Open 570: Making Friends and Enemies (Mafia Wins!)

[Scripten]

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for policy lynching that dude


I saw newb town

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for lynching that dude


I saw newb town

^I agree.

Interesting. What makes your reads newb town and not newb scum?

NPAU:

Come on back to the party. We miss you and you should come contribute more.

Zebulin:

Keep your reads lists in the thread, please. It goes along with the whole not-editing-posts thing. Also goes along with not talking about the game outside of it. Just keep everything game related in this thread and you're good.

Btw, finished my ISO reads. Mostly the same as before. Notable changes: Mala and Shinobi look a little better upon closer examination. (Mala's (329) sets off a few red flags, but meh.)

[Josh_B]

I'm not sure if he's scum.

He's been saying weird shit thus far, but it's MS: that's just how he is. I don't feel like anything he has said thus far has been particularly alignment indicative.

Though I will admit that it's complete nonsense...

Shinobi

:

Seems towny. I really like post 75, and 19 posts is pretty active. He

doesn't seem to care for Metal Sonic very much

, but isn't calling anyone out particularly. He is trying to get the game moving, which is nice.

I'm don't see what makes him think that Shinobi doesn't like Metalsonic. Or maybe I'm thinking too narrow mindedly about Zebulin's post.
Shinobi doesn't like MetalSonic "in this game" (my understanding)
Shinobi doesn't like MetalSonic "at all" (possible meaning)
but still not sure why Zebulin thinks that.

On another note. I like zebulin's recent explanation. Can we vote Peabody now?

VOTE: peabody

[Metal Sonic]

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for policy lynching that dude


I saw newb town

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for lynching that dude


I saw newb town

^I agree.

Interesting. What makes your reads newb town and not newb scum?

NPAU:

Come on back to the party. We miss you and you should come contribute more.

Zebulin:

Keep your reads lists in the thread, please. It goes along with the whole not-editing-posts thing. Also goes along with not talking about the game outside of it. Just keep everything game related in this thread and you're good.

Btw, finished my ISO reads. Mostly the same as before. Notable changes: Mala and Shinobi look a little better upon closer examination. (Mala's (329) sets off a few red flags, but meh.)

Newb scums are obvious scums

Newb towns are vi

[Scripten]

On another note. I like zebulin's recent explanation. Can we vote Peabody now?

VOTE: peabody

I wouldn't mind a Peabody lynch. He's a little scummy, but right now I'd like to see a good NPAU wagon. His votes are all over the place, he's misrepping BBT something -hard- in (320). Also, (224) is terrible, but this takes the cake:

Define soft defend. Why would scum more likely to soft defend each other and not just outright defend or outright distance each other?

Might do a short meta checkup, but that's ringing scum to me.

VOTE: nopointinactingup

Newb scums are obvious scums

Newb towns are vi

Alright. That's a fair enough point for the moment. Why are you pushing a lynch on goodmorning again? What makes a scum GM opposed to a town GM to you? Gimme something good.

[goodmorning]

Newb scums are obvious scums

Newb towns are vi

I don't think I agree with this.

For me it's mostly a tone thing - his general posting is pretty null.

Gimme something good.

He doesn't have anything good.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

@ BBT:

Re: 350. So what you're saying is that if A votes B and then B later votes A then it's a scum tell? Because it really isn't, unless B is saying A is scum purely because he voted B

Do you see any other reasons for MS' votes? If so, please show me.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Also Mala, can you stop fucking dodging my question to you in 183. This is the 3rd time I'm having to ask you.

[Malakittens]

Also Mala, can you stop fucking dodging my question to you in 183. This is the 3rd time I'm having to ask you.

Mixture of gut and meta really. GM and I have experience in playing together. I used to have a tell that I figured out on her while we were scum partners a long time ago, but since then that tell I think has been outted or at least less noticeable to spot in her scum play. I normally read town-GM by gut depending on how she reacts in certain situations, but I'm not really getting a town read nor a scum read. It's just that simple.

You and I also have experience together so I know that this answer won't sit well with you. Which is a reason why I dodged it because whichever way I answer with you is a double-edged sword.

(Also I will say that my post today was

kinda

a prod dodge as I was at a reunion earlier and I close on Sunday for work).

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Here you go;

Yeah ms has been pinging for a while.

And what have you done to develop this read? Other than telling MS to stop doing the things you're finding scummy.

Now, try again.

[Josh_B]

Which lead me to believe a 'sheep me-BBT' is not entirely truthful in his convictions.

He never is. Lucky for you that you are finding this out now as opposed to later. I think I speak for all of us that know BBT, your case is weak. Is there anything else that you want to add?

[Metal Sonic]

Alright. That's a fair enough point for the moment. Why are you pushing a lynch on goodmorning again? What makes a scum GM opposed to a town GM to you? Gimme something good.

"I dont have meta on goodmorning. But she's checking lots of stuff on my scum-catcher-checklist. You shall take it for a fact that my scum-catcher-checklist is infallible.

Of course, she is a good player, after I have caught her she has been more careful and has ceased to drop any more scumtells.

If this is going to be like pulling teeth, then we will just let the masons (attempt to) recruit her tonight and be done with it.

[Metal Sonic]

Uncle Sonic's Scumhunting List!

~Uncle Sonic~

Metal Sonic

Good!

Josh_B
BlueBloodedToffee
Zebulin
Malakittens
Shinobi

Maybe good?

Huntress
Peabody
Scripten
nopointactingup

No Read

Ucitron
hephaestus

No Good!

goodmorning

[Metal Sonic]

BlueBloodedToffee,

Who do you think is the towniest at the moment? Help me fix my read list. ^

Maybe there is a townread that needs to sit up there, but is in my No Read or Maybe Town section.

[Metal Sonic]

Oh, and as a side note:

This is not related to mafia in any way

Just a request,

Scripten, can you please change your avatar? Thanks.

[Scripten]

Scripten, can you please change your avatar? Thanks.

I suppose I could. What needs changed about it?

[Malakittens]

Here you go;

Yeah ms has been pinging for a while.

And what have you done to develop this read? Other than telling MS to stop doing the things you're finding scummy.

Now, try again.

I really don't know know to read sonic. Majority of games sonic and I; I have been scum besides one where I I gored him throughout the game.

Also I wasn't telling him omg stop being scummy I was telling him to knock off things that were irritating. There's a diff

[Malakittens]

Also I don't know why I thought you asked me about GM

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I really don't know know to read sonic. Majority of games sonic and I; I have been scum besides one where I I gored him throughout the game.

Also I wasn't telling him omg stop being scummy I was telling him to knock off things that were irritating. There's a diff

You must have an inkling on how to read him given you stated he had been 'pinging for a while'.

I'll ask again, why have you done nothing to try and develop this read? What was making him ping? My point is further emphasized if you don't know how to read him. This makes me think you should be making an

extra

effort to try and gain a read on him.

[Malakittens]

sigh.

Because of me only playing scum games with him I don't know how to interact with him. I don't. I couldn't read him in xmen and I was town. I just don't know how to go about it with sonic. Yes it's dumb, but after playing a certain alignment so long and finally starting to play with him as a diff role I just don't what to do.

What I have noticed is he tends to have a similar playsytle as myself.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You said he was pinging.

What was making him ping?

[Malakittens]

He was annoying me with all the mason and VT bullshit. I think I made myself clear on that one.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Annoying you makes him scum?

[Malakittens]

Annoying you makes him scum?

For him it might. When I was scum partners with him he walked the thin line of my patience. I ended up blowing up his hydra partner in thread with my engaging which then got me frustrated. So yes him being annoying could potentially be a scum tell for him. I don't know for sure.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I think you thought his wagon may pick up and you wanted to make sure you had an excuse to jump on.

I have gave you numerous chances to give me a good answer and every one of your answers has been awful.

VOTE: Mala

[Malakittens]

Nope, but good try!

Well you were pretty much going to vote me anyways because you know none of my answers to your questions would be satisfactory to you because you disagree with what tools I hunt with so~