Advance Wars UPick!--Game Over..?

[orcinus_theoriginal]

unfortunately I don't like discussing my Cabd read in front of Cabd

[notscience]

fair enough

[orcinus_theoriginal]

I'm not sure if she pushes players she knows well when she's scum, though. The games I'm remembering, I'm pretty sure she was pushing players she thought would be relatively easy to mislynch.

the last time mara pushed me as hard as this she was scum in hard boiled, iirc

rereading through the games i've played with mara i am gradually confirming that i have aggression as a scumtell for mara

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Flubbernugget is a town-read because I haven't seen him be this aggressive nor this out-front as scum. His play is a bit erratic as either alignment imo, but he's not this open with his reads and opinions as scum in my experience.

i don't see open reads.

Varsoon gets town points for not replacing out yet.

VOTE: varsoon

literally successive posts

I'm not sure how I feel about orc's scumread yet.

VOTE: marangal

without explanation

I read up to the last post I made but its all a word jumble right now and idk how to approach trying to get into the game.

or are you referring purely to his interaction with the varsoon wagon in the later stage of day? idk i'm interested in sorting him, could you tell me more stuff about things ty

[fferyllt]

It's going to be a bear for me to get back into this game, I think. :/

Notsci do you have a Cabd read?

What do you think of orci's players of interest?

[notscience]

I think he's town but there's something that can likely change my stance on it but that something isn't all that likely so town

I thought Mara's reaction to cabd's first wall looked like she expected the reaction test and was trying to beat it if that makes sense

null on the other two

[notscience]

Bear with me on that one though

I know it's kinda vague but I'm kinda confident in it

But it's not related to his activity or anythng

[fferyllt]

I feel like my day 1 reads were to some extent coming from a naive, "I want everyone to be town" PoV. But, when I'm in that mode, my really strong town reads are usually town. I started the Serum and Steel game in that mode. Two of my 2nd tier town reads turned out to be scum.

I have one fear about Cabd and it's in a superstitious sort of "if you say it, it could become real" part of my mind. I'm going to hold it in check and see how things develop.

[wgeurts]

I'm rereading at the moment, screw you for lynching while I was gone.

[LynxKuroneko]

Still catching up (page 32), first large game and didn't realize 20 pages were possible almost overnight. I do have to say that THIS is not sitting well with me, especially on day 1. Trying to sway a doc's target in a game this large, where there are more than likely uncommon power roles, this early just doesn't sit well with me.

I also am getting the strange feeling that there are in fact 4-5 people playing this game. I hope that changes soon (again, just a page < 33 post). I also hoped Varsoon actually scumhunted or set up a better case against others instead of "I'm town, don't lynch me", which never really helps.

Will post again once I have fully caught up.

Also...

Spoiler: Note to Nintendo / Intelligent Systems

Where the hell is our 3DS AW game!? *insert various expletives and shameless begging spouts*

[Honey bee]

Not Voting(4):

wgeurts, LynxKuroneko, Flubbernugget, Cephrir, SavetheDragons, BipolarChemist, fferyllt, MafiaSSK, honey bee, Cabd, Ms Marangal, Albert B. Rampage, SMP, Brian Skies, grapes, Bookitty, orcinus_theoriginal, Saki, Konowa, notscience,

Neotank Mk2

With twenty-one alive, it takes eleven to lynch.

Whoever understands wtf that is needs to explain right now.

Also I'd like to talk to ceph when he comes online.

[Honey bee]

mara is by far my strongest scum-read so far
-don't see how anybody could've possibly seen that varsoon was town, much less declare him "literal god-town"
-as has been said in this thread, i think mara's tunnel on me leans scum because 1. it's based on nothing 2. level of conviction 3. i have a feeling this is her scum-meta but i definitely have to reread games because all of my meta is a year old

You said yesterday that you were convinced varsoon and mara were scum together, why does vars town flip convince you she's still scum? And you don't think she's convinced of a tell that she bothered to make an entire thread about?

[wgeurts]

Neotank Mark 2 is one of two possibilties:
1. Someones abiltity has given them an alt. meaning they have 2 votes.
2. It's a joke reference to AW.

The neotank was added to the game in Advanced Wars 2: Black Hole Rising, it wasn't well recieved as:
1. The other tanks were called tank, then medium so the neotank should of been a large tank according to some OCD's.
2. It was overpowered as hell, only artillery could stop it. It was also a very powerful snowball.
3. It looked like an egg with legs which ran on wheels. Google it.
Natirasha could be making a joke here if she's aware of AW discussion.

[wgeurts]

If it's an alt lash probaly has it as lash was the first to have the lab in AW2 that unlocks the neotank.

[wgeurts]

She's basically the black hole scientist and was very overpowered in varied terrain, she'll be a powerhouse one way or another.

[Honey bee]

I mean I knew what it is in the game I was just paranoid about unlisted players again lol. But I didn't see any account under that name and it doesn't appear to be votable so I'm just guessing its a secret double voter.

[fferyllt]

Let's see if it belongs to me then.

VOTE: Cabd

[Albert B. Rampage]

The case against Ms Marangal is wack. You seem to have taken everything out of context while thoroughly slipping your bias in.

Vote: grapes

[Bookitty]

@Ms. Marangal: How much of your suspicion of Orcinus is based on his role in the game?

[Albert B. Rampage]

@Ms. Marangal: How much of your suspicion of Orcinus is based on his role in the game?

I'm sort of suspicious of you. You always says the perfect thing that scum would say in every game, even if you're town.

[Bookitty]

How is asking that question scummy, ABR? I don't get your point there. Or is that not what you mean by saying the perfect thing that scum would say? If not, then please explain.

I was unconvinced by Ms. M's case on Orcinus. I don't agree with the "if you give a summary of the game on request you're scum" scumtell. Also, she was saying it was a 100 percent scumtell and then backed off that when others disagreed. So I want to know where her head is at.

[MafiaSSK]

unfortunately I don't like discussing my Cabd read in front of Cabd

Yeah, no. That's not how this game works, orci. You don't just get to opt out of reading a player because you don't like to publically state it.

[Albert B. Rampage]

I quoted you simply to direct my post to you, not to respond to what I quoted. You're just very, how to say it...consensus-building. You're agreeable, you're positive, you seem perfectly reasonable.

Contrast with say cabd, who makes polarizing posts. I could vote for cabd, but he makes good posts I think come from town sometimes. I'm not really sure. I want to hear more from fferyllt. A better example might be DGB or me, who easily turn people against us with our forcefulness and aggressiveness. Your type of aggression, and you are aggressive, somehow has the uncanny knack to make people take your side instead of suspect you, regardless of alignment.

I think this is how you carry your way to the endgame as scum. I know it's your playstyle, but it's hard to read and harder to bring any sort of bandwagon against you because everybody likes you.

I'll have to analyze what you say more extensively.

Fferyllt, do you think Cephrir and orc are 100% town?

[fferyllt]

I quoted you simply to direct my post to you, not to respond to what I quoted. You're just very, how to say it...consensus-building. You're agreeable, you're positive, you seem perfectly reasonable.

Contrast with say cabd, who makes polarizing posts. I could vote for cabd, but he makes good posts I think come from town sometimes. I'm not really sure. I want to hear more from fferyllt. A better example might be DGB or me, who easily turn people against us with our forcefulness and aggressiveness. Your type of aggression, and you are aggressive, somehow has the uncanny knack to make people take your side instead of suspect you, regardless of alignment.

I think this is how you carry your way to the endgame as scum. I know it's your playstyle, but it's hard to read and harder to bring any sort of bandwagon against you because everybody likes you.

I'll have to analyze what you say more extensively.

Fferyllt, do you think Cephrir and orc are 100% town?

About 95% on both. There's that persistent gnat-like paranoid flicker that I'll never completely shake.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Since they think you're town too, why aren't you voting as a block?