Mini 1625: Redemption (Game Over)

[droog]

even though my suspicions were entirely founded =p

[droog]

please tell me if this sounds dumb as shit

why are we lynching gdb?
he's a bigger threat to scum because he could kill any of them
whereas we can always lynch him

even if we cant control him
the threat he poses to any other faction is greater than the threat he poses to us

[droog]

please tell me if this sounds dumb as shit

why are we lynching gdb?
he's a bigger threat to scum because he could kill any of them
whereas we can always lynch him

even if we cant control him
the threat he poses to any other faction is greater than the threat he poses to us

[crazypianist1116]

Um, he has a kill. That's a much higher threat to town than to a potential unidentified faction. It's pretty straight forward.

Reading through d2 right now.

[GGG]

If DGB killed randomly it would be good for us to keep him alive as a random kill has a chance of hitting scum where as night kills kill only town. However DGB is probably more inclined to kill the people who caught him first.

If we lynch DGB today we have a 7-2 situation if DGB is being honest or an 8-1 with just one scum team. That result is pretty good after two days. And is far less risky than letting her live.

Lynching DGB is the correct play.

[crazypianist1116]

Why is everyone ruling out the 3 man werewolf team so readily? It's very possible DGB is lying about her team being just her and AWA.

[crazypianist1116]

Also lynching confscum is always the right choice.

[crazypianist1116]

Droog in particularly posts like he knows we're in multiball.

[crazypianist1116]

I think there's a good chance GGG is scum.

I want to hear more about this.

[Whomping Willow]

I think we should lynch AWA

[droog]

Why is everyone ruling out the 3 man werewolf team so readily? It's very possible DGB is lying about her team being just her and AWA.

Droog in particularly posts like he knows we're in multiball.

hang on
you cast doubt on my theory saying dgb could be lying
and then cast doubt on me, saying i know we're in multiball?

[TellTaleHeart]

I think there's a good chance GGG is scum.

I want to hear more about this.

My first instinct was that one of the people trying to split the vote from AWA to istott (i.e. Originalchris and GGG) were scum. The "congratulating" Naomi in post 1225 also felt off because both the sentences in the post seem stilted. A more exhaustive search of GGG's activity showed a fairly extensive history of criticism towards Riddleton's slot and AWA and that's why I called the read "premature" later.

droog, we have to flip DGB in order to secure the premises to build on. If she's actually mafia, any speculation done today would be built on bogus assumptions.

VOTE: DrippingGoofball

[droog]

i want to hear from delibird before we hammer

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't particularly want to keep on living just to provide the town with a NK that might hit mafia.

I've been caught, my team is done, this would be like torturing me.

But I will say this: the players that suggested that I be allowed to live to kill players at night are now 100% confirmed town. No mafia would make such a suggestion.

[DrippingGoofball]

please tell me if this sounds dumb as shit

why are we lynching gdb?
he's a bigger threat to scum because he could kill any of them
whereas we can always lynch him

even if we cant control him
the threat he poses to any other faction is greater than the threat he poses to us

There is no way that droog is in the mafia faction.

Which really sucks because I would have wished that the other faction would also have to deal with being in some shitty neighborhood.

While I'm at it I would like to petition for a ban on neighbors. I hate this role (especially as scum) with the heat of 10,000 volcanoes, and I suspect the two players that replaced out this player slot didn't relish the thought either.

[DrippingGoofball]

Droog in particularly posts like he knows we're in multiball.

You're pretending not to know.

Werewolves imply multiball.

[crazypianist1116]

Why is everyone ruling out the 3 man werewolf team so readily? It's very possible DGB is lying about her team being just her and AWA.

Droog in particularly posts like he knows we're in multiball.

hang on
you cast doubt on my theory saying dgb could be lying
and then cast doubt on me, saying i know we're in multiball?

I'm saying making affirmative statements about a specific scenario being true is scummy.

Droog in particularly posts like he knows we're in multiball.

You're pretending not to know.

Werewolves imply multiball.

Reasons you should already be lynched. Please continue trying to throw everyone off./s

[Whomping Willow]

@mod VC please

[GGG]

So DGBs insistence on multiball leads me to believe she is protecting her last person. Especially the last neighbours comment. Her push for multiball would make sense if there was an associative link between DGB / AWA and the last remaining scum. The biggest one would be istot / eyestott slot with the Riddleton/DGB fake dayvig.

[GGG]

I think there's a good chance GGG is scum.

I want to hear more about this.

My first instinct was that one of the people trying to split the vote from AWA to istott (i.e. Originalchris and GGG) were scum. The "congratulating" Naomi in post 1225 also felt off because both the sentences in the post seem stilted. A more exhaustive search of GGG's activity showed a fairly extensive history of criticism towards Riddleton's slot and AWA and that's why I called the read "premature" later.

droog, we have to flip DGB in order to secure the premises to build on. If she's actually mafia, any speculation done today would be built on bogus assumptions.

VOTE: DrippingGoofball

To clarify TTH I had town read AWA pretty hard after the big walls started showing up and droog was twisting things around. Then I quit reading the big walls and game back at the deadline to assure a lynch. I did like the DGB wagon yesterday and was pushing that pre deadline, pre-flip and pre-watcher reveal today.

Right now do you believe there are two factions or one faction?

[GGG]

Forgot about that. My thought was that either both scum groups killed the same person or the mafia kill failed somehow. Because the probability of the mafia kill failing is likely low, I figured they both killed the same person. :S

You forgot that the watcher would have seen the second killer if they both double killed tier? That doesn't seem likely.

[TellTaleHeart]

I forgot about the watcher results altogether. Something still feels missing though.

[TellTaleHeart]

Right now do you believe there are two factions or one faction?

If DGB flips werewolf, probably one. If mafia, then there's two.

[GGG]

I have no allies, I'm the last of my two-person faction.

Why are you still participating and throwing out reads

[crazypianist1116]

OC and CDB can you post reads so we can get on with our lynch for today?