vigs?

[d3x]

Lynx better not have Investigated you...

[Konowa]

Konowa thinks Konowa has kills figured out, but it's pretty wonky so no need to really share since OP is likely scum and game over.

[Konowa]

What Thor is trying to say is if there is two one-shot vigs, ger's shot is still missing from N2 and Ansuz claimed ger shot N2. So why is there two deaths N3? Which Konowa understands why Thor thinks third party.

[Konowa]

Konowa is going to be giddy if Konowa is right about the kills

[Osseus pseudotripodis]

The only way you're not scum is if Kthx decided to play terribly.

apparently he did. sorry.

again, you really have no reason to believe me until we flip, so I'd rather not continue this discussion since there really should be nothing I can do to convince you otherwise.

considering the facts laid out, this slot needs to die and as town I have no desire for the town to waste time discussing it. this needs to be done so you can stop analyzing the game through the OP-is-scum lens

[Osseus pseudotripodis]

Konowa thinks Konowa has kills figured out, but it's pretty wonky so no need to really share since OP is likely scum and game over.

lay it out. we're town, so get your idea out there in case scum wants to kill you tonight.

[Osseus pseudotripodis]

@OP- Please answer my question from Yesterday.

@OP- Why do you think you're still alive?

Is it your contention that HS/Josh had not a single Vote on Town for the entire game? Also that AnsuzScum would be pushing a counterWagon on his PR Scum partner over his Vanilla Scum partner D2?

my reads are my reads.

I have, as a goon, bussed PR scum. it's not out of the question to me.

[d3x]

N3's 2 deaths were a bodyguard and a Hider. There's only 1 kill.

The easiest explanation for N2 is a BP OPScum.

[d3x]

Or a selftargeting ScumDoc...

[Konowa]

N3's 2 deaths were a bodyguard and a Hider. There's only 1 kill.

The easiest explanation for N2 is a BP OPScum.

Actually, correct.

Theory out the window. What happens when you are sleep deprived.

[Konowa]

Whatever, "pronoun".

[Thor665]

Eh, I'm fine with Konowa playing that close to his chest - I have some theories as well, and since Konowa understands my question I suspect we'll do fine on the theory working if you are indeed town and the game doesn't end.

@Osseus - out of curiosity - where do you think Ger's shot went? Since you couldn't protect yourself, and you must not think scum protected you, so...?

@D3x - You think there are two 1-shot vigs? I wasn't even aware that was a consideration, honestly.

@Konowa - BP scum paired with Ascetic scum? You must be sleep deprived.

[Konowa]

Konowa was moreso quoting the first half of that quote.

Self targeting mafia doc seems right though.

Still sleep deprived.

Daughter back in school and working nights does not make a happy Konowa.

[d3x]

I'd have to dig for it, but I'm fairly certain I've been in a game with 2 1shot Vigs here before.

[Thor665]

I'd have to dig for it, but I'm fairly certain I've been in a game with 2 1shot Vigs here before.

So?
Unless you're claiming 1-shot Vig I don't see the point of even considering it.

[Thor665]

Self targeting mafia doc seems right though.

It would pair well with the role cop, agreed.

[d3x]

What am I missing here?

2 players Claimed 1shot Vig. 1 shot is unaccounted for. 1 player has Claimed Doc {and we're all pretty much in agreement that he's a self targeting Mafia Doc}. The missing Vig shot was supposed to be on the {Mafia}Doc.

I'd have to dig for it, but I'm fairly certain I've been in a game with 2 1shot Vigs here before.

So?
Unless you're claiming 1-shot Vig I don't see the point of even considering it.

Does this mean that you're fine with Ansuz being a 1shot Vig and you're off the 2nd nonTown killing faction theory?

[Thor665]

2 players Claimed 1shot Vig.

I do not believe this happened - who do you think claimed this?

[d3x]

I am a one shot vig (with a few extra caveats to it).

I shot geraintm last night.
I'm a one-shot vig, and I have no caveats whatsoever to my ability.
Discuss.