Open 582: Stackin' the Deck/Hipster Mafia (Over)

[Alchemist21]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 0&start=25

[droog]

@droog: So wgeurts is town. Wherefore is Riddleton scum?

his case had more distortions than the 5th dimension

[Mathdino]

I sense we will be moving out from RVS soon. Time to check my weapons and ammo.

This isn't townposting.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Alchemist21

Why is it scumposting?

It reads like coaching to me.

The move from RVS should never be stated explicitly, because there's always a chance scum will miss it and do something stupid (and I believe that they are more likely to miss it because of their information). Posting out loud in thread that you think we're moving into "serious voting" reads to me like "Hey, buddy, I think the game's getting serious now, better knuckle down"

What do you think of Alchemist's meta?

[theslimer3]

Because it was posted on page 3.

You're based on page 3

[Albert B. Rampage]

Because it was posted on page 3.

You're based on page 3

What?

[Mathdino]

Because it was posted on page 3.

You're based on page 3

Thank you based slimer.

Any thoughts on the game?

[Alchemist21]

VOTE: Slimer

Looks like he's trying to fluff his way through.

[Mathdino]

VOTE: Slimer

Looks like he's trying to fluff his way through.

What're your current reads on Howl and wgeurts?

[Alchemist21]

Howl is null.

Wgeurts is null-town. If he doesn't care much for RVS I can see his freakout about the Howl wagon coming from a Town perspective, but I would expect him to know that this group of players likes to build early pressure wagons.

[theslimer3]

Honestly no I don't have any reads yet. Though it's fun to watch. I'll keep my presence maximum so I can get tryed and become apart of this game officially

[Alchemist21]

Anything you agree/disagree with even if you don't have reads?

[2birds1stone]

Anyone who wants to dig up a game to meta-clear themself over a single vote five pages into a game is far too defensive to be town.

VOTE: Slimer

Looks like he's trying to fluff his way through.

I actually played on a scumteam with slime once (as the spectacularly annoying Terrance and Phillip hydra with AcRv), and I don't recall this being slime's playstyle, though it was a long time ago.

[Anatole Kuragin]

Vote Count 1.5

Wgeurts (5) (L-2): Riddleton, mathdino, Howl, Albert B. Rampage, texcat
Alchemist21 (1): 2birds1stone
Albert B. Rampage (1): Wgeurts
Texcat (2): Bicephalous Bob, Randomidget
Riddleton (1): Droog
theslimer3 (1): Alchemist21

Not voting (1): theslimer3

Deadline: (expired on 2014-12-24 14:55:00)

[Alchemist21]

Anyone who wants to dig up a game to meta-clear themself over a single vote five pages into a game is far too defensive to be town.

VOTE: Slimer

Looks like he's trying to fluff his way through.

I actually played on a scumteam with slime once (as the spectacularly annoying Terrance and Phillip hydra with AcRv), and I don't recall this being slime's playstyle, though it was a long time ago.

Right. It's totally overdefensive for me to bring up a recent town game of mine to show you why what I did wasn't scummy, but it's completely fine for you to bring up one old game with another player to defend them.

[Riddleton]

Droog, you don't like my case. OK, but how does that make me scum? I still stand by it; I think you're misinterpreting some of the points I made.

VOTE: ABR
I know thy ways.

Is this a random vote? Not sure if thou hath evolved but I recall a lot of talk of thou disliking RVS.

'tis RVS.
Also wherefore's howl being destroyed for a RV?

This is fine, except how he gets defensive when MathDino questions him not liking RVS. His defensive "But 'tis RVS" responce is trying to posture his vote as valid as if it was handed down from above.

dino: "a or b?"
wgeurts: "a"
riddleton: "look at that posturing! "

Saying "tis RVS" in a semi-casual way like that after your meta of disliking RVS has been called out is scummy behaviour.

The point hither is his vote was

perfectly acceptable

but the excessive justification of a silky RVS vote is very scummy behaviour.

excessive justification?
am i in the wrong game?
did i hang left at some parallel universe where wgeurts explained his vote in more three words?

RVS votes don't

need

be justified usually. The fact that Wgeurts tries to do this -- by explaining "oh yes it's RVS! Cool, isn't it?" and by defending someone's elses RVS vote as valid also -- is unexpected defensive behaviour. I tend to associate this defensive behaviour as scum, because that's what it is most of the time.

b) His continues to defend the Howl wagon by analysing everyone's prayers on it in the Post 57 wall.

wgeurts defends a wagon by saying someone on the wagon is scum????

Yes. He said BB's vote is "null" despite being acceptable RVS (ie, acceptable, good, town =/= "null"). He then called people scummier and scummier the later they were on the wagon, which isn't a coincidence to me.

[Bicephalous Bob]

ugh

[Bicephalous Bob]

eh

VOTE: midget

first post scum joke

[Mathdino]

^

What does everyone think of this vote?

[Bicephalous Bob]

I like it!

[texcat]

meh I think it's fine as a pressure vote. RandomMidget has only posted twice, and one of those was just a promise to post more today.

[wgeurts]

Mathdino is an innocent child.

Well that is sort of terrible.

Riddleton is fun to play with, this just means he'll die very quickly.

Mathdino, not Riddleton. But you're fun to play with too lol. Plus Mathdino is easy to read.

Vote: howl

Unvote, vote wgeurts

wgeurts is sort of annoying to be honest, and given his posts in this game I'm highly comfortable with my vote him.

This is the worst of the three, there is a scum between ABR/Alch/2B1S. He is the wprst of the three.
VOTE: 2birds

This quote in particular is surprisingly bad.

Because it was posted on page 3.

Because it was posted on page 3.

You're based on page 3

What?

Why ABR is a better vote than me

• The case on me is absolute conspiracy crap.
  
• His first 3 posts are only fluff.
  
• He's wagon hopped onto howl and me with
  naked votes
  .
  
• He did this as traitor in the other stack the deck.
  
• His reasons for voting me is "He's annoying" and he's refrained from actually explaining these "bad posts".
  
• All the other posts are fluff. Seriously ignore slimer, he's got like 1 or 2 fluff posts ABR's ISO consists of nearly only fluff posts

[wgeurts]

Accidentally quoted his whole ISO...
A well, helps prove my points.

[Mathdino]

UNVOTE: wgeurts

VOTE: 2birds

[Albert B. Rampage]

Accidentally quoted his whole ISO...
A well, helps prove my points.

You try too hard at being too confident too early. You're jumpy and self-conscious. That sums up what I have to say about you in a nice little bundle.

[Anatole Kuragin]

Bump